Tuesday, 10 February 2009

The Asians Are Drinking All The Scotch!

We have spent a considerable amount time on this blog defending the merits of globalization in general and free trade in particular. One of the key selling points of opening up trade relations is that consumers get access to more variety and cheaper products. You would need only to compare the variety of cuisine offered in major cities like London, Beijing and Tokyo to what it was 30 years ago for a vivid illustration of this change.

Globalization has also produced some interesting effects on markets for alcoholic beverages. For instance, I enjoy quizzing Guinness drinkers on which country consumes the most of Ireland's famous black liquor. They are usually surprised to learn that Nigeria has taken over the largest share of the Guinness market, with more sales than either Ireland or the UK. In fact, a reliable source suggests that Africa accounts for 40% of Guinness' brew and sales.

So globalized markets are great for beer connoisseurs in Africa. However, I'm sorry to say that there are limits to the globalization of alcoholic beverages, and we've reached them. The line has been crossed. If this trend is not corrected, then I'm leaving the globalization fan club. I'll be handing in my members mug and hoisting a poorly-designed placard, donning my gas mask and joining an anti-globalization rally somewhere. Because, you see, this morning I learned that the Asians are drinking all the scotch.

I was in the liquor store inquiring about why a certain bottle of single malt was no longer being carried, and was it possible for it to be ordered. Following a Q & A, I learned that, despite being one of the largest purchasers of alcoholic beverages in the world, my government-monopoly-owned liquor store is losing its market share of single malt scotch to Asia. Not only has the selection declined, but the prices of the remaining scotches is going up. Indeed, I have watched in horror as the price of one particular bottle - Lagavulin - has increased 25% over the past 6 months. The same trend repeats itself across the shelf, although in varying degrees.

There are some basic economic factors at play here. First, demand in Asia is waaaay up. So much so that suppliers are having a difficult time keeping up with their orders. The high-growth markets are the BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China) as well as Singapore, South Korea and other smaller markets. Furthermore, I was told by the manager of the aforementioned liquor store that the profit margins are higher in East Asia when compared to the more mature markets of North America - this, despite the fact that they need to ship the booze further and that Asian consumers are less-wealthy, as a group. I wonder if the lack of competition helps as well: in North America, (Scottish) scotch has to compete with Irish whiskey, Canadian whiskey, bourbon and similar products. I doubt the same is true of South Korea.

Thus, by harnessing some of the benefits of globalization, major emerging markets have grown wealthy and have begun importing products on which to spend that wealth. The effect, perversely, is that the globalization of markets has actually made products in my part of the world both less available and more expensive.

A few more points are worth pondering:

- First, is this trend going to repeat itself with other luxury goods like Persian rugs, French wine and German cars?

- Second, given the way things are going lately, this trend makes distilling scotch one of the few areas of UK business where things are looking good (that, and bankruptcy law). In fact, several new distilleries have been built to deal with the surge in demand. Will these new distilleries be able to ride the wave long enough to compete with more established brands? The Asian Generation of single malts, perhaps.

- A final, and related, point is that Asia is set to be very hard hit by the fallout from the current financial turmoil. Will that curb their enthusiasm for delicious scotch? It's reasonable to suspect that it will, but only temporarily. As Frank the Tank put it so eloquently: "Once it touches your lips..."

Monday, 9 February 2009

Quick hits and pink picks

-Robert Mugabe declares, "Let them eat cake!"

-Ukraine has all but abandoned compliance with the conditions of its $16.5bn IMF standby facility. According to the FT, Ukraine has sent letters to a number of countries (US, Russia, China, EU, Japan) requesting emergency loans to plug a revenue shortfall. Kiev's unwillingness to balance the 2009 budget and cut deficit spending alarmed an IMF delegation last week, who warned of "serious problems" in Ukraine's economy. It is unclear how this visit will affect further disbursements of IMF funds.

-In a VoxEu article, Jeffry Frieden looks at the difficult balancing act policymakers must navigate in building domestic support for international cooperation in response to the worsening economic crisis.

-Ahead of the Treasury Secretary's official announcement tomorrow, the NYT is reporting that Timothy Geithner prevailed over top administration aids calling for stricter conditions in the second banking bailout. Geithner was reportedly concerned that too much government intervention would discourage private investors from participating and increase the cost to taxpayers in the long run.

-Jonah Lehrer at the great science blog The Frontal Cortex asks: why can't Federer beat Nadal? Conventional wisdom is that tennis is a young man's game and 28 is the apex of every great career. As Federer hits that wall (he turns 28 in August), his decline is all but inevitable. But Lehrer points to the post-30 performance of great athletes in sports like basketball or track and field as proof that the body doesn't necessarily decay in our late 20's. So what's unique about tennis? Lehrer echoes my own observation following Federer's post-Aussie tear fest: its mental.

So what happens to tennis stars? Why can Federer no longer defeat Nadal? I'm guessing performance anxiety. I think tennis, perhaps more than any other sport, is a game of self-confidence. Unforced errors are inevitable - the margin for error when hitting a ball that fast with a metal racket is simply too small. The question is how you deal with these mistakes. Players with swagger - say, the Federer of 2006-2007 or the Nadal of now - brush off their errors and come back with an ace. With age, however, comes the nagging tremors of self-doubt. When I watch the Federer of 2009 I see a player who no longer knows he's the best - his face occasionally betrays anxiety and insecurity. The end result is a dangerous form of self-consciousness, as Federer starts thinking too much about his serve, or that backhand whip shot, or his forehand down the line. Why aren't his shots going in? Why is his serve 5 mph slower? Why can't he beat this annoying young Spaniard in the capri pants?

The problem with such reflections is that tennis needs to be played on auto-pilot. Once you start thinking about your shots - and I think Federer is especially self-conscious when playing against Nadal - you lose the necessary fluidity and grace. These deliberate thoughts - the by-product of age-related insecurity - interfere with the trained movements of our muscles, so that we start regressing on the court. When players worry about not hitting a shot in, they're bound to hit it out. Federer doesn't need a new trainer: he needs a shrink.

Saturday, 7 February 2009

That Was The Week That Was

Politique
-US Vice President Joe Biden outlined the foreign policy vision of the young Obama administration in a speech at Munich. He called for a "reset" of US-Russian relations, offered Iran "meaningful incentives" to abandon its nuclear program, and called on America's allies (i.e. Europe/NATO) to shoulder a greater burden in security (Afghanistan, Guantanamo detainees). The speech comes days after Kyrgyzstan, under Kremlin pressure, announced it would close an American military base of great strategic importance. Russia embraced the "reset" concept.

-The US Senate reached a tentative deal on a $827 trillion stimulus package. After fierce political debate that all but shattered Obama's "post-partisan age", the Democrats appear to have picked off three Republican votes by cutting direct aid to states and localities and increasing the percentage of tax incentives in the bill (the bill cuts the size of the so-called 'middle-class tax cut' while increasing incentives to purchase homes and cars). Congress must now reconcile the House and Senate bills before a final package can be sent to Obama's desk.

-Morgan Tsvangirai returned to Zimbabwe to form a coalition government with Robert Mugabe. The president will sign a constitutional amendment allowing Tsvangirai to become prime minister, while a judge threw out treason charges against an important MDC figure.

-Abdul Qadeer Kahn, father of Pakistan's nuclear bomb and prolific nuclear proliferator, was freed from house arrest after 5 years. France and the US immediately criticized the move.

Economia
-The US unemployment rate hit 7.6% and GDP plummeted 3.6% in Q4 2008. According to The Economist, the fall would have been over 5% if not for a sharp rise in inventories. Elsewhere, German industrial output fell by a record 4.6% in December.

-The BoE cut rates to 1%, while the ECB held steady once again.

-Obama imposed a cap on executive compensation at companies receiving "exceptional assistance" from the US government. Politics 101: if you want to appeal to public anger, but have little intention of widely enforcing a rule, insert a vague definition like "exceptional assistance."

-The rouble floor announced by the Russian central bank was tested this week; traders are betting the floor was set too high; oil price and capital flows volatility will continue to weigh on the currency.

The Rest
-In the Prem, Torres fires Liverpool top of the table (for now), Chelsea are in free fall (bye bye Big Phil?), and Arsenal just suck. In Italy, Milan's initial formal offer for Becks was rejected outright by LA Galaxy.

-French street artist JR brought his "28 millimetres: Women" project to Kibera, Kenya. The artist imposes facial images on homes and buildings, providing an identity and voice to the women of one of Africa's largest slums.

-Over 84 people have been killed in Australia's deadliest fire disaster. The state of Victoria has been ravaged by the bushfires, fueled by a prolonged drought and soaring temperatures.

-Scientists have identified a key protein in the process by which the H5N1 virus replicates itself. It is hoped that the discovery will lead to more effective drugs to combat the virus. Egypt confirmed its second human case this year, while both Hong Kong and Vietnam announced new cases in birds.

Friday, 6 February 2009

Broken Glass, Everywhere

And here I was thinking I was clever by quoting Frédéric Bastiat last week. Since then, I've been tripping over his name in articles debating this or that policy measure - and no surprise, as the man is great for a quote.

But here's a Wiki-article worth reading: Bastiat's parable of the broken window. It's a helpful story for anyone who'se feeling over-stimulated by the stimulus debate.

Also Greg Mankiw reports on a modern-day example of the broken window fallacy literally put into action.

The Debate Continues...

...on protectionism. First off we have the indefatiguable free-trade defender Jagdish Bhagwati who is, well, defending free trade. Even if the US enacted measures that were WTO-consistent, Bhagwati points out that other countries could do the same:

Nothing would prevent India and China from choosing to raise tariffs thus on items of export interest to the US. Besides, they could shift their own purchases of aircraft away from Boeing to Airbus, and of nuclear reactors from American to French companies. The response would, of course, be for the enraged US congressmen to start enacting their own retaliation. The game would become lively.

In the interest of balance, I point you to a column by Oxfam's Duncan Green that argues that protectionism is not all bad, particularly for developing countries. I had the pleasure of having Duncan give a guest lecture in one of my graduate school classes - he offered a refreshingly blunt assessment of what it was like to work for an NGO, both good and bad.

As far as his argument goes, I think he's in good intellectual company when he points out that the poorest developing countries may need trade barriers to help them escape from a poverty trap. I think the well-respected development economist Paul Collier argues as much in The Bottom Billion. To be fair, however, we've been focusing our criticism on the Buy America, Buy China and Buy India type policies enacted by members of the G20. For these countries, at least, Duncan thinks protectionism is a rotten idea.

...and on fiscal stimulus. There's no end to the material provided by all sides of this lively discussion, but I particularly enjoyed this sarcastic op-ed by Benn Steil:

Citing Keynes gives us special licence to talk economics without using any. To paraphrase the lawyers’ dictum, when the facts are on our side, we pound the facts; when theory is on our side, we pound theory; and when neither the facts nor theory are on our side, we pound Keynes – and to great effect.

I think that Keynes is right when it comes to the need compensate for market downturns through active policy measures, rather than simply waiting things out, and Stein takes Keynes' quote about how "in the long run we are dead" out of context. But his target is not so much some long-dead economist but rather the people who are inclined to use the name of some long-dead economist as justification for spending our money. Just because there is a clear need to "do something" significant doesn't mean our legislators should be given a free reign. With huge stimulus packages being proposed by almost every major Western government, it has become more important than ever to ensure that the money is A) being spent on what's being promised, B) having the effect that's promised, and C) not mortgaging our financial future in the process.

Easier said than done.

Update: Brad DeLong retorts to the Steil piece.

Thursday, 5 February 2009

Should All Students Learn Economics? Part II

In an earlier post I looked at a report suggesting that American youth were woefully under-educated when it comes to dealing with their personal finances. With only 21% paying off their monthly credit card bills, today's young consumers could probably benefit from a better understanding of debt and credit. But does that apply to economics more generally?

Broadly speaking, it certainly wouldn't hurt to have a more educated populace. While we're at it, it would be great if people knew advanced biology, another language and could play an instrument. But there are opportunity costs to learning these things, so the question becomes: is this important enough to include macro & micro economics in the core curriculum of secondary schools and universities? The report argues that it is.

I think a case can be made for the importance of certain economic principles. The idea of an opportunity cost, already mentioned in this post, is helpful when making decisions. Similarly, the basics of sunk costs, supply & demand, savings & investment, operating at the margin, taxation, etc, are all very relevant concepts in day-to-day life. One particularly topical issue is that of comparative advantage: the idea that Country A can be better off specializing in the production of beer and trading it to Country B for pizza, even when it can produce both beer & pizza more efficiently than Country B. I've heard econ profs talk about how it's always a real challenge to teach such a counter-intuitive idea to first-year students, and yet that's the fundamental principle behind free trade. Maybe if more people understood how comparative advantage works, "Buy America" provisions would be less popular. Maybe.

But there are other issues to consider. Take the example of the humanities (philosophy, theology, literature, classics). My own public school upbringing left me pretty under-exposed to most of these fields. I feel as though, if I had been attending Eton or Harrow in the late 19th Century, maybe I wouldn't be having to play "catch-up" on basic philosophy in my spare time. But if everyone got a more thorough training in the humanities, maybe we would have fewer people inclined to take up a trade or a job requiring hard labour. In other words, there might be unanticipated costs for more education. The same might be true for economics.

Let me put it another way. A quote from the report reads:

The study found that only 16 percent of Americans could differentiate free markets from central government planning. Less than 30 percent of those surveyed understood the relationship between taxes and government spending, and less than 40 percent knew what sort of fiscal policy would produce economic stimulus.
I agree that this represents a bit of a problem, but the joke of it is, I'm pretty sure less than 40 percent of PhD-trained economists know what sort of fiscal policy would produce economic stimulus. So is society better off if we have more plumbers or more economists? (I apologize to any humanist plumbers with economics training for my over-generalizations).

So to summarize, I think it would be helpful if people had more familiarity with some of the basic principles of economics - the ability, even in passing, to do what my 2nd year econ prof referred to as "putting on one's economic glasses." But those glasses have a very distinct way of looking at the world and it's very important to be able to take them off now and again. At the very least, if we're going to invest time and energy in educating our youth on our socio-political history and institutions (Civics class) then this should be complemented by an understanding of our economic institutions and how the two sets interact. But beyond that, it's not clear to me that economics is something that is so necessary as to be part of the core curriculum. Any thoughts?

(Photo: Financial Sense)

Wednesday, 4 February 2009

Really, Davos Man? Really?

Its not easy being Davos Man. Last year's master of the universe is this year's public enemy #1. Breaking the financial architecture, plunging the world into depression, mega-bonuses and ornate office furniture amid rising unemployment and home foreclosures; that's a lot to live down. Its no wonder the mood was so dismal on Mount Olympus last week.

But the irony is that while Davos Man broke the system, we rely on him to repair it. Thus, while the World Economic Forum may have failed to map the "post-crisis world", we can all take solace in knowing that Davos Man's personal transformation has begun; he shares your sacrifice, he feels your pain, he too is, um, homeless. Via FP Passport...I give you Refugee Run.












Really, Davos Man? Really?

Should All Students Learn Economics? Part I

That's the question being asked in this report by Maurice Black and Erin O'Connor over at Minding the Campus. Actually, the title is misleading since they are really asking two questions, one focused on knowledge of personal finances (debt, credit, investment, risk) and the other on knowledge of basic economic principles. They are related, but distinct, so I think it's worth looking at them separately.

I think answering the first part is easy: yes, we should spend more time teaching youth the basics of personal finance. As the report points out, a large - and growing - chunk of [American] children make use of debit and credit cards, but few have a strong grasp of concepts like credit risk, interest rates and so on. One paragraph reads:

...more than half of all high-school seniors do not realize that paying off a credit card balance more slowly will result in higher finance charges. Only one in three teens knows how to read a bank statement, balance a checkbook, or pay a bill. In short, young adults have ready access to finance, but not to education about finance.
That's discouraging, particularly in light of how we've seen the consequences of consumers in Anglo-American economies taking on completely unsustainable levels of personal debt. Now, society as a whole might be better off if we were better educated in plenty of areas - a basic understanding of, say, automechanics and carpentry. But those are fields that can be safely contracted out to specialists; personal finance is an area that has the potential for more wide-ranging costs and benefits.

I would put it in the same category as health and sexual education: the more aware you are of the basic facts, the more informed your decisions will be and people around you will benefit. For instance, perhaps more education on the basics of infectious disease will lead to more people getting vaccinated - that's a public good. Similarly, it's become clear that poor finance has contagious effects as well.

This is one reason why I think high school math courses should place greater emphasis on teaching risk and probability. In my personal experience, once you moved past basic math courses you were offered Algebra & Geometry, Calculus and other high-level material. But very few of our daily decisions require an understanding of calculus. By contrast, a great deal of them require some basic assessments on risk, probabilities and returns: everything from card games to deciding whether to go back to school, from buying a stock to starting your own business, right down to family planning.

Moreover, psychologists have plenty of experimental evidence suggesting that, as a species, we are very poor at guaging probabilities and risks: we tend to discount high-probability events like heart disease, but focus on low-probability, attention-grabbing events like airplane crashes. So we need all the help we can get. For the topic at hand, a basic understanding of risk and probability might help some people realize that they need more diversity in their financial portfolio than that which is provided by a 401(k), or something similar.

So for me, a stronger emphasis on the basics of personal finances in school would be an excellent idea. However, I'm not sure the case is so clear for the study of economics more generally - but I'll look at that next. In the meantime, does anyone have suggestions for other areas we could beef up on when it comes to secondary and higher education? Comment away.

Monday, 2 February 2009

Finally, someone in charge unequivocally denounces "Buy America(n)"

From Dallas Federal Reserve President Richard Fischer:

"Let me just be blunt. Protectionism is the crack cocaine of economics. It may provide a high. It's addictive and it leads to economic death"

Editor's note: the provision in question has been alternately referred to as "Buy America" or "Buy American." I started using "Buy America" because Reuters (the source of my initial post on the provision) does. However, it seems "Buy American" is more widely used.

Legendary journalist William Safire has a weekly column in the New York Times Sunday Magazine called, "On Language", in which he explores the origins, meanings, and uses of popular words or phrases. I think the "Buy America"/"Buy American" distinction would be an interesting case. While the essence is the same, does the addition of the 'n' alter the implied scope or meaning in some subtle way? Sadly, I can't answer that.

Quick hits and pink picks

-According to the FT, over 20 million rural migrant workers have lost their jobs in China as a result of the global economic crisis, stoking party fears of social instability. The actual figure may be much higher; the initial number doesn't account for the workers who've remained in eastern cities.
-As first reported by The Cable last week, the US has been engaged in high level, "Track Two" discussions with Iran for the better part of a year, intensifying in recent months and including a number of individuals close to the Obama administration. The Iranian side has been led by Ali Asghar Soltanieh, ambassador and permanent representative to the IAEA. The talks have been conducted in European cities under the auspices of the Pugwash group. As The Cable notes, back channel talks have always occurred between the two nations (irrespective of public posturing), but these talks are significant in their attendance, timing, and frequency. While the nuclear issue is obviously the most pressing, talks have also focused on "how to move beyond the 1953 coup and 1979 revolution." This strikes me as a recognition by both sides that a window exists for a fundamental transformation of the relationship.

-Political violence is on the rise in South Africa. A string of high profile assassinations in Kwa-Zulu Natal reflect rising tensions in the province between ANC and IFP supporters. Meanwhile, Cope (the party formed out of the ANC split last year) leader Mosiuoa “Terror” Lekota issued his strongest criticism yet of the ANC and Zuma, claiming the party will push through immunity for the presidential favorite after the coming general election.

-Davos utterly failed its agenda: "shaping the post-crisis world". Chris Giles, Peter Thal Larsen, and Gillian Tett of the FT found the attendees united in their lack of confidence and inspiration.

Monday Morning Round-Up: UK Frozen Assets & more

- Oh how I wish I wish this had happened while I was living in London: the heaviest snowfall in almost two decades has hit the UK capital. I've always wondered how the City workers would react to snowfall and now we've found out: they take a "snow day" - to the cost of about 1 billion pounds. (Here's a slideshow, and more funny)

- Anti-protectionist writing continues to pour out of the economic blogosphere. You can find a writer at Free Exchange dismantling the populist argument here; the Davos crowd is understandably nervous, and Willem Buiter is his usual, uncompromising self. A sample:
If anything like the Buy American clause inserted by the House survives in the bill president Obama gets on his desk, he must veto it. The questionable value of the fiscal stimulus is overwhelmed by the unquestionable domestic and global harm caused by the Buy American clause. If president Obama fails to veto a protectionism-laced bill, it will be clear that we have a wuss in the White House.

- China's manufacturing sector contracted for the sixth consecutive month in January. But in fact the trend is much wider than that, and much worse. Cue the trade war.

Sunday, 1 February 2009

That Was The Week That Was

Politique
-As the financial crisis rolls on, the next phase of government (re)action is developing: US House approves an $819bn stimulus package (with a certain provision we don't like very much) and the FT reports that Obama will unveil a "Big Bang" package of banking/financial/housing reforms this week (now next), Harper's minority government unveils a federal budget that includes the country's first fiscal deficit in over a decade, Merkel has reportedly settled on a plan to create government-backed "bad bank" vehicles to clean up balance sheets, and Aso unveiled his own stimulus package under considerable opposition (he also pledged $17bn in aid to other Asian nations).

-62% of Bolivian voters approved a new constitution in last Sunday's referendum. The new constitution increases the government's control over strategic industries (including natural resources), strengthens indigenous rights, and furthers land reform. Despite the popular majority, 4 of the country's 9 provinces voted against the changes.

-North Korea voided all political and military agreements with the South this week, as mounting tensions on the Korean peninsula threaten all out military conflict. While Kim's motivation is unclear, a few theories seem plausible: 1) he is pushing his way onto Obama's agenda, 2) he is provoking an international crisis to stem any internal revolt amid his ailing health, 3) he has lost control and hardliners are their authority over foreign policy.

-Social and political instability is spreading across Europe: Iceland's government fell, massive strikes paralyzed France, and British workers walked off the job to protest the use of foreign workers amid rising British unemployment. Nationalism, protectionism, and industrial action are all on the rise.

-Iraqis voted in provincial elections. Despite a lower than hoped turnout, the elections were peaceful.

Economia
-The IMF reduced its global GDP forecast for 2009 to 0.5%, and the global economy shed over 70,000 jobs in one day.

-Sterling had a small recovery this week on a slight confidence jump in UK banks, the Euro slipped amid eurozone economic weakness and lack of faith in the ECB, and the USD and Yen both endured "rollercoaster" weeks.

-Exxon Mobile reported record earnings for the 4th quarter. The Lex column in the FT praised the company for "generating free cash flows as others invested" during the good times, positioning itself to pick off rivals and acquire assets in the bad. This conservatism has acted as a hedge against the rapid fall in prices.

The Rest
-In the Prem, ManU go 2 clear with 1 in hand, Liverpool score 2 late to take all 3 from a 10-man Chelsea, and Arsenal throw up a big 0 at home against West Ham. Elsewhere, Becks scores his second for Milan as speculation mounts over his return to LA.

-In tennis, Nadal beat Federer in 5 for the Australian Open title. Rafa's performance was simply incredible, coming less than 48 hours after his Australian open record 5 hour, 14 minute semifinal match against fellow Spaniard Fernando Verdasco. Many took Federer's uncontrollable tears in the post-match ceremony as a sign that even the Swiss great doubted his ability to ever beat Nadal again in a major final and catch Sampras' record 14 major titles.

-In Olympic swimming, Oops!

-While much of the fashion world has been tailoring collections to reflect our dark economic times, these designers look to color.

-Move over Highlander, meet Turritopsis nutricula: immortal jellyfish.