Tuesday, 30 September 2008

Politics and the Paulson Plan: a rant

I was strongly considering not commenting on yesterday's news that the US House of Representatives rejected the Paulson TARP proposal - it has already been disected by anyone and everyone with access to a soap box - but I've changed my mind.

Despite the heaping pile of unknowns, several points seem clear to me. First, everyone can find something to dislike about the piece of legislature that died on the floor yesterday. Second, it was generally understood that the TARP was not going to be the singular cure to the ills in the housing and money markets.

Third, the "blame" for failing to adopt the plan can be shared all around. More Dems voted 'yay' than 'nay,' but Nancy Pelosi still failed to rally 1/3 of her troops and was evidently guilty of trying to ram the bill through knowing full well that most of the Republicans were not ready to accept it. Meanwhile, half of the Republicans voted 'no,' killing the plan and prompting markets to jump into the abyss.

Finger-pointing aside, what irked me most was the language used by certain members of the Republican party to justify their vote against the bill. We heard that this bailout was going to place us on the slippery slope to socialism (re: communism). We heard that the already borderline socialistic White House was now proposing Hugo Chavezesque solutions to economic difficulties. We heard much, much more.

This is infuriating because it is inflammatory, hypocritical, and quite simply wrong. In no way do such comments from the political leadership move the debate forward or help the American economy. Furthermore, as Jonah Goldberg argues, "Only now, when capitalism is in flames, does this fire brigade try to enforce the free-market fire codes without compromise." It's also wrong to suggest that Hank Paulson and Ben Bernanke are doing anything other than trying to find a solution that will allow American capitalism to thrive and for them to return to their respective day-jobs of guiding US fiscal and monetary policy.

A brief history lesson for the die-hard free-marketeers: it was the abominable living conditions of the Industrial Revolution which led Karl Marx to develop his theories; it was the Great Depression which fuelled the rise of fascism and communism and drove America and Europe to the adopt post-war government social programs which you so heavily criticize. Only when capitalism is healthy and regular citizens feel that they too can become rich does the American dream of free markets and individual liberty thrive.

So Congress has told Wall Street to drop dead. Fine. This is not the end of the world. But as I discussed below, the conventional wisdom has no place in unconventional times. When the politicians reconvene on Thursday, I sincerely hope that they leave their ideological baggage at the door.

Monday, 29 September 2008

The Week Ahead

Last week I speculated about the possible market reaction to the promise of a massive government injection through the Paulson Plan. So far, that reaction has been something akin to a spoiled child who, having been promised a treat, throws a tantrum when it doesn't arrive now now now!

There are two sentences that I will be keeping in mind as I continue to watch these events unfold over the course of the next couple of weeks. The first comes from J. K. Galbraith, who wrote in The Affluent Society that "In areas of large economic affairs, the march of events... has again left the conventional wisdom sadly obsolete." Although Galbraith penned this line in the late 1950s and was referring to something completely different, I think it's fair to say that the march of events continues uninterrupted, dislodging a lot of comfortably-held beliefs along the way.

Over the weekend, presumably exhausted negotiators reached a tentative agreement to buy up $700 billion in "troubled assets." The plan - which ballooned from 3 pages to 110 - also includes possible restrictions on pay for CEOs of firms who make use of the plan, as well as warrants (convertible into non-voting stock) for the government. The notion that the government could place restrictions on the pay of Wall St. executives is antithetical to the entire spirit of American capitalism, and represents a pretty enormous shift away from the conventional wisdom.

Meanwhile, over in the UK, Bradford & Bingley - a troubled mortgage lender - has been nationalized by the government. Whereas the nationalization of Northern Rock last fall made a big splash, it's unlikely that this B&B deal will dominate headlines for long.

That being said, not everyone has given up faith in the markets. If nothing else, this article in the Washington Post is a refreshing change from the usual headlines. It points out that small banks in America are weathering the storm quite nicely - in fact, their lending has actually increased. Alex Tabarrok, who references the above WaPo article, also makes a couple of other points worth reading (I consider Alex's own plan below).

The second sentence that caught my eye this week came from Barry Eichengreen, a Berkely economic historian and prolific writer. Adjusted somewhat, Barry points out that "Watchers tend to internalize the views of the watched." I thought that was interesting, because there's no doubt that the "watched" right now include first and foremost Henry Paulson and Ben Bernanke. Those two spent their week warning of impending financial meltdown. This, in turn, has been the story carried all week by the media. Because of the authority these two gentlemen command, I think it's fair to say that us "watchers" have mostly been convinced that the conventional wisdom is no longer viable. Whether this is actually true or not remains to be seen.

Moving on. Other upcoming events this week:
  • Speaking of the behaviour of spoiled children, North Korea continues to move towards reinstating its nuclear processing plant in Yongbyon.
  • Despite the power-sharing deal signed on September 15, Zimbabwe's leaders will continue to struggle this week to resolve the crisis of government.
  • The Economist is reporting that "Russian warships set off to Latin America to take part in joint manoeuvres with Venezuela, for the first time since the cold war." (no link)
  • Market gloominess will continue to impact the economy in various ways: oil drops below $103; East Asian markets are unimpressed.
  • Arsenal is looking to rebound after a poor showing over the weekend: they play Porto in the Champions League on Tuesday.
Enjoy your week!

Saturday, 27 September 2008

That Was The Week That Was

Politique
-US Congress debates $700 billion "Paulson plan". House Republicans opposed on principle and politics. Having lost his party, Bush's quacking becomes deafening.

-South African President Thabo Mbeki resigns after being pushed out by ANC leadership. ANC deputy president Motlanthe assumes caretaker presidency until likely election of Jacob Zuma next year. Markets initially panic following Trevor Manuel resignation, stabilize on his backtracking.

-Suicide bombing kills 53 people and wounds over 200 at Marriott Hotel in Islamabad. Occurs amid rising tensions between US and Pakistan over US military incursions into Pakistani territory. Reports indicate that the two sides have exchanged fire in recent days.

-Barack Obama and John McCain hold first presidential debate in Oxford, Mississippi. Latest polls...

Economia
-Washington Mutual fails. It is the largest bank failure in US history. JPMorgan quickly buys assets, affirms status as Wall Street's only shining light. Bradford & Bingley, UK's largest mortgage lender, expected to be nationalized on Sunday.

-FBI reportedly conducting formal investigation into 26 cases (including Fannie, Freddie, Lehman, and AIG) of possible fraud related to collapse of US mortgage industry.

-Survey/data indicate the Eurozone has fallen into recession.

-Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley transform themselves into "bank holding companies", marking the death of the broker-dealer model. Banks submit themselves to significantly greater regulation in order to survive independently.

The Rest
-Paul Newman, iconic American actor and philanthropist, dies at 83 in Connecticut.

-Zhai Zhigang becomes first Chinese man to walk in space.

-New York City's Yankee Stadium hosts final game. New York Yankees baseball team is vacating 85 year-old "house that Ruth built" for new $1.6 billion stadium across the street.

-Bruno invades Milan's Fashion Week.

Friday, 26 September 2008

I, Master

While the financial gods are down on one knee, and institutions continue to fail, one man stands tall: Jamie Dimon.

The JPMorgan chief is THE master of the universe.

(Photo: Reuters)

On South Africa and the ANC

On Monday morning, it seemed as if the long leadership/personal battle between ANC factions had been settled. South Africa's dominant political party, led by supporters of Jacob Zuma, succeeded in forcing the resignation of President Thabo Mbeki, the man who has run the country since Nelson Mandela left office in 1999. Jacob Zuma would almost certainly assume the presidency in 2009, after a brief care-taker run by Kgalema Motlanthe, deputy leader of the ANC and Zuma loyalist.

By Tuesday afternoon, the country was in the midst of a full-scale political crisis (and possibly on the brink of a financial crisis). 14 ministers resigned over the manner of Mbeki's ousting, including Trevor Manuel, the world-respected finance minister who is widely credited with South Africa's macroeconomic success. So spooked were the markets by Manuel's reported departure, that the Rand sank 3% in less than an hour. When Manuel's press secretary publicly stated his willingness to serve on, the Rand bounced back. But the shock of his departure illustrated just how unstable South Africa's macro success is. It also signalled a period of political instability in Africa's largest economy.

The ANC has dominated South Africa's political scene since the fall of apartheid. Under Mbeki's leadership (which to many extends back well into Mandela's presidency- Mbeki essentially ran the economy as Mandela's deputy), the party embraced liberal macro policies and fiscal discipline. Manuel's stewardship of the economy isolated the influence of the trade unions and old revolutionary communists that dominate the ANC's rank and file, satisfying foreign investors and an emergent (but tiny) black middle class.

But Mbeki's ANC has always been an uneasy alliance. Zuma's resurgence has been driven by a revolt of sorts by the trade unions and rural base. He carries the torch for the old school ANC, concerned with equity and workers rights rather than macro stability and foreign capital. Mbeki and his liberal policies had become so detached/isolated within the ANC, that his ousting was probably inevitable. While he was playing peace-maker in Zimbabwe, Zuma loyalists were orchestrating his demise. Unless the legal proceedings against Zuma return with a sense of legitimacy, he will assume the presidency next year, and the party base will expect a return to the ideological roots of the revolutionary years.

Zuma will have to be attendant to the interests responsible for his rise to the presidency. They want greater spending (difficult given ZA's already troubling deficits and reliance on foreign capital), a renewed focus on jobs and equity (desperately needed), and the abandonment of an inflation-targeting monetary policy (potentially disastrous). But few doubt he will fully reverse Mbeki/Manuel's macroeconomic policies. Zuma himself has been at pains to assure foreign investors and business leaders of his commitment to austerity and monetary discipline.

The real risk to South Africa is a political split within the ANC. This is more likely than it was last fall, when the party seemed united behind Zuma. While woefully unpopular, Mbeki's ousting reeked of revenge and opportunism, and the resentment over this spread beyond the former president's allies. Archbishop Desmond Tutu (Nobel laureate and South Africa's moral authority) was widely quoted as warning, "The way of retribution leads to a banana republic". The mass resignation of ministers was largely protocol (and a show of loyalty to Mbeki), but the former president's allies are unlikely to passively fall in line behind Zuma.

More importantly, the ideological split that has festered beneath the surface of the ANC has now burst into the open. This may be harder to reconcile than old grudges.

Whatever the ultimate outcome of this leadership struggle, South Africa's post-apartheid stability is in real trouble.

Thursday, 25 September 2008

Linguistic Embranglement

Today's Globe had an interesting article on some English words that are on the linguistic chopping block for the next edition of the Collins English Dictionary. Forced to economize space and incorporate new vocab, the dictionary authorities have deemed these poor words under-utilized and unloved by modern language. In short, they will be exuviated.

My favourites are: muliebrity, oppugnant, and niddering. I challenge anyone to use a word off of that list during conversation tomorrow.

Also, isn't agrestic also the name of the suburb in the teevee show Weeds? I wonder if that's intentional irony. Either way, that must surely count for popular usage.

UPDATE: here's an interesting video of Ed Rondthaler that reveals the irrationality of the English language. The confusing nature of English is apodeictic, but I still think the sort of rational spelling he proposes would take some of the fun out of it all.

A Suspiciously Simple Supply-Side Solution (to the Credit Crunch)

Alliteration is fun! Alex Tabarrok proposes an alternative approach to dealing with the credit crunch at Marginal Revolution. First a recap for the uninitiated.

Briefly stated, the effect of the "credit crunch" is that banks/financial institutions are not lending money to other banks/financial institutions. Moreover, they aren't lending to firms, government organizations, individuals, etc... This means that all sorts of things - funding new enterprise, getting a new mortgage, getting a student loan - has become more difficult or impossible. In short, the financial gears that keep our economy running smoothly are grinding to a halt.

Why did this happen? Again, briefly stated, banks made mortgage loans to people with poor credit ratings (or people with poor credit history took on loans they couldn't afford, depending on how you look at it). These are the sub-prime mortgages. When the housing boom slowed, mortgage rates went up and many of these people defaulted on their payments. Some mortgage lenders went bankrupt and banks lost large sums of money.

Furthermore, banks used credit derivative "vehicles" that packaged sub-prime mortgages with higher-grade assets to spread the risk. These bundles of asset-backed securities were then sold on to other financial institutions. When the value of these securities came into question following the housing collapse, more losses and uncertainty ensued.

That's a painful oversimplification of things. But basically the double-shot of large write-downs and uncertainty about the value of assets has left credit markets dry. As Alex explains, banks are the bridge between savers and borrowers. Those bridges are now collapsing. The US Treasury plan is to prop up those teetering bridges; Alex's alternative solution is to encourage savings and thus increase the flow of credit across the bridges that are still structurally sound. He proposes a tax holiday on contributions to an Individual Retirement Account for a year, with the governenment matching a certain amount as well.

Cool idea, but I'm not sure that it will do the trick. The problem is, saving today means forgoing consumption today - that's bad news for an economy facing a recession. Also, as Keynes pointed out, it does not necessarily mean consumption later: uncertainty about the future economy means people may save to have liquidity (assets that are easily accessible/convertible to money) as insurance against economic misfortune. Money saved in liquid assets doesn't automatically increase demand for 'producible' goods that lead to more employment and a stronger economy. In other words: a penny saved does not equal a penny earned.

Also, if the real problem is uncertainty - financial institutions hoarding liquidity and refusing to lend to one another - it's really not clear how an increase in savings will help. Then again, Alex is infinitely more knowledgeable than I am, so I've probably missed something here.

(Photo courtesy of http://www.lewrockwell.com/)

Wednesday, 24 September 2008

McCain suspends campaign, requests debate postponement

US presidential candidate John McCain has just released a statement indicating that he will suspend his campaign tomorrow morning, and return to Washington for talks on the proposed financial bailout plan. He has called on Barack Obama to join him.

Bold leadership or shrewd stop-gap? Discuss...

Hank Paulson's Flawed Bail-Out

I was asked yesterday why, given the state of the US economy and looming prospect of credit markets becoming as liquid as the Arizona desert, the US Congress was not passing Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson's troubled asset relief program (TARP). Let me provide you with a taste of the answers to that question:

The Economist:
It could safeguard irresponsible bankers’ jobs, while doing little to stop troubled mortgage debtors from being thrown out of their homes. It seeks to invest massive power in a treasury secretary with a lifelong loyalty to Wall Street. The banks with the worst assets (ie, those which have made the worst decisions) could receive the most help. Most disturbing, the taxpayer will be funding an enormous, ill-defined programme, without any stipulation as yet that the banks who orchestrated the mess will pay a penalty.
Martin Wolf:
The fundamental problem with the Paulson scheme, as proposed, is then that it is neither a necessary nor an efficient solution. It is not necessary, because the Federal Reserve is able to manage illiquidity through its many lender-of-last resort operations. It is not efficient, because it can only deal with insolvency by buying bad assets at far above their true value, thereby guaranteeing big losses for taxpayers and providing an open-ended bail-out to the most irresponsible investors.
Luigi Zingales:
If banks and financial institutions find it difficult to recapitalize (i.e., issue new equity) it is because the private sector is uncertain about the value of the assets they have in their portfolio and does not want to overpay. Would the government be better in valuing those assets? No. In a negotiation between a government official and banker with a bonus at risk, who will have more clout in determining the price? The Paulson RTC will buy toxic assets at inflated prices thereby creating a charitable institution that provides welfare to the rich—at the taxpayers’ expense. If this subsidy is large enough, it will succeed in stopping the crisis. But again, at what price? The answer: Billions of dollars in taxpayer money and, even worse, the violation of the fundamental capitalist principle that she who reaps the gains also bears the losses.
24/7 Wall St:
What has become clear is that Treasury plans to purchase bad assets from banks at prices very near their original value. The risk to taxpayers under this program would be tremendous. If housing prices continue to fall, so will the value of the paper the government has purchased. Under this set of circumstances the public could be at risk for underwriting the great majority of the Treasury's purchases and never having a chance to recoup their investment.
Let me add my own two cents. Here's how Section 8 of the original proposal reads:
Decisions by the Secretary pursuant to the authority of this Act are non-reviewable and committed to agency discretion, and may not be reviewed by any court of law or any administrative agency.
Excuse me? This gives an enormous amount of discretionary power to the US Treasury and its boss. Given the sums of taxpayer's money involved, oversight is absolutely necessary. Paulson responds.

On a related note, does anyone else think Henry Paulson sounds like a professional wrestler?

Tuesday, 23 September 2008

The Conservative & Liberal Party Platforms: International Perspective, part I

(Another Update, Oct 3 - part II on the environment is here)
(Update, Sep 30 - An earlier version of this essay included a specific Tory promise on immigration that was incorrect and has been removed. The full Conservative platform has not yet been released. I'm using press releases, the 2006 platform, the 2007 throne speech, and the National Post article which lists all promises made thus far. It's all we've got, people).

The humble scribblers here at le Journale have made a conscious effort to avoid commenting on the ups and downs of election campaigns, but exceptions are made for issues relating directly to international political economy. Earlier, Rory took issue with the suggestion that a certain US VP candidate's lack of international experience was not a significant matter, or worse: an asset. He argued that it's simply not acceptable for the executive branch of government to be out of touch with global issues when so many of our greatest challenges don't respect national borders. Agreed.

Well, Jeffrey Simpson has pointed to a similar worrying trend up here in Canada: the current election campaign is proceeding along as if the rest of the world doesn't exist. Normally I would insert a self-depreciating joke about how the rest of the world doesn't know Canada exists, but this is patently untrue: Canada is regularly referenced as a model for immigration, health care, multiculturalism, internationalist foreign policy, environmental issues and the like. The sad part is, most of these stereotypes do not hold up well to scrutiny. Canada has one of the worst greenhouse gas emissions rates per capita, our foreign relations have been on a downward trend of late, as have our trading relations and levels of foreign aid. Meanwhile, with the effects of the American recession seeping across the border, the importance of attracting international investment and workers to maintain growth and innovation is more important than ever.

So, with that in mind, I'm going to dig into the policies of the two parties most likely to win the election - the ruling Conservative Party and the rival Liberal Party - to examine the future outlook for foreign countries, firms, and citizens who expect to be dealing with the Canadian government over the next few years. Today's themes will be immigration and trade.

Immigration
Canada's ability (and willingness) to attract foreign workers represents a huge economic advantage over the United States. The American H-1B temporary working visas are capped at 65,000 per year (!), which makes doing business in the United States considerably more challenging. This has led firms like Microsoft to re-locate north of the border. What are the two main political parties promising to do about immigration?

Conservatives: Quite frankly, not much. By and large, multiculturalism doesn't jive well with the Conservative's emphasis on 'Canadian values,' but to ignore the fact that immigration is a driving force in the competitiveness of the Canadian economy also doesn't fit with their message of economic responsibility.

Liberals: This party has always had a strong emphasis on attracting new immigrants and on the benefits of multiculturalism. Their promises include a new program to facilitate temp workers and international students gain residency, as well as a re-tooling of our immigration points system to emphasize the skilled trades.

Verdict: Liberals look stronger.

Trade
Quick facts: exports account for roughly a third of Canadian GDP; 80% of those exports are destined for the (slumping) US economy. Exports are mainly from the automotive, aircraft, telecommunications, oil, gas, and agricultural sectors.

Conservatives: In the past year under the Conservative government, Canada has successfully negotiated free trade agreements with Columbia and the European Free Trade Area. That's good. The Prime Minister has also managed to sour our economic relations with China. That's bad. The party has produced protectionist rhetoric that vows to defend the agricultural community but also a promise to re-assert leadership on free trade negotiations with the Americas, East and South Asia.

Liberals: The party platform includes only three paragraphs on trade, most of which lacks any concrete commitments. Unlike the Tories, the Libs at least give a nod to multilateral WTO negotiations; like the Tories, they also promise to make 'Canadian values' of human rights and corporate social responsibility central to trade negotiations.

Verdict: Both parties are strong on free trade in principle; both violate this principle in practice. The edge goes to the Conservatives.

Monday, 22 September 2008

The End of Investment Banks

Last Wednesday, Rory wrote:
Prediction: by Christmas, there will be no major, independent US investment banks left. The broker-dealer model is dead.
Try: "by next week."

Sunday, 21 September 2008

The Week Ahead

After passing through one of the worst - and most interesting - weeks of the credit crisis so far, I’m curious to see how the market reacts after having the weekend to mull it over. As the crisis in debt markets has progressed, the US government has responded with measures that have been increasingly drastic. Each time, the market has responded favourably, but for progressively shorter periods of time before the downward trend continues. We’re coming off a big market rebound on Friday following the big announcement from the US Treasury, so let’s watch to see how long that euphoria lasts.


In my view, the more important question is what precedent this sort of action sets for the future. There are a lot of legal, jurisdictional and practical difficulties associated with the proposal, the outline of which was leaked late last week. For instance, is the US Treasury going to buy up the bad debt from non-American firms as well? If they’re systemically important, why not? For that matter, shouldn’t other affected governments be contributing as well? It appears as though firms must have their HQ located in America to qualify, but there’s nothing (I think) stopping an arbitrage situation where American-based firms buy up foreign-based companies and proceed to sell the toxic assets to the US government. I certainly wouldn’t expect Congress to accept bad foreign-firm-owned debt without making some noise.


In fact, this jurisdictional ambiguity is the sort of thing that led to the creation of the Basle Committee on Banking Supervision following a series of bank collapses in the 1970s. The BCBS began initially through bilateral US-UK talks that expanded to include other countries. Since Wall St and the City are once again at the center of the crisis, I wonder if we’re going to see a push for greater international collaboration. Much of that may depend upon who makes up the next US administration.


Anyway, I’m getting ahead of myself - there will be plenty of other interesting developments this week.

  • For instance, Japan’s ruling (in coalition) Liberal Democratic Party will be selecting a new leader on Monday. Whoever is chosen will become Japan’s next Prime Minister.
  • Britain’s Labour Party Conference began today and will continue until Wednesday. Unlike Japan, this will probably not result in a new Prime Minister, but that hasn’t prevented the media from discussing the possibility at length.
  • Tensions between the United States and Pakistan continue over the cross-border raid conducted by US Special Forces that resulted in civilian deaths.
  • The NHL hockey preseason has begun. So, I’m happy.

UPDATE: See this list of economists shouting 'no!' to the Treasury's plan.