Showing posts with label Canada. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canada. Show all posts

Sunday, 8 March 2009

America's Next Top Model: The Canadian Banking System?

The relative health of the Canadian banking system has been getting a lot of attention these days. Yves Smith notes with approval the "decidedly retro" nature of the system while referencing a NYT op-ed that praises "The Great Solvent North." On a bigger scale, the Europeans seem to have latched on to the success of Canadian banking system as a guide for banking reform - they may very well use it as a stick with which to beat the Americans over the head while promoting their new joint economic agenda for the G20. Finally, with the World Economic Forum recently ranking it the soundest in the world, the boys of Bay Street have become the envy of the global financial system.

It's easy to understand why. After witnessing the fallout from what happens when the world's largest banks leverage their assets 30-, 40-, or 70-1, some policymakers are positively drooling at Canada's cautious reserve requirements. And if it weren't enough that their levels of market capitalization now rival their major American counterparts, some of these cheeky Canuck banks are still making profit! In a recession!

So why have Canadian banks so far remained (relatively) insulated? From the NYT article:
The five major chartered banks, the few regional banks and handful of large insurance companies are all regulated by the federal government. Canadian banks are relatively constrained in the amounts they can lend. Canadian banks are required to have a bigger cushion to absorb losses than American banks. In addition, Canadian government regulations protect the domestic banks by limiting foreign competition. They also keep banks broadly owned by public shareholders....
The... horror. I think Italy is the only other major industrialized country with such heavy protective measures over its financial community - a factor which also seems to have insulated them from the crisis somewhat. But it's important not to overstate things. The op-ed continues:
Canadian banks are known to be risk-averse, and this has served them well. While their American counterparts were loading up their books with risky mortgages, Canadian banks maintained their lending requirements, largely avoiding subprime mortgages.... The big five Canadian banks... [have] survived the recent turmoil relatively unscathed.
I think those points deserve a few qualifications. First, I don't think the full impact of the US economic collapse has filtered across the border yet: several of Canada's top 5 expanded their operations into the US and so remain exposed to the fallout. Secondly, anecdotal evidence suggests that some of the banks were decidedly less cautious when it came to investing in the subprime market - and their clients are feeling the pain. Finally, it's not clear where future profits are going to come from given the nasty global environment - there are worrying signs already.

So maybe this model has a few blemishes after all. It's also worth noting that many banking execs had been lobbying very hard for Canada to alter its regulatory structure to allow its domestic banks to compete with their international rivals. Their relative failure to achieve this has proved to be their saving grace. But before the Europeans and Americans rush headlong into imposing Canadian-style banking regulations, they should take a good hard look at the social, political and institutional reasons for why those lobbying efforts had limited success - it wont be easy to re-create that environment at home.

But one thing does seem clear: Canada's financial regulators have the eyes of the world upon them. It will be interesting to see how they choose to deal with the new-found attention.

(photos: Mike Manalang's & Mister V's photostream)

Friday, 9 January 2009

Lazy Friday Links

Too lazy to string together a coherent argument, I instead provide links for your reading pleasure.

I'm making a concerted effort to read both interventionist and classical liberal types when it comes to economics with the hopes of cutting down on bias. As a Canadian, it's much easier to come across strong leftish sentiments, but it's reassuring to see that both sides get equally worked up. Check out the comments on Alex Tabarrok's summary of Obama's speech at GMU. I, for one, am hoping Alex is right.

Canada has no coherent government. "Essentially we are arguing that Canada has become a more genteel Somalia." Spicy!

The November stats are in. Consumer spending in America was way down, but volume of consumption was up. Wait, what?

A new blog over at Science has been launched with Darwin's Origin of Species as inspiration. On a related note, Dr. Boli has made a scientific discovery.

(I'm nitpicking here, but hopefully the content of Origins will be better than its grammar. The serial comma is running rampant in the welcome:
As part of its celebration of these two anniversaries, Science will be blogging, with Darwin as our inspiration. On this site, our writers and editors, as well as guest researchers and blog readers, will share their thoughts, not just about the origin of species but also about key nodes throughout the evolution of life, just as Darwin did.

I enjoy a comma as much as the next guy, but that's painful.)

Thursday, 11 December 2008

The Canadian Political System: Explained

The recent kerfuffle in Canadian politics managed to draw the attention of international spectators just long enough for some awkward questions to be raised about the nature of democracy in some of the United Kingdom's former colonies. Who exactly is the head of state in these places? What is their role? What does it mean to "prorogue" parliament? Is Stephen Harper's hair made of plastic?

Question no further, readers. All is explained through these links:

The Daily Show tackles the tough questions here (or here for Canadian readers).

I also enjoyed Dr. Boli's answer.

Monday, 8 December 2008

Quick hits and pink picks

-John Thain wants his 2008 bonus, reportedly $10m. Two ways to look at this: 1) his social and political thermometers are broken, or 2) he deserves it. Despite all of his misleading statements on the health of Merrill Lynch and role in its eventual acquisition by Bank of America, he did secure the sale of the firm at $28 a share. Remember what Bear went for? My take: I recognize point 2, but agree with point 1. He's insane for asking, and his compensation committee would be crazier to approve. UPDATE: Apparently, someone told him this whole bonus demand was a bad idea, because he no longer wants it.

-The FT has an interesting article on today's elections in Quebec. The economy trumps sovereignty, a good sign for Liberals.

-The Pulitzer Prizes have expanded to cover online only publications. IPE Journal submits itself for consideration.

-Petroleum Intelligence Weekly has released its influential annual rankings of the world's top oil companies. The report highlights the increasingly marginalized position of the traditional private oil majors, and growing global market dominance of majority state-owned companies. This trend towards nationalization and state control of increasingly scarce resources has a number of powerful implications.

Saturday, 6 December 2008

That Was The Week That Was

Politique
-US President-elect Barack Obama unveils details of his "21st century New Deal". The Economic Recovery Plan is preliminarily based on 5 pillars: energy, roads and bridges, schools, broadband, and electronic medical records. Many, including prominent members of his own party, are becoming increasingly frustrated with his "there is only one president at a time" line, as the sitting President appears to have checked out while Rome burns.
-The terrorist attacks on Mumbai end, the Indian investigation expands, and at least 29 people die from a car bomb in the Pakistani city of Peshwara. Blame for the attacks has focused on Pakistan-based Lashkar-e-Taiba (the likely perpetrators), the Indian government (early warnings, poor response, failure to hold Pakistan accountable), and the Pakistani regime (failure/inability to address sources of terrorism and militancy within its borders).
-A deliciously intriguing affair in the British House of Commons has ignited a fierce debate over Parliamentary independence, opposition politics, and police powers. Meanwhile, Canada has its own legislative controversy to deal with (find Dave's take here).

Economia
-The US learned it has been in recession since December 2007 (something everyone but this guy has been well aware of) and lost 533,000 jobs in November, the largest jobs decline in 34 years.
-Angela Merkel grew increasingly isolated in Europe as French President Sarkozy unveiled a €26bn stimulus package. UK Prime Minister Brown and Sarkozy will meet in London on Monday to renew their call for a coordinated European stimulus.
-An historic week in European central banking: BoE cuts 100 basis points to 2.0% (lowest level since 1951), ECB goes with 75 basis points to 2.5% (its largest single cut ever), and Sweden slashes a record 175 basis points to 2.0%.

The Rest
-In the Prem: Arsenal continue form following famous win at Stamford Bridge, Liverpool stay top, and ManU and Spurs on track for Carling Cup final. In Europe: Cristiano Ronaldo wins Ballon d'Or, reveals he was "an inch away" from being a Gunner in 2003.
-This week in Japanese innovation: omelets with the Motoman SDA10.
-"Experienced bandits" steal €85mn in luxury jewels from Harry Winston store in Paris. According to Reuters, the heist occurred almost a year to the day of a similar $16mn robbery at the store.

Wednesday, 3 December 2008

Double Down: When One Crisis Is Just Not Enough!

The first six articles on the front page of the Financial Times this afternoon read as follows:
  • "Record contraction in US services sector: Private sector sheds most jobs in six years"
  • "Record number of companies at risk of default"
  • "More grim data pushes Wall Street lower: job cuts worse than expected"
  • "Markets braced for big rate cut: Bad economic data continue to flow from leading economies"
  • "Blackberry maker warns on slower growth"
  • "Commodities prices at six-year lows"

Not exactly cheerful news. And yet it is in precisely these grim economic times that the politicians of one of the best-performing rich countries have decided to instigate a political crisis. All by themselves. Non-residents will be forgiven for not having heard about Canada's most recent political circus - you will also be forgiven for continuing in that blissful ignorance.

As I alluded to, Canada's economy has so far held up extremely well compared to the rest of the G7. However, the knock-on effect of recessions in the economies of Canada's biggest trading partners is likely only to be delayed and dulled, not avoided. Given that, Prime Minister Harper's decision last Thursday to use his "economic update" in parliament as an excuse to kneecap both opposition parties and public servants was pretty shameful. See Paul Wells for more on that score.

Equally shameful was the response of the various parties that make up the parliamentary opposition. Within weeks of decisively losing a federal election, the three opposition parties have decided, in their collective wisdom, that rather than blocking the PM's maneuver with their combined majority or even (horrors!) suggesting a viable policy alternative, they will form a coalition and take over the government.

The battle lines have been drawn and both sides are working ferociously to brand the other as unpatriotic, irresponsible, power-hungry nutters. Both sides are winning; meanwhile, Canadians everywhere are the losers.

Let me quickly address some of the main issues. First of all, there is nothing in principle wrong with the idea of a separatist party engaging in a government coalition. Moreover, since both sides have relied on said "separatist" party to support their agenda, there is equal parts hypocrisy on all sides. As far as the complaint by the opposition that the economic update did not include appropriate measures for fiscal stimulus... I got yer fiscal stimulus: right here!

I will finish with an open letter to Canada's legislators:

Dear Conservative, Liberal, New Democratic and Bloc Parties,

Grow up.

Tuesday, 4 November 2008

Trade in Asbestos: Really?

Freer trade is almost always a good thing. Almost. The biggest exceptions to this rule are weapons, narcotics, dangerous chemicals and, uh, people. Most people would agree that restrictions on trade in such things is a good idea. But apparently "most people" doesn't include Canadian lawmakers, who have been lobbying hard to prevent white asbestos from being added to the Rotterdam Convention's list of toxic substances. With success.

The Economist has provided an excellent backgrounder on the issue, but the basics are simple: the World Health Organization thinks white asbestos is potentially dangerous and wishes to add it to this list; the substance has been banned by 40 countries; alternatives to white asbestos exist; the industry employs less than a thousand workers in Canada and brings in less than $200 million in revenue; Canada is the third largest miner of asbestos, and exports over 90% of its asbestos to other (mostly developing) countries. Moreover, the health risks of white asbestos are highest for those who mine it - so who exactly is this benefiting?

It is not clear to me where the upside is, and Canada's blatant hypocrisy on this issue undermines its position on the world stage. It is time to move on from this shameful practice.

Friday, 3 October 2008

Liberal and Conservative Party Platforms: Int'l Perspective, part II: Environment

I have been patiently waiting for the release of the Conservative party platform to continue with this series on the election issues in Canada from an international perspective, but it appears that I am waiting in vain. It's shocking that a party can run for re-election without a platform, but so be it. All I can say is that, given the popularity of part 1, even as the media focuses on the personality-cult of election campaigns, people are actively searching out the positions of the political parties on their own - that's encouraging.

So today I will be looking at the Liberal and Conservative positions on the environment & taxation - specifically, how each party plans to spread the cost of meeting emissions targets. Taxation and environmental policies are crucial both for Canada's economic competitiveness in attracting foreign investment and rebuilding its moral authority at multilateral negotiations. Also, regardless of which plan is implemented, it will serve as an important model for other countries to study, for better or worse.

The Conservatives
The Conservatives' environmental plan amounts to a cap-and-trade system. Andrew Coyne has an excellent summary of the plan here. Emissions are "capped" at a certain level; firms that cut emissions below the cap can earn credits on the surplus; firms that exceed the cap must buy up credits from the surplus market. Alternatively, firms buy credits on the international market or contribute to a "green technology fund."

The goal is to reduce emissions by 20% by 2020, using 2006 as the baseline. Make no mistake, said Stephen Harper in 2007, this regulatory framework will create "very real costs" and result in "noticeable price increases for consumer products such as vehicles, natural gas, electricity, and household appliances." As Coyne rightly points out, we're not hearing much about those costs anymore.

The Liberals
In a nutshell, the Grits' Green Shift amounts to a carbon tax: greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions will be priced at $10/tonne, rising another $10/year until it reaches $40/tonne. To offset this carbon tax, the Liberals promise to cut income taxes for the lowest bracket from 15 to 13.5%, and the income taxes of the middle brackets from 22% and 26% to 21% and 25%, respectively. Small businesses get an additional 1% cut, and there will be further undefined incentives for green technology.

The Liberal target is also a 20% reduction by 2020, but they're using 1990 as the benchmark - so, a more ambitious target.

Analysis
As LSE's own maver-economist, Willem Buiter, points out: from an economic perspective, a cap-and-trade system is equivalent to a carbon tax. Both a market cap and a carbon tax raise the marginal cost of GHG emissions. Those with a low marginal cost will expand their activities, those with a high marginal cost will reduce them. The biggest difference is that, under a carbon tax, the price of carbon is set at X and firms trade amongst themselves. Under a cap & trade, the total amount of emissions is set, permits are auctioned off, the secondary market establishes a price, and the firms trade amongst themselves.

However, Buiter qualifies the equivalence:
An argument in favour of carbon taxes over cap & trade is that cap & trade requires an efficient secondary market. As we know from recent experience, financial market efficiency cannot be taken for granted.... In a world with uncertainty but incomplete markets, the carbon tax and cap & trade are similar but not equivalent; neither one obviously dominates the other under all circumstances.
The main trade-off is knowing the price of carbon vs. knowing the amount of GHG emissions. From a business perspective, I would imagine the prospect of a tax is discouraging, but the certainty of the costs allows for more accurate business modeling. On the other hand, the cap-and-trade system is more obscure than a tax, which makes it popular for politicians.

In both cases, revenue is generated for the government that can be used or abused as they see fit. I will finish by summarizing Andrew Coyne's analysis, which neatly outlines the flaws in both plans.

Conservatives
  • The plan is "just as costly as the Liberals'... twice as complicated...and probably half as effective." Indeed, leading climate experts agree that even the modest targets set by the Tories will not be met.
  • Ironically, given the Conservatives' 2006 platform, the cap & trade is less transparent than the carbon tax
  • The plan is infinitely less politically risky than the Liberals', which also makes it more likely to be implemented
Liberals
  • The plan is not radical enough, but costly enough to annoy everyone.
  • Libs haven't explained how they will apply the carbon tax to provinces that already have one, and have not promised to cut income taxes by anything near enough to make this revenue neutral, as promised.
  • The details are fuzzy, and a tax is politically unpalatable, making its implementation (especially in a minority government situation) far less likely.

Tuesday, 23 September 2008

The Conservative & Liberal Party Platforms: International Perspective, part I

(Another Update, Oct 3 - part II on the environment is here)
(Update, Sep 30 - An earlier version of this essay included a specific Tory promise on immigration that was incorrect and has been removed. The full Conservative platform has not yet been released. I'm using press releases, the 2006 platform, the 2007 throne speech, and the National Post article which lists all promises made thus far. It's all we've got, people).

The humble scribblers here at le Journale have made a conscious effort to avoid commenting on the ups and downs of election campaigns, but exceptions are made for issues relating directly to international political economy. Earlier, Rory took issue with the suggestion that a certain US VP candidate's lack of international experience was not a significant matter, or worse: an asset. He argued that it's simply not acceptable for the executive branch of government to be out of touch with global issues when so many of our greatest challenges don't respect national borders. Agreed.

Well, Jeffrey Simpson has pointed to a similar worrying trend up here in Canada: the current election campaign is proceeding along as if the rest of the world doesn't exist. Normally I would insert a self-depreciating joke about how the rest of the world doesn't know Canada exists, but this is patently untrue: Canada is regularly referenced as a model for immigration, health care, multiculturalism, internationalist foreign policy, environmental issues and the like. The sad part is, most of these stereotypes do not hold up well to scrutiny. Canada has one of the worst greenhouse gas emissions rates per capita, our foreign relations have been on a downward trend of late, as have our trading relations and levels of foreign aid. Meanwhile, with the effects of the American recession seeping across the border, the importance of attracting international investment and workers to maintain growth and innovation is more important than ever.

So, with that in mind, I'm going to dig into the policies of the two parties most likely to win the election - the ruling Conservative Party and the rival Liberal Party - to examine the future outlook for foreign countries, firms, and citizens who expect to be dealing with the Canadian government over the next few years. Today's themes will be immigration and trade.

Immigration
Canada's ability (and willingness) to attract foreign workers represents a huge economic advantage over the United States. The American H-1B temporary working visas are capped at 65,000 per year (!), which makes doing business in the United States considerably more challenging. This has led firms like Microsoft to re-locate north of the border. What are the two main political parties promising to do about immigration?

Conservatives: Quite frankly, not much. By and large, multiculturalism doesn't jive well with the Conservative's emphasis on 'Canadian values,' but to ignore the fact that immigration is a driving force in the competitiveness of the Canadian economy also doesn't fit with their message of economic responsibility.

Liberals: This party has always had a strong emphasis on attracting new immigrants and on the benefits of multiculturalism. Their promises include a new program to facilitate temp workers and international students gain residency, as well as a re-tooling of our immigration points system to emphasize the skilled trades.

Verdict: Liberals look stronger.

Trade
Quick facts: exports account for roughly a third of Canadian GDP; 80% of those exports are destined for the (slumping) US economy. Exports are mainly from the automotive, aircraft, telecommunications, oil, gas, and agricultural sectors.

Conservatives: In the past year under the Conservative government, Canada has successfully negotiated free trade agreements with Columbia and the European Free Trade Area. That's good. The Prime Minister has also managed to sour our economic relations with China. That's bad. The party has produced protectionist rhetoric that vows to defend the agricultural community but also a promise to re-assert leadership on free trade negotiations with the Americas, East and South Asia.

Liberals: The party platform includes only three paragraphs on trade, most of which lacks any concrete commitments. Unlike the Tories, the Libs at least give a nod to multilateral WTO negotiations; like the Tories, they also promise to make 'Canadian values' of human rights and corporate social responsibility central to trade negotiations.

Verdict: Both parties are strong on free trade in principle; both violate this principle in practice. The edge goes to the Conservatives.