Tuesday, 13 January 2009

Tuesday Round-Up: Geopolitics and the Financial Crisis

Some stuff I've read over the weekend has been swimming around in my head and I think it needs to be written down to help me identify, if not the right answers, at least some of the right questions. I'll try to be as coherent as possible:

- Looking ahead at 2009, Dani Rodrik writes that he is more worried "about growth in advanced countries than in the developing world." I wonder why that might be. Could it be the fact that aid flows to the poorest of the developing world drop during periods of economic downturn? Probably not, since aid flows account for only small amounts of growth - although it is worth noting that official development assistance is even more volatile than GDP or fiscal revenue, so a recession in the rich world is not good news for the truly impoverished.

Maybe it's because the developing world depends upon advanced country markets as a source of their exports and growth? That seems more likely (I'm skeptical of the decoupling thesis), but that's nothing compared to the damage caused by the commodity bust to developing country growth prospects. Because of those two factors, I - unlike Mr. Rodrik - am definitely less worried about the North Atlantic economies' capacity to recover from this crisis and stay in one piece. Certainly Rodrik agrees with me in so far as it concerns...

- China. He writes:
"China is a country of enormous tensions and cleavages beneath the surface.... The question is whether policy actions to date will do enough to stem a socially and politically dangerous slowdown in the economy. Whichever way the Chinese leadership responds, future generations may remember 2009 less for its global economic and financial crisis than for the momentous transformation it will have caused in China."
Indeed. On this topic I turn to two articles, the first by John Kemp. Kemp looks at how the economic slowdown has affected Guangdong province - China's manufacturing hub - and how a slowdown in the region will affect global markets, particularly for energy and raw materials. There's much more in there, so give it a read.

Dan Drezner also raises a number of excellent points concerning China, as well as several other "known unknowns" from the current financial mess. He thinks we can expect countries like China to begin de-coupling by using their fiscal stimulus plans to target domestic firms and encourage the growth of domestic markets to offset declining demand abroad. That's a roundabout way of suggesting that protectionism in on the rise and the gains in political cooperation that come from economic interdependence are on the decline. I would argue that this situation, along with the macroeconomic imbalances problem, calls for more international cooperation, not less, but is Drezner's prediction more likely?

- Russia and the Ukraine have signed a deal to resume gas flows under the supervision of international authorities. Is Russia's plummeting ruble going to make the country more or less aggressive over its energy supply policies. Or maybe: is Russia's weakening economic situation going to embolden countries like the Ukraine to provoke them even further?

Sunday, 11 January 2009

Ben Bernanke to speak at the LSE

I have turned into something of a podcast junkie recently, and one source of excellent material is The London School of Economics public lecture series. This week, however, there's a particularly prominent guest speaker in the form of US Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke. The title of the talk is "Policy Responses to the Financial Crisis" and I highly recommend you tune in. There will actually be a live webcast of the event (Tuesday, 13:00 GMT, 8:00 EST) for those who want visuals.

The trouble with high profile speakers who hold public office is that their talks tend to be vague and pull punches on sticky issues - that Bernanke is operating "between" administrations with different policy response ideas won't help either. That being said, however, it will definitely be worth a listen.

While you're at it, I also highly recommend a talk by Paul Collier, author of The Bottom Billion - an excellent book on poverty reduction that's aimed at non-academics. You can also find him doing a (shorter) TED talk here.

Friday, 9 January 2009

Lazy Friday Links

Too lazy to string together a coherent argument, I instead provide links for your reading pleasure.

I'm making a concerted effort to read both interventionist and classical liberal types when it comes to economics with the hopes of cutting down on bias. As a Canadian, it's much easier to come across strong leftish sentiments, but it's reassuring to see that both sides get equally worked up. Check out the comments on Alex Tabarrok's summary of Obama's speech at GMU. I, for one, am hoping Alex is right.

Canada has no coherent government. "Essentially we are arguing that Canada has become a more genteel Somalia." Spicy!

The November stats are in. Consumer spending in America was way down, but volume of consumption was up. Wait, what?

A new blog over at Science has been launched with Darwin's Origin of Species as inspiration. On a related note, Dr. Boli has made a scientific discovery.

(I'm nitpicking here, but hopefully the content of Origins will be better than its grammar. The serial comma is running rampant in the welcome:
As part of its celebration of these two anniversaries, Science will be blogging, with Darwin as our inspiration. On this site, our writers and editors, as well as guest researchers and blog readers, will share their thoughts, not just about the origin of species but also about key nodes throughout the evolution of life, just as Darwin did.

I enjoy a comma as much as the next guy, but that's painful.)

Thursday, 8 January 2009

Some Optimism

A comment over at Free Exchange about how the market psychology that led to inflated asset prices during the boom might also apply to the downturn. In other words, we can overshoot on the way down as well. This points to the inherent difficulty in seeing beyond the immediate trend to predict future events.

The article includes optimistic prognostications about the length of the downturn from James Surowiecki and economist heavyweight Kenneth Rogoff. Nice to see that my prediction of a couple months back is still in good company. Here's Rogoff:
Still, it must be noted that negative output growth for more than two years is a relatively rare event, even in the aftermath of severe banking crises. Historical statistical relationships are perhaps cold comfort in a downturn that now seems so insidiously different from previous catastrophes. But they should not be dismissed.
There, I feel better already. And certainly if I had any money, I'd be investing it right now. But that aside, there's still the interesting question about whether the boom & bust cycle is in fact the result of "a herd of hysterical lemmings," as Free Exchange puts it, or rational economic actors responding to a poorly structured market environment. The answer, as Mark Thoma discusses, matters a great deal for what policies are going to be most useful in softening the downturn.

I'm still leaning towards the hysterical lemming model, but that's mainly because I prefer the mental image...
(image from consumeist with apologies to Larson)

Wednesday, 7 January 2009

Has The American Economy Lost Its "Alpha"?

Willem Buiter certainly thinks so. His essay is, as usual, probably too long and dense for casual readers so I'll try to draw out some of the main points here. Before doing that, here is some background:

For quite some time now, the United States economy has been taking in more foreign investment than its citizens are investing abroad. Despite this negative net investment, American investors are earning more from their foreign investments (in aggregate) than the interest being paid on debts owed to foreign investors. This situation is what is being referred to when we talk of "alpha" - being able to secure positive returns despite a situation of negative net investment. This alpha has resulted from two factors: the very low rate of return offered on US assets and the increasingly risky nature of US-owned assets abroad (leading some to describe the United States as the world's largest venture capitalist).

Buiter outlines one possible explanation for the existence of alpha:
"Because of its unique position as the world’s largest economy, the world’s one remaining military and political superpower (since the demise of the Soviet Union in 1991) and the world’s joint-leading financial centre (with the City of London), the US could offer foreign investors lousy US returns on their investments in the US, without causing them to take their money and run."

The problem is, to the extent that it ever existed, this situation has been undermined:
There is no chance that a nation as reputationally scarred and maimed as the US is today could extract any true “alpha” from foreign investors for the next 25 years or so. So the US will have to start to pay a normal market price for the net resources it borrows from abroad. It will therefore have to start to generate primary surpluses, on average, for the indefinite future.
Thems fightin words. In order to generate those primary surpluses, the American economy will need higher taxes and/or less government spending (as well as higher personal savings). Yet the prospective Obama administration's economic stimulus plan contains precisely the opposite: lower taxes and higher government spending.

Buiter doesn't expect to change the outcome of the stimulus package, but his point is this: while the short run effects of a stimulus package may be beneficial, it will destroy the long-run prospects for the entire US economy. In short, the US economy cannot afford a Keynesian stimulus package. He predicts a global dumping of US assets in 2-5 years.

I wouldn't spend too much time worrying about Buiter's specific predictions on asset-dumping. Keynes himself pointed out that our ability to forsee the long-run is so limited as to be practically useless. Moreover, currency predictions are fickle at the best of times because everything is relative. For instance, even with current US economic weakness, we're seeing a flood to the US dollar a safehaven from other crashing currencies. So in two to five years, just about anything could happen. For more counter-arguments, see Free Exchange here and here.

Nevertheless, Buiter's overall concern is a real one and I'm not willing to dismiss it out of hand. But I think the most important questions to policymakers with more short-run horizons still comes down to: what's the alternative? and can America really afford not to have a Keynesian stimulus? A political consensus appears to forming that makes the answer to that last question a resounding "no."

So either Buiter is overstating the extent to which investors will be scared off by higher US debt levels, or there could be some very real long-run consequences that will make Obama's Harlem-Globetrotter-esque economic advisors look like the Washington Generals.

Tuesday, 6 January 2009

What Barack Obama kind of said today

Following the bombing of a UN school in Gaza, where civilians had taken shelter from the fighting, US President-elect Barack Obama was finally compelled into a statement on the conflict:

"The loss of civilian life in Gaza and Israel is a source of deep concern for me."

As it is for everyone else. And....?

Quick hits and pink picks

-David Hale believes the dollar rally is overdone, and argues in the FT that gold, not the euro, will be the short term alternative to the greenback (and inflation hedge of choice) in 2009.

-FP Passport looks at the new American Embassy in Baghdad. Once, US embassies housed cultural centers, English-language libraries and social spaces for the local population. Now, a really high wall and a whole lot of concrete. Architectural historian Jane Loeffler: "If architecture reflects the society that creates it, the new U.S. embassy in Baghdad makes a devastating comment about America’s global outlook."

-Samuel Huntington, giant of political science, died on December 24th at age 81. Huntington's 1993 essay in Foreign Affairs, "The Clash of Civilizations" (later expanded into a book), sparked a global debate on international conflict, religion and the nation-state that still rages today. I have been struck recently by the number of non-IR/IPE people who have not read the essay, especially among those critical of its thesis. It can be found here, and I strongly encourage a (re)reading.

Monday, 5 January 2009

Recommended: Eero Saarinen, architect

I recently attended an exhibition on Eero Saarinen, the Finnish American architect. Saarinen designed corporate, governmental, academic and residential buildings in the mid 20th century. His works include the Gateway Arch in St. Louis, the TWA terminal at New York's JFK airport, the IBM manufacturing and training facility in Rochester, Minnesota, the American Embassy in London, and the Ingalls Hockey Rink on the campus of Yale University (see sketch), to name but a few. He is also renowned for his furniture design, including the iconic Knoll "Womb" chair.

Saarinen's mid-century modernism was highly influential, but criticized by some contemporaries for lacking stylistic discipline. Admirers, however, believe that Saarinen "rejected the dogma of an orthodox modernism and instead adopted a varied approach to architectural design, letting the subject and site guide his inventive solutions".

If you are interested in architecture and design, check out Eero Saarinen.

Sunday, 4 January 2009

That Was The Week That Was

Politique
-As the world limped into the new year, IPE Journal looked back at the defining political stories of 2008.

-Israel's Gaza operation entered its second week. A ground invasion is now underway to topple the Hamas regime and prevent further rocket attacks on Israel. The UN Security Council failed to reach a consensus position this weekend, despite an humanitarian situation characterized as "desperate."

-Czech President Vaclav Klaus assumed the rotating EU Presidency this week. After a widely praised and robust Sarkozy presidency, Brussels watchers are anxious that the "prickly" Klaus will undermine EU consensus on the financial crisis, climate change and, well, the EU itself.

-The Chinese government moved to silence the signatories of Charter 08, a "wide-ranging blueprint for peaceful political, legal and economic reform in China." The crackdown reflects the deep anxiety carried by the Chinese leadership into 2009.

Economia
-Entering 2009 with much economic and financial uncertainty, IPE Journal looked back at the economic stories of 2008.

-Another price dispute between Russia and Ukraine resulted in the suspension of natural gas deliveries to Ukraine, with reports of growing shortages from Turkey to the Czech Republic. Both Moscow and Kiev are courting European support for their position in the dispute.

-Sterling neared Euro parity for the first time, a milestone that might spark a much deeper sterling sell-off.

The Rest
-Now more than ever, we need distractions. IPE Journal looked back at the cultural, sporting and down right random things that captured our attention in 2008.

-In the FA Cup, Arsenal go forward on a Van Persie brace, while Man City crashes out in spectacular fashion. Notable 4th round ties: ManU v. Spurs, Liverpool v. Everton.

-40 drunken passengers run "riot" on Cuba bound flight from Gatwick. "Drunk", "Gatwick" and "riot" are three words I am not surprised to find in the same sentence.

-The Obama's arrived in Washington...let the parties, galas and Republican exodus begin.

Saturday, 3 January 2009

The slippery slope to protectionism or How to create your own depression

The interwar period is a fascinating "topic" in IPE. Scholarship on the period is vast, offering multiple explanations for the trends, events and ideas that contributed to the Great Depression and WWII. Some of the great thinkers in IPE (such as Kindleberger, Eichengreen and some guy named Bernanke) have contributed to the analysis of the period.

The interwar period is studied so closely because it provides lessons on how NOT to respond to economic contraction and financial crisis. If this history is any indication, protectionism should be avoided like the plague. The Smoot-Hawley tariff set off a change reaction of protectionism from 1930 on that plunged the world much deeper into depression. While a global (meaning British and American) consensus on trade was unattainable immediately following the war (see ITO failure), the GATT succeeded largely due to the Anglo-American recognition that tariffs were dangerous to economic recovery, prosperity and peace itself.

Over the next few weeks, the Obama transition team and US Congress would do well to brush up on their interwar history. The US steel industry, after years of benefiting from illegal subsidies, are reportedly lobbying in favor of a massive public works plan that would have a "buy US" provision inserted into every project. This would conceivably require the recipients of federal funds for public works and infrastructure projects to purchase US steel.

The proposal is troubling on a number of levels. For one, it would prove that the TARP was but the tip of an iceberg of government subsidy. Banks, autos, steel...where does it end? Second, it underlines the risks posed by the DDA's failure. WTO and G20 indecision in the face of rising protectionism risks exactly the domino effect that Smoot-Hawley accelerated nearly 80 years ago. Finally, a "buy US" clause would be a dangerous precedent for the President-elect to set. Many are already skeptical of his commitment to a liberal trading system, and early support for such backdoor protectionism would do little to burnish his trade credentials internationally.

Vice-President elect Biden believes that to be credible and effective, the Economic Recovery Plan must be "pork-free". It is equally important that it avoid the kind of backdoor protectionism the US steel industry is lobbying for.

From The Alan Greenspan Dept. of 20-20 Hindsight

With only a couple of weeks left in office, Hank Paulson has been busy holding interviews to make his views on the financial crisis clear. Here he is explaining how the Treasury lacks sufficient authority to deal with financial crises. Here he is again two days later explaining how macroeconomic imbalances are the true, underlying cause of our recent financial mess. (For a basic run down on the imbalances issue, see my previous essay).

Now, Hank Paulson is absolutely correct in pointing to the imbalances as a source of cheap credit that led to excessive risk-taking. But as my co-author rightly pointed out, it is almost as if Paulson is blaming a concept for the crisis, not unlike those who blame "globalization" for all the world's ills:
"Aha!," say the Americans, "it was those pesky imbalances that made us run huge national deficits and unsustainable personal debt." "It's not our fault either!," retort the Chinese, "those imbalances forced us to manipulate our currency in order to sustain a massive trade surplus." "Don't look at me!," says the investment banker, between Manhattans. "What did you expect me to do with all that cheap credit? Monitor who was holding all that risk?" "Why are we burning through cash at a rate of billions per month after operating for three decades with an unsustainable business model?" asks GM's CEO on conference call from his private jet, "Why, it was the, er... macrosomething imbalances!"

You get the idea. The reality is that the economic imbalances are the culmination of the decisions of governments and individuals over an extended period of time that were self-interested and ignored the bigger picture. The imbalances equation has a savings glut and investment drought on one side, and a collection of irresponsible financial incentives on the other. Ultimately, this situation has been brought on by the unwillingness of the world's major financial actors to take responsibility for the long run implications of their actions. A quote from The Economist:
"A sound international economic order cannot be built on the assumption that the rumbustiously richest country will go on borrowing unprecedented amounts at enormous interest rates from everybody else for ever.”
And yet that's pretty much the model we've been working from (except with low, instead of high interest rates). Oh, and where did I take that quote from? The Economist's 1984 endorsement of Ronald Reagan for president. Twenty. Four. Years. Ago. These imbalances did not creep up on us, folks. We need coordinated action by the G20 economies to address the problem without resorting to protectionist measures. It's too bad we needed a recession to drive this point home to the Secretary of the Treasury, but there you have it.

Friday, 2 January 2009

What Barack Obama did, and still did not, say today

The seventh day of Israel's air offensive on Hamas and infrastructure in Gaza has passed, and still no word from Barack Obama. A transition spokesperson, in response to growing calls for Obama to speak up, released a statement that recycles the President-elect's typical response to issues he wants to avoid, "President-elect Obama is closely monitoring global events, including the situation in Gaza, but there is one president at a time."

This Boilerplate statement is a cop-out, and the press needs to start calling Obama on his selective respect for Bush's non-existent presidential authority. If there is only one president at a time, why is Obama heading to Capitol Hill on Monday to negotiate with lawmakers on his economic agenda? Last I checked, his inauguration is not until the 20th.

I am on Obama's case because Gaza affects us all, and could matter as much to his presidency as his stimulus plan. The Israeli/Palestinian conflict is central to explaining global terrorism and middle east instability. As Bush quickly learned (remember his 2000 campaign? international disengagement, education, compassionate conservatism), international events often occupy presidencies, and if Obama is serious about tackling international terrorism, the peace process, or the potential for wider instability in the middle east, it would serve him well to start engaging the Israeli/Palestinian conflict now.

Let me be clear that I am not calling for Obama to speak out against Israel's action (silence is often tacit approval in politics). I do not advocate a particular side in this conflict; I advocate a solution. And I do not pretend to know what that would be. I simply know that the status quo hasn't solved anything.

I do, however, believe that a cessation of hostilities is preferable to a prolonged Israeli ground invasion, and would make a new truce agreement more likely. Toppling a democratically elected government (no matter how despicable Hamas is, its political wing was legitimately and democratically elected in a US sponsored election) and the destruction of Gaza's infrastructure is not in Israeli, or US, interests. The backlash in Palestine and the Muslim world would be immense, and likely result in a third intifada. Problem is, the only party with the leverage to push the parties toward a truce, the US, remains on the sideline.
Rice's press conference today was disappointing (but unsurprising), echoing the administration's stance on the 2006 war in Lebanon. To borrow her words, a "durable and sustainable" cease-fire is achieved one of two ways: a total defeat of one side (which, given the structure of Hamas and Israel's experience in Lebanon, policymakers shouldn't count on), or an agreement that appeals to the interests of both (no matter how disproportionate). It is difficult to envision Israel achieving either of these two outcomes with a full invasion of Gaza, which is exactly what the Bush administration is supporting (at least publicly). This is why Obama should intervene. Not officially, rather by speaking on the subject and setting out his general intentions for the peace process. Even in abstract, an indication of Obama's middle east policy would temper Israeli actions. Admittedly, a ground operation looks unavoidable at this point. But, Obama can limit the operation's duration and damage to civilians and public infrastructure.
This might be critical to providing the conditions under which a truce or eventual peace agreement can be negotiated. The Israeli leadership will listen; they serve no interest by crossing the President-elect. Palestinians will listen too; not Hamas, but a civilian population that must feel like the world has left them behind. If alternatives to Hamas begin to look "durable and sustainable", the sentiment and support that swept Hamas into power will begin to fade. And that might just be the key to ultimately ending rocket attacks on Israel. It would also help boost Fatah, who could fill the vacuum, and are more prepared to negotiate with Israel. If anyone should appreciate the power of "hope", Obama should. Furthermore, if Israel and the US seek to build up Fatah as a partner for peace, actions that bolster the credibility and appeal of Hamas should be avoided. Unfortunately, a prolonged ground war in Gaza will do just that.
Obama has an opportunity to lay the groundwork for the next 4 years of middle east policy. He can't be expected to prevent tomorrow's events in Gaza, but he can affect their duration and damage. US leadership has been, and will be, key to a lasting peace agreement. Obama's silence is helping no one, and only complicates his future efforts towards that end.