Friday, 30 January 2009

US Steel Proposes To Build 'Negative Railway'

Rory and I have both made our views clear on the recent resurgence of protectionist measures in G20 countries so, instead of spouting off once more, I think it's worth looking at the arguments at work on both sides. Via Megan McArdle:

Proponents of expanding the "Buy American" provisions enacted during the Great Depression, including steel and iron manufacturers and labor unions, argue that it is the only way to ensure that the stimulus creates jobs at home and not overseas.... The proposals are meant to regenerate heavy manufacturing jobs in the United States by forcing government contractors to use domestic materials and equipment, even if they are more expensive.
The logic here is that, in order to prevent stimulus money from leaking abroad, one must spend money on domestic goods. These are, after all, the workers and firms who are going to be hard-hit by this recession. But does anyone else find it odd that these proponents are suggesting that the best way to deal with a consumer-driven recession is to make things that are more expensive? And yet that's what we're seeing once again with the proposed additions to the economic stimulus package that was voted through the US House of Representatives yesterday (see Rory's post below).

It's interesting to see how the arguments for protectionism have changed so little over the years. Thanks to the wonders of the internet, I have managed to track down a biting critique of protectionist logic by 19th century French writer Frédéric Bastiat. In his book, Economic Sophisms, (available at EconLib) Bastiat used his humour and wit to ridicule the policy proposals of his day. Below is Bastiat's essay: "A Negative Railroad" - see if you can draw parallels with today!

I have said that as long as one has regard, as unfortunately happens, only to the interest of the producer, it is impossible to avoid running counter to the general interest, since the producer, as such, demands nothing but the multiplication of obstacles, wants, and efforts.


I find a remarkable illustration of this in a Bordeaux newspaper. M. Simiot raises the following question:
Should there be a break in the tracks at Bordeaux on the railroad from Paris to Spain? He answers the question in the affirmative and offers a number of reasons, of which I propose to examine only this:


There should be a break in the railroad from Paris to Bayonne at Bordeaux; for, if goods and passengers are forced to stop at that city, this will be profitable for boatmen, porters, owners of hotels, etc. Here again we see clearly how the interests of those who perform services are given priority over the interests of the consumers.


But if Bordeaux has a right to profit from a break in the tracks, and if this profit is consistent with the public interest, then Angoulême, Poitiers, Tours, Orléans, and, in fact, all the intermediate points, including Ruffec, Châtellerault, etc., etc., ought also to demand breaks in the tracks, on the ground of the general interest—in the interest, that is, of domestic industry—for the more there are of these breaks in the line, the greater will be the amount paid for storage, porters, and cartage at every point along the way. By this means, we shall end by having a railroad composed of a whole series of breaks in the tracks, i.e., a negative railroad.


Whatever the protectionists may say, it is no less certain that the basic principle of restriction is the same as the basic principle of breaks in the tracks: the sacrifice of the consumer to the producer, of the end to the means.

The Zim dollar goes the way of the dodo

Does it matter if an already worthless currency is abandoned?

House passes "Buy America" clause, EC takes notice

On Wednesday I poked fun at the hypocrisy of Vladimir Putin's Davos speech. Despite this, his warning on the dangers of protectionism should be heeded by policymakers, particularly in the US, especially now.

The US House yesterday passed the $819 billion stimulus package, known as the American Recovery and Reinvestment Plan (I love the use of the word "reinvestment", you just know it focus-grouped so much better than "exploding deficit"). The vote was along party lines; not a single Republican voted for the package. The debate over the contents and balance of spending/tax cuts is endless, and I won't wade into those waters here. But I am very troubled by one aspect of the bill: the now notorious "Buy America" clause (which, I must boast, I was all over from the beginning). What at first looked like a shameful attempt at backdoor protectionism, is now officially on the table. It passed.

We know that the House version of the bill is different from the one the President will ultimately sign. It is likely that many of the "pork-lite" programs will be shed to deflect widespread criticism over their relevance to the immediate economic crisis. But in all the partisan back and forth, I have yet to hear a passionate criticism of the "Buy America" clause. The Republicans are more outraged by $335m in funding for sexual health education and prevention programs. The silence on "Buy America" is dangerous and increases the likelihood that the clause remains in the final version. It also provides a fundamental test of Obama's trade policy, whatever that might be. Megan McArdle and Dani Rodrik agree.

Luckily, the European Commission has a bit of a problem with "Buy America" (Canada too). Peter Powers, Commission spokesman, warned, "If a bill is passed which prohibits the sale or purchase of European goods on American territory, that is not something we will stand idly by and ignore." Furthermore, the European Confederation of Iron and Steel Industries (Eurofer), a powerful lobby representing over 370,000 EU workers, has called on the EU to bring it to the WTO, saying, "Our view is that if passed this would be a clear violation of their WTO commitments on government procurement rules", and, "It is a protectionist measure which goes against the commitment made to the G-20 to keep markets open."

Dave was spot on when he said of this rising protectionism, "the real danger is that tariffs/bans on stuffed kittens and fancy cheese are the first snowballs that kick off an avalanche of protectionism that smothers trade and damages geopolitical relations." But what if that avalanche is exactly what we need? Could "Buy America", cheese duties, and stuffed kitten tariffs be the sparks that finally break the DDA deadlock? A rapid deterioration in the trading system could compel leaders to look past the modalities and embrace the central role of trade in saving the global economy.

Maybe. We've learned that a crisis is often necessary to force policymakers out of their comfort zones and stand up to powerful interests. At the very least, a little pressure from the across the Atlantic might bring US policymakers to their senses.

UPDATE: The FT reports that the "Buy America" clause is not present in the current Senate bill, but Senators like Sherrod Brown of Ohio are pushing for its inclusion. I mistakenly assumed it was.

(Photo: funkandjazz)

Thursday, 29 January 2009

It's all politics, even the Super Bowl

The Pittsburgh Steelers will face the Arizona Cardinals in this Sunday's Super Bowl. To our readers from everywhere but North America, that's the championship game of the sport where the ball bounces funny (no, not rugby).

As everyone knows, Barack Obama is from Chicago. That makes him a Bears fan. But that hasn't stopped the press from asking who he's rooting for in the big game. His answer?

''Other than the (Chicago) Bears,'' Obama said, ''the Steelers are probably the team that's closest to my heart.''

You might be asking yourself, how does a guy who was born in Hawaii, lived in Indonesia, attended college in L.A. and New York, law school in Boston, and spent his adult life in Chicago become such a sentimental Steelers fan?

Well...Pittsburgh=Western Pennsylvania/Eastern Ohio media markets=key electoral battlegrounds=2010/2012 elections=Steelers fans are really, really important in American politics.

If it sounds trivial, you've never met this guy:

Football matters.

VoxEU's Global Crisis Debate

VoxEU.org has a new initiative aimed at influencing the agenda of the next G20 meeting in April. Good for them. It's great to see the acedemia harnessing the internets to take seriously the issues facing our global economy.

However, in the event that they influence the ideas put forward by the G20, there's no guarantee that our political leaders will actually, ya know, do anything about it.

82 per cent

Today's statistical indicator has been brought to you by the Institute of International Finance, an association of financial institutions. 82% is the projected decline in private capital flows to emerging market (EM) economies in 2009, compared to 2007 (full report here). They now estimate flows of $165 billion, compared to $466 billion last year and $929 billion during the boom year of 2007. That's quite a drop.

Particularly hard hit will be Eastern Europe and Russia - countries that rely heavily upon external financing. Also interesting is their set of explanations for how emerging market financial institutions were hit so heavily last fall despite the fact that they weren't badly exposed to mature-market lenders. It shows very clearly how financial problems in one part of the world can filter throughout global credit markets quite easily.

Furthermore, there is a danger that emerging markets in need of financing will be "crowded out" by the now massive borrowing needs of the G7 countries. Despite the huge amounts of debt they are taking on, the returns on bonds of G7 countries are still fairly low, indicating that investors still consider them safer than the alternatives. One of those alternatives is, of course, emerging markets.

The good news, according to this report, is that financial surpluses from earlier growth is giving EM economies more space for counter-cyclical monetary and fiscal policies. Moreover, while the commodity boom-now-bust has hurt some (oil-producing) EM economies hard, it's making the recovery of other (oil-consuming) EM economies easier.

But overall, the report suggests that things are looking pretty fragile, particularly for governments with little or no access to international debt markets (Argentina, Venezuela, Ecuador, Hungary, and others). This means that there will be greater need for official lending from the IMF (which has already stepped up to the plate with a whole range of new programs) as well as financing from regional development banks and bilateral agreements.

So just as private lenders in G7 economies have seized up, leaving the responsibility for economic recovery upon the shoulders of governments, so it will have to be with EM economies. Let's just hope that our official lenders are up to the task. If not, they should be given the tools they require.

(Table taken from p.7 of quoted report)

Wednesday, 28 January 2009

Vladimir Putin: "Don't do as we do...we do it best!"

Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin used his podium at the World Economic Forum to attack the dollar's supremacy, skewer Wall Street bankers, and call for a new global energy paradigm. He also layed the smack down on Michael Dell.

But it was his warning against excessive state intervention in response to the global economic crisis that really caught my attention. His statement was, um, interesting:

"Excessive intervention in economic activity and blind faith in the state’s omnipotence is another possible mistake."

Huh. Putin, excessive intervention, blind faith in state's omnipotence. I feel like these things are related.

India Toys With Protectionism

For those you with short memories: a reminder about the G20 meeting from late 2008. Among the many fine words put forward following the November summit, there is one collection that seems worth revisiting. Declaration #13 reads (ahem):
We underscore the critical importance of rejecting protectionism and not turning inward in times of financial uncertainty. In this regard, within the next 12 months, we will refrain from raising new barriers to investment or to trade in goods and services, imposing new export restrictions, or implementing World Trade Organization (WTO) inconsistent measures to stimulate exports.
Given the near-universal consensus on the detrimental contagion effects that protectionist measures have on global trade and material well-being, this was not particularly earth-shattering. Still, it was nice to see our political leaders re-affirming their commitment to...

Oh bugger! it took only three days before we heard serious talk in America about bailing out the automotive industry. This was followed shortly by the lawmakers considering a "buy US steel provision" for TARP funds. Meanwhile, in China, there is the small matter of currency manipulation and using the fiscal stimulus plan to promote domestic industries.

Not to be outdone, India has stepped up to the protectionist plate (wicket?) to take a few swings. Yesterday, India's government banned Chinese toy imports for six months - all six which fall into the twelve month period of no-import barriers promised above. From Free Exchange:
What the [Indian] government is thinking is unclear. In a grave speech at the G20 meeting in November, India’s prime minister urged the group to "forestall any protectionist tendencies which always surface in times of recession". The G20 seems to take India seriously. But India doesn’t seem to feel the same way about the G20.
Unfortunately, the same can be said for many of the G20's members. Of course, if all Chinese toys posed a serious health hazard in some way maybe this could be justified. But is it likely that all Chinese toys are dangerous? If so, India's government should be presenting their evidence to the WTO, not taking the path of least domestic political resistance and implementing a complete ban. Incidentally, this is also the path towards a trade war with one of the world's largest exporters.

Now I'm guessing the toy industry does not represent a significant portion of China's GDP, but that's not really the point. As The Economist's in-depth look at the infamous Smoot-Hawley bill of 1930 made clear, the real damage comes from how such laws sour trade relations, leading to retaliatory effects. Just look at what happened last week with French cheese.

So let's leave aside for the moment how such actions undermine the G20 and provide yet further evidence for the calculated hypocrisy of our political leadership. The real danger is that tariffs/bans on stuffed kittens and fancy cheese are the first snowballs that kick off an avalanche of protectionism that smothers trade and damages geopolitical relations. It is precisely now, in this economic turmoil, when international cooperation is needed more than ever.

Monday, 26 January 2009

Monday was a really bad day for the global economy

Over 70,000 jobs were cut on what the FT calls "one of the gloomiest days in the global economic crisis so far". The size and global scale of the job losses are staggering. Raymond Torres of the ILO explained the situation in this way:

“We have a vicious circle of depression, where job losses lead to falling consumption, which lowers industrial confidence, which leads to less investment, which results in more job losses, and so on.”

As a recent masters graduate still looking for employment, that's some really bad news.

Monday Round-Up: Euro-trash & helicopter cash

- "The mood is going to be somewhat sober" at the Davos World Economic Forum this year, which starts on Wednesday. No kidding. In that vein, the WEF's opening speaker is someone not known for his overwhelmingly upbeat rhetoric: Vladimir Putin.

- John Hempton at Bronte Capital thinks we should stop fiddling around with metaphors and literally drop money from helicopters to induce inflation fears. Sure some people may accidentally die from the falling money packages, says John, but it might also induce consumer spending. Or, you know, cause foreign investors to dump all their US assets.

- A good discussion over at Free Exchange over whether the euro-zone is a modern day gold bloc - referring to the rigid constraints of the interwar gold standard that delayed economic recovery in 1930s Europe and beyond. The short answer is no, it is not. The takeaways:

"...because the break-up of the eurozone would involve unacceptable financial damage, the ECB and member governments are committed to the rescue of flailing national economies. Europe cannot allow Ireland or Spain to collapse, and so presumably, international capital will treat those states differently than they might Britain, which is stuck out there by its lonesome."
Moreover, the gold standard had no institutional equivalent of the ECB to help facilitate coordinated monetary easing - something that was a real sticking point. This doesn't mean the euro-zone is entirely in the clear, just that it has a set of challenges distinct from any historical precedent.

- Democracy woes from the pages of the WaPo: social unrest in Eastern Europe, and Bolivia's new constitution.

Sunday, 25 January 2009

That Was The Week That Was

Politique
-On Tuesday, Barack Obama became the 44th President of the United States. Or was it Wednesday? He swiftly moved to roll back the Bush years through executive orders on Guantanamo, interrogation, and foreign assistance. The President also named two high profile envoys to the middle east and south Asia, a signal that the State Department and America's "soft power" will lead US foreign policy.

-Israel completed its withdrawal from Gaza, days after both Israel and Hamas declared "unilateral" ceasefires. The death toll from the conflict is estimated at 1,300 Palestinians and 13 Israelis. In related news, the BBC came under intense pressure following its refusal to broadcast a Gaza aid appeal by the Disasters & Emergency Committee.

-The Prime Minister of Iceland, Geir Haarde, called a March general election and will not seek reelection. The Daily Mail (and many others) incorrectly labeled Haarde's government the "first in the world to be effectively brought down by the credit crunch." As Dave noted in December, Belgium's government was the first to fall under pressure directly stemming from the financial crisis.

Economia
-Negotiations over the US stimulus package intensified as Obama met with leaders from both parties to shape a consensus. The stimulus package will undoubtedly pass, but what will it look like: will it hit $1 trillion (many economists believe it must to be effective)? how large are the tax cuts (will Obama bend to his own party by limiting this political manoeuvre)? how many Republicans will ultimately be on board?

-Spain and Portugal were hit with downgrades this week, and the eurozone looks to be on the verge of a serious crisis of confidence. Following its second bail out of the banking sector and the Pound's sharp decline, is the UK in the firing line? Does Britain=Iceland?

-In a written statement to the Senate Finance Committee, US Treasury Secretary designate Timothy Geithner accused China of "manipulating" the renminbi. In a measured response, the Chinese government said Geithner's comments were "out of keeping with the facts", would undermine the global effort to combat the financial crisis, and could fuel protectionism. In other China news, year-on-year GDP growth slowed to 6.8% in the 4th quarter, the slowest pace in 7 years.

The Rest
-Holders Pompey crash out of the FA Cup, Arsenal are held at last year's finalists Cardiff City, and the Merseyside derby ends in a draw, setting up a 4th round replay. In other Prem news, Kaka's megadeal to Man City fell through and a Kuwaiti consortium's proposed takeover of Liverpool has reportedly collapsed.

-In other sporting news, the disturbing balkanization of grand slam tennis.

-Affirming Dave's "political economy theory of fashion", Milan fashion week reflected the economic downturn, with the suit notably absent from many collections.

-The 81st Academy Awards nominations were announced in Los Angeles. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button lead the pack with 13 nominations, followed by Slumdog Millionaire with 10.

-Blackberry addicts the world over are scrambling to get their hands on the "Barackberry", after the US President finally wins his battle to stay connected in the White House. The NSA-enhanced device will have two "modes": one for personal contact with a tiny group of family and friends, another for official communications with a small circle of advisors and officials.

Saturday, 24 January 2009