Friday, 15 January 2010

Efficient Markets Hypothesis: Further Reading

We've seen an uptick in traffic to the site today thanks to Matt Yglesias' reference to the ketchup economics post from a while back. If anyone is interested in exploring this topic further, try reading this discussion of the efficient markets hypothesis.

The challenge for the ketchupal economists is not an abstract one: it affects business execs, government bureaucrats, and huge sections of the financial industry on a regular basis. When attempting to quantify the something as complex as the marketplace, you leave yourself vulnerable to the unquantifiable & the unforseen. For more, see this post about the pretence of knowledge.

(Alternatively, if you're more interested in all things ketchup, I'm sad to say we've got that covered as well: see here and here.)

Wednesday, 13 January 2010

How to help the Haitian people and relief effort

The human and physical damage caused by the 7.0 earthquake in Haiti yesterday looks to be absolutely devastating. By some accounts the entire capital of Port-Au-Prince is leveled. The presidential palace and UN mission headquarters are gone. The prime minister believes the death-toll has already surpassed 100,000, while a leading senator says the final number could be over 500,000. The problem in a country like Haiti, as they both acknowledged, is that we may never really know. The tsunami in 2004 was a level of natural destruction we had never seen in modern times, and judging by the early indications this earthquake could surpass it in a much more concentrated area.

For any of our readers in the United States who are wondering how they can assist the relief effort, I have found two prominent and active organizations moving provide immediate relief to Haiti: the American Red Cross' International Response Fund, which is pledging an immediate effort of at least $200,000, and UNICEF's US page, an organization that focuses on the most vulnerable in a crisis like this, the children.

I encourage everyone to look into how they can help the situation in Haiti, however small or remote that effort might be.

Correction: The American Red Cross has pledged an initial $1 million, far more than the $200,00 figure I found this morning. Also, if you are in the US and want to donate $10 to the Red Cross' Haiti effort, you can text message the word 'Haiti' to 90999. The donation will be reflected as a charge on your cell phone bill.

Monday, 11 January 2010

The Curious Case of Benjamin Bernanke

Bernanke's speech in Atlanta last week spread throughout the blogosphere like wild fire, and the reaction was not positive. The Fed chief defended US monetary policy in the run-up to the financial crisis and claimed that lax regulation, not interest rates, inflated the housing bubble. A chairman of the Fed defending the bank's record and competence against a backdrop of political hostility and regulatory reform is not surprising. Bernanke's position that prolonged low interest rates played no role in the housing bubble is more so.

But after reading the Fed staff working paper that accompanied Bernanke's speech, the folks at Free Exchange believe that, interest rate correlation aside, the Fed's worldview has been quietly transformed. The Fed's analysis featured three names: Shiller, Kindleberger and Minsky. For those unfamiliar with these men, they are three of most prominent advocates of the idea that markets are imperfect, unstable and subject to psychology (hence the title of Kindleberger's book Manias, Panics and Crashes). This is downright antithetical to the Fed's prevailing ideology, and their acceptance could represent an important shift in the Fed's understanding of markets and its role in influencing them. I can assure you that Alan Greenspan would have neither reached nor endorsed their conclusions, and a search of the Fed's website by Free Exchange found only two previous references to Minsky and just one to Kindleberger.

Paul Krugman agrees with Bernanke that there were compelling reasons for 2002-2006 monetary policy. But this doesn't mean that the policy didn't contribute to the housing bubble, or that the Fed failed to act on the warning signs. Krugman faults Bernanke for not acknowledging the inadequacies of the Fed's prevailing wisdom before the crisis and admitting that they all missed the housing bubble. On this measure his speech was disappointing, particularly for those of us who support a second-term. But by digging beneath the headlines, Free Exchange has highlighted an important shift in the Fed's institutional understanding of markets, regulation and monetary policy, one that is hopefully diffused throughout the policy and academic establishment.

Venezuela Update!

Venezuela has taken the "war on inflation" to a new level (via DeLong):

"Hugo Chávez, Venezuela’s president, on Sunday threatened to deploy troops and expropriate businesses that increase their prices following a steep devaluation of the currency on Friday.... Go ahead and speculate if you want, but we will take your business away and give it to the workers, to the people,” he said, stating there was no reason for businesses to raise prices."

Hmm, expropriation by the government for the good of the people.... Maintaining that level of doublespeak must be exhausting. More likely, this money will be used by the government to pay back foreign creditors.

I gather that Venezuela's currency had been overvalued for quite some time, so this is a good news for Venezuela's revenues from oil exports, on which it relies for about 30% of GDP. That very same GDP contracted by about 3% last year.

Unfortunately for regular Venezuelans, this means that their personal savings have been devalued along with the currency, and those lovely imported DVD players are going to be more expensive. But that's okay! because you can't use a DVD player if you don't have any electricity!

Thursday, 7 January 2010

Blog Upgrades

We've just added a visitor map widget (over there --->) that plots the IP addresses of visitors to the blog on a map of the world. Cool! Sure beats doing it manually.

It will start updating shortly, so tell your friends.

A Reminder, Revisited

(Our look back at 2009 is stretching out into January a little, but I'm not quite finished with the stock-taking exercise. Our soap box, our rules)

Around this time last year, I pointed out that, if nothing else, 2008 drove home a fundamental lesson of IPE: the economy drives politics. Many of the best laid plans of early 2008 were sucked down the toilet along with the global economy, leading to some surprising outcomes.

My question for 2009 was therefore: how hard would politics push back? Because push back it did: countries that once championed free market principles quickly turned inward in order to protect their interests and respond to popular outrage. Let's have a look back:

Protectionism
As discussed below, the spectre of protectionism was haunting us early in 2009. In Britain, we suddenly saw shades of populist xenophobia from Gordon Brown (pray tell us, Gord, what exactly constitutes a British worker? shall we ask the BNP?). In the USA there was the noxious "Buy American" clause, the auto-bailout, and some other hilarious examples. India banned Chinese toys for six months. But the most gregarious example of all comes from China itself: the undervaluation of the yuan, and its consequences for everyone else, is probably the biggest protectionist story of the year.

Tobin Tax
While not exactly a crackpot policy proposal, the Tobin Tax (explained here) is still a bad idea. Unfortunately, because it was re-introduced by Lord Turner of the FSA in a widely-publicized report, it got a lot of media play. Thankfully, the US made it clear that they weren't interested so the idea was stillborn (er, maybe not).

[Don't get me wrong - sometimes capital controls are a good idea, especially for emerging markets facing massive inflows of capital, but more on that later.]

Pay czars! Wait, Pay czars?
Somehow the use of the term "czar" here just doesn't inspire confidence. Here we have liberal, democratic, relatively free and competitive societies appointing pay czars to set limits on the compensation of a particular subset of society. I get that skewed pay incentives led to excessive risk-taking, but there were much bigger factors at play.

However, as one astute observer pointed out, the job description of the pay czar is not to curb bankers' pay but rather to curb public anger at bankers' pay. I hope it worked, since I'll bet there were some Frenchmen dusting off their guillotines... just in case.

SuperTax 2009
Further caving to popular anger, the UK and France introduced the SuperTax 2009. I feel no sympathy for the uber-rich bankers traveling in their Mercedes to the Human Rights Tribunal to plead their case. But why stop at bankers? You should at least be consistent.

We Still Like Capitalism, Though, Right?

Taking the long view, capitalism has been a resounding success for humanity. It is the single biggest poverty-killer in history. But as we have seen, the free market is a fragile thing, and prone to excesses. These excesses produce backlash, and the backlash can be severe.

We need only ask John Maynard Keynes, a first-hand observer of how bad the backlash can be. An astute observer of history and human psychology, Keynes had the following to say about pre-WWI Europe:
The power to become habituated to his surroundings is a marked characteristic of mankind. Very few of us realize with conviction the intensely unusual, unstable, complicated, unreliable, temporary nature of the economic organization by which Western Europe has lived for the last half century. We assume some of the most peculiar and temporary of our late advantages as natural, permanent, and to be depended on, and we lay our plans accordingly.
Those advantages collapsed spectacularly in 1914. We spent the next seven decades sorting out the mess. Now, I'm not suggesting that pay czars and supertaxes are the first steps towards a return to communism or fascism or whatever - not by a long shot. But try to remember how unlikely those things would have seemed a couple of years ago. Things change in a hurry.

The lesson that I take from all of this is as follows: the liberal market economy is a fragile social experiment - it is not a naturally occurring phenomenon. We need to keep this message in the back of our minds as we take stock of recent events. This little project of ours requires safeguarding, not hysterics. So let's tone down the ideology and tone down the populism and instead focus on pragmatic ways to keep it going a little longer.

Thursday Readables

- Britons decidedly skeptical of global warming. Children are thrilled; Arsenal fans less so.

- Dispatches from countries that do not exist. "I had my leg propped up on a dark wooden desk and was wincing at the sting of a vigorous alcohol-swabbing by the health minister himself. I was not accustomed to such personalized government service. Fake countries have to try harder, I thought." Outstanding.

- Remember Calvinball? Meet something similar, but more sinister: Terrorball. This game has only two rules: (1) the game continues until there are no terrorists left, and (2) if the terrorists manage to kill, injure or seriously frighten anyone, they win.

- Finally, the chart of the day: the accuracy of economic forecasts from the past decade (or not). Unfortunately, this little graph doesn't tell you who'se forecasts are being plotted, what the forecast time-periods were, or even what the Y-axis represents (GDP, presumably) - so its credibility is suspect. Nevertheless, it vizualizes an important point about market forecasters (or forecasters of almost any kind): they're usually wrong. Forecasts huddle around the median, reality does not.

So the next time a professional economist, government official or IPE blogger offers you a specific forecast - do yourself a favour and ignore them. (...then go read this book!)

Wednesday, 6 January 2010

Quick hits and pink picks: Shooting yourself in the foot edition

-A leadership challenge to Gordon Brown has once again thrown Labour into disarray, just as the party managed to reverse the Tory poll momentum. Who knew British politics could be so fun! (Update: he has survived, again...)

-The president of Iceland, a country on a fast-track to EU accession, has refused to sign off on legislation that would have repaid the UK and Netherlands some $5.5 bn lost in failed 'Icesave' accounts. He has instead decided to put the matter to a referendum. The move seriously jeopardizes Iceland's EU prospects and threatens to further isolate the tiny nation. The economy minister says the referendum decision has effectively put on hold both the country's IMF program and any decision to lift capital controls. Ouch.

-Argentina's president has fired the president of the central bank over his refusal to back a government plan to tap the country's $48 billion reserves to pay off $6.6 bn in debt this year. One problem: Martin Redrado says he won't go! He says the power to fire the central bank chief rests with Congress and he has no plans on going. Further, the man tapped by Fernandez de Kirchner to replace Redrado, former central bank president Mario Blejer, has declined the offer. Blejer resigned in 2002 due to government interference in the bank's independence. Argentina has finally been making progress in negotiations with defaulted creditors who refused the previous government's offer to renegotiate their portion of the $95 bn 2001 debt default, and was aiming to return to international markets this year for the first time in nearly a decade. The president's intervention does little to bolster the confidence Argentina has taken so long to recover.

Tuesday, 5 January 2010

Chart of the day: World Trade in 2009

In our year in review of economics, I deliberately left out any discussion of trends in world trade for 2009. This was because, frankly, I couldn't find any information to use. Luckily, there is Mike Mandel to the rescue (via Felix Salmon):




So the IMF figures we're back to where we were in 2003. Great.

Sunday, 3 January 2010

That Was The Year That Was: Economia

"The best that can be said for 2009 is that it could have been worse" - Joseph Stiglitz, in China Daily

That pretty much sums it up right there. I have been looking through some of our posts from late '08 and early '09 and things looked pretty grim on a number of fronts. But the year did not turn out quite as badly as it could have. Let's have a look back at some notable items from the world of economics in 2009, shall we?

Some Statistics from 2009
# of US banks shuttered by the FDIC: 136; the current yield on a 1-year US Treasury bond: 0.00%; China's government stimulus package: 4 trillion yuan ($586 billion); inflation of the gold bubble this year: 27%; IIF's projected decline in foreign direct investment to emerging market economies in 2009: 82%; Actual decline as of October 2009: about 30%; IIF's prediction for 2010: probably worth ignoring entirely; The Economist's global public debt clock as of today: $32,052,820,000 (or thereabouts).

Protectionism
When we started our year, the threat of protectionism loomed large in many different countries. We've seen some bad examples throughout 2009 - government-sponsored stimulus packages being probably the worst offenders - but I suspect the above quote from Stiglitz applies here. We can find a number of protectionist anecdotes that make us shake our heads, but it doesn't appear to be systemic. Encouragingly, the G20 at least got the right language in their public statements, even if they haven't followed it to the letter.

The G20's extraordinary economic intervention

Surpassing my wildest expectations, the G20 has proven itself to be something other than a complete waste of time. The members of the G20 have shown themselves to be genuinely interested in making a crack at international cooperation on economic affairs - albeit with the usual cases of counter-productive grandstanding by leaders for their domestic political purposes. Granted, the "trillion dollars" of stimulus money pledged by the G20 in April may have been fudged a little, but the perception that governments were willing to step up and do something probably helped counter the deep-seated uncertainty felt by markets and citizens across the globe.

In all likelihood, the G20's accomplishments will be less about the big numbers and rhetorical posturing of the summits, and more about the incremental changes made by sub-bodies. Take the Financial Stability Board which, despite sharing an acronym with Russia's domestic security services, may prove to be quite useful. The FSB, like the IMF, has been tasked with some of the heavy lifting for the G20: strengthening regulatory standards, developing principles for compensation practices, and monitoring "exit strategies." They will also likely play a role, alongside the IMF, in the G20's efforts to conduct peer-review evaluations of each other's financial policies starting in 2010. Something to watch for.

Return of growth or govt life support?
Many of the economies of the world officially exited recessions my mid- to late-2009. These stats are always subject to later revision, but the overall point - that things did not get profoundly worse for economic growth - is the take home message. Of course, what's unclear is whether this growth will sustain itself when governments begin to ease off the stimulus measures. Moreover, the focus on overall GDP growth ignores the fact that unemployment rates have skyrocketed in many countries.

Macroimbalances
A running theme throughout the year was the dynamic between the US's efforts to re-balance their chronic deficits with China's efforts to continue export-led growth with an under-valued currency. Pressure on China has been growing throughout the year and will continue into the next.

Public Debt

Really piled up.

Some Losers
American auto-makers (esp. GMAC and Chrysler); traditional newspapers; global trade & Mother Nature (casualties of shifting priorities); Gordon Brown (policies as finance minister came home to roost); the US dollar (losing relative clout to China, maybe); frozen waffles & the Icelandic BigMac.

Some Winners

Gold, Goldman Sachs (God's work is apparently quite lucrative); Gordon Brown (crisis has temporarily breathed new life into premiership); IMF (relevant & better resourced); Ben Bernanke; and crackpot populist economic measures

That Was the Decade That Was: the long view

In looking back at the past decade, most commentators have forfeited any meaningful narrative in favor of the proverbial 'better luck next time.' But if the following trends are taken in toto, the past decade in the markets looks downright revolutionary:

-The S&P500 fell 24%, its worst performance since the 1930s, FTSE down 7.3%, DJIA down 9.3%, Nikkei down a massive 44% over the past ten years. Contrast that with the major emerging markets: Russia's Micex index hit the moon with an astounding 802% rise, Brazil's Bovespa jumped 301%, India's Sensex rose 249% and the Shanghai Composite closed 140% higher.

-The benchmark Nymex crude oil contract ended the decade up 210%, but the story in between is among the most volatile in memory. Oil closed out 1999 at $25.60 a barrel, hit $147.27 in July 2008 and ended 2009 at $79.36.

-Spot gold closed the decade up 281%, while copper ended 290% higher.

-Two major stories in the currency markets: the dollar's long decline and the euro's rise to viability. The dollar ended the decade down 23.5% on a trade weighted basis, while the euro gained 43% on the dollar.

So what can we extrapolate from the data above? The 'rise of the rest' is the defining trend of the past decade; loose monetary policy contributed to a great capital flight from developed market equities; the dollar's long relative decline has eroded the US' influence internationally and will shape the coming decade as much as any other trend (politically, financially and economically); emerging market industrialization made commodities a really, really good bet; and precious metals retained their mystical aura in uncertain times.

If you ask people in China, India and Brazil for their impressions of the past decade, I suspect you'll get a more positive consensus than 'good riddance.'

Friday, 1 January 2010

Progress

As usual, The Economist's year-end issue is sweeping and engaging. Its lead article, 'Onwards and Upwards: Why is the modern view of progress so impoverished?' is the paper at its absolute best.

Happy new year.