Tuesday, 18 November 2008

Thoughts on Blogging

Willem Buiter - LSE prof and former Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee member - explains why he writes his blog for the FT:

There are minor vanity/ego rents to having people read what I write, and my consulting income may receive an indeterminate boost from these activities. But all that is secondary to my need to write. I don’t know something unless I have written it down.
I agree completely. Too bad I can't guarantee the opposite relationship: just because I've written it down...

Monday, 17 November 2008

Thomas Friedman on the auto bail-out

I don't read Thomas Friedman that often. I always found his "flat-world" theory to be lacking an appreciation for the asymmetries in the international political economy. I think a world of "peaks and valleys" is a more appropriate image. But who am I? Friedman's sold a billion books, won multiple Pulitzers, and is rumored to garner circa $50,000 per speaking engagement. Obviously, he's doing something right.

But I do read Dave Hart (regularly in fact), whose great piece on the Big-3 got me traversing the internets for opinion on the prospects of an automotive bailout. This led me to Friedman, whose recent media crusade against the US auto industry I find spot on. His 11/11/08 NYT column, "How to Fix a Flat", sums up his criticism of the US Big-3 automakers:

for years, executives, lobbyists, and Congress (in particular the Michigan delegation) have sheltered these companies from the need to innovate or die. The have been allowed to resist higher environmental and fuel-efficiency standards, and implement bone-headed strategies that prioritized the SUV over hybrid or smaller, fuel-efficient vehicles. And now, as their business model, balance sheets, and beloved SUVs are forcing them into bankruptcy, these companies feel entitled to a taxpayer-funded bail-out?

I share Friedman's (admittedly, everyone's) outrage. I recognize the risks to the real-economy of their bankruptcy. Millions of workers (if you include suppliers) would lose their jobs in a period of rapidly rising unemployment and deflation. I also believe that the sensible arguments against Chapter 11 are important: in the current credit environment, Chapter 11 restructuring might be impossible, giving way to Chapter 7 and the worst-case scenario. But what is the chance that these companies will be compelled into any of the necessary restructuring in exchange for further financial assistance? Remember, the US government has been bailing these bozos out for decades, and what have we received in return? Sasquatch.

As Clusterstock pointed out, a short/medium-term cost benefit analysis might fall in favor of a bail-out. But what then? The shield that would be erected around these three posterchilds of protectionism would take decades to dismantle. The union contracts would remain largely in tact (not a chance Dems are jeopardizing the Rust Belt in 2010)*. CAFE standards are already (predictably) being vilified by the auto companies.

The US economy can't afford an industry collapse. But taxpayers can't afford another waisted bailout. If they agree to the thorough concessions and restructuring Friedman and Ingrassia call for, then bail em out. If they don't, let creative destruction work, and follow Friedman's advice. Allow Chapter 11, compel independent administration, and set these companies toward a restructuring process long overdue. One company might go into bankruptcy, but like the investment banks after Lehman, the others will quickly fall in line and accept strict conditions to assistance.

We must also renegotiate the contracts of remaining workers (on fair terms- whatever those are), increase unemployment benefits, and retrain those who are laid off in green jobs or re-employ them in a massive infrastructure-based stimulus project. And how about universal health care reform as well?

We need the political will (finally) to confront the auto industry and dictate the terms of assistance. This means confronting their stubborness head on. It may be risky, but its a risk worth taking.

Vikram Pandit's unconventional pep talk

I woke up this morning to the following headline on the front page of my Financial Times:

"Pandit's Pep Talk: Citigroup boss calls a 'town hall' meeting aimed at restoring morale of 350,000 staff".

Make that 300,000 staff. So much for morale.

Sunday, 16 November 2008

Bretton Woods, the G20 and the International Financial Architecture

As most well-informed observers were stressing all week, yesterday's G20 meeting in Washington was not going to lead to new financial architecture for the global economic system. "Bretton Woods, the Sequel," this ain't. For one, it was not taking place in the New Hampshire hotel after which the original conference was named (see photo). For two, this meeting was not complemented by several years of preparatory groundwork or by unilateral American leadership coming on the heels of a paradigm-shifting depression and world war. So maybe Mr. Brown and Mr. Sarkozy were getting ahead of themselves with all of their blustery rhetoric.

Now, as is expected for these types of events, the G20 meeting produced a declaration (available here) that contained a fair bit of vague language on what the world leaders are going to do to a) address the current crisis and b) fortify the financial architecture to prevent a repeat performance. But the meeting did produce one, large, significant shift in the way our global economy will be governed in the near future: the G20 appears to have taken over from the outdated G7/G8. On this point, the punditry appears to be unanimous. This is important because the G20 includes powerful emerging economies like Brazil, China, India, Indonesia and Turkey.

This shift is long overdue, but will necessarily make international negotiations that much more difficult. As I alluded to above, the successful completion of the original B.Woods in 1944 was in large part due to the ability of the United States to push its agenda forward unilaterally. Had the Brits not been so crippled by the war, they surely would not have ratified the agreement. It should be clear that, 60 years on, there remain important philosophical differences between the Americans and Europeans on financial governance. Insert China and India into the mix and things become more complicated. But global financial governance is complicated and excluding these countries is a non-starter.

The agenda for the G20 membership from now until the next meeting in April 2009 is to make progress on a number of fronts. Highlights:

- Reform of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund to be more representative of the distribution of economic power (not new).

- Expand the membership of the Financial Stability Forum to include G20 members (relatively new). The FSF is a body that combines governments and international regulatory agencies to establish "best practices" in everything from accounting to insurance.

- Members have agreed to undergo a financial checkup by the IMF and increase funding for IMF lending programs to crisis-stricken countries (that's right, the IMF is relevant again).

- Various other sensible, but hardly revolutionary, promises to beef up financial supervision.

- And finally, a promise to deal with the fact that the Doha round of trade negotiations is dead. It has ceased to be. Bereft of life, it rests in peace. It's bleeding demised. It has rung down the curtain and joined the choir invisible...

Saturday, 15 November 2008

That Was The Week That Was

Politique
-G20 leaders arrived in Washington for a summit that had been hailed Bretton Woods II. With President-elect Obama avoiding the summit, and sharp differences between world leaders on the reforms needed to repair the international financial and economic systems, the summit ends like so many before it- with a consensus on principles, little coordinated action, and an agreement to meet again. Declaration text here.

-A regional war looms as the situation in the DRC deteriorates. African peacekeepers are impotent and declared targets by Nkunda, the number of foreign troops/mercenaries in the country grows by the day, and southern African leaders are threatening full-scale military involvement. The NYT looks at the role of minerals in the DRC's history of conflict.

-The EU agreed to restart talks on a strategic partnership agreement with Russia following an EU/Russian summit at Nice. Russia hasn't met the EU conditions set out as a prerequisite to talks following the conflict in Georgia, and it seems only Lithuania has the spine to say so.

-Iraq's cabinet approves new security pact with the US. The agreement extends US troop mandate through 2011.

Economia
-Paulson shocks congress with plan to spend remaining TARP money on capital injections into troubled institutions and companies and consumer spending. The Treasury will no longer purchase illiquid assets, and congressmen/women of both parties are screaming "bait and switch". Paulson deputy Kashkari testified before an angry House, with Rep. Elijah Cummings asking him, "Is Kashkari a Chump?"

-Treasury v. FDIC. FDIC's Bair wants to directly assist 1.5 million homeowners in the US, while Paulson resists a (*cough-cough*) "government spending program"- Paulson believes that his actions are "investments".

-Is a sterling run imminent? That's what George Osborne, Tory shadow chancellor, implied this week in criticizing Gordon Brown's fiscal plans. Osborne's political career is likely done. Sterling has hit a 6-year low against the dollar at $1.49, and Simon Derrick at BoNY Mellon believes sterling's position is now worse than Sept. 1992.

-Eurozone enters its first official recession.

The Rest
-India celebrates first lunar landing.

-This week in Japanese innovation: a robot that feeds you, and bionic legs.

-Arsenal's Prem title run is dead in the water.

-Gordon Brown: control freak.

Thursday, 13 November 2008

Creative Destruction: Automotive Edition

The shares of General Motors, America's largest automaker, are now worth less than those of Goodyear. In a sense, GM is now worth less than the sum of its part. This is bad news, not only for those employed by GM, but for everyone who is even remotely concerned about the government throwing caution to the wind and bailing out uncompetitive, politically-sensitive industries.

You see, GM and the rest of the Big Three are vying for public funds to keep them out of bankruptcy, or at least to keep them functional during a bankruptcy. For some firms, like United Airlines, it is possible to enter into bankruptcy proceedings and resume flights a short time later. However, unlike with commercial aviation, car consumers are looking at shelling out anywhere from $20-70K for a vehicle with the expectation that the firm will be there five, ten years down the road to provide ongoing support. The worry is that, should GM, Chrysler or Ford enter into Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings, consumer confidence will plummet and they will never recover. Kaput.

Unlike the airline edition of this series, I have nothing personally riding on the outcome of this bailout debate. Nevertheless, the principle is the same. If a firm with as many assets as an enormous automotive company cannot receive financing, there's got to be a good reason. In fact, there are two good reasons. The first is that, due to the credit crunch, financial institutions are currently de-leveraging their liabilities and are thus unwilling to take on a large-scale financing project of this nature.

The second, more relevant, reason is that these firms have been operating under a failing business strategy for at least a decade. These companies are simply uncompetitive: they have over-priced, lower-quality vehicles (pickups excepted), silly-expensive labour union deals and are failing to adjust to environmental concerns.

Moreover, this bailout plan smacks of thinly-disguised politicking. It is a well established fact that the Big Three have considerable traction in Washington, and a Democrat-dominated legislature tends to lean towards protectionism on these issues. In any event, we'll find out on Monday how this one is going to play out. In the meantime, some questions to ponder and some readables to read.

Question first: Do the Big Three pose systemic risk for the economy in the same way that Bear Stearns or AIG do? If not, why are they being considered under TARP?

Question second: Should the government finance GM's bankruptcy, do they have any prospect of getting their money back?

Yet more questions: For a considerable chunk of the electorate (and thus a considerable chunk of politicians), defending the Big Three is equivalent to defending American industry. But what is an American car anyway? If it's a Ford minivan made in Windsor, Ontario with Japanese parts, does it count? What if it's a Honda made in Ohio? Or that Mercedes engine plant in Alabama?

Links
- FT Alphaville thinks we've moved past moral hazard into a barely-concealed sense of entitlement. Nobody "deserves" a bailout.
- GM wants a bailout? Clusterstock lays out their conditions.
- Clusterstock responds with a counter to its own argument.

Opening material sourced from Planet Money.

Vladimir Putin wanted to hang Saakashvili by the b*lls

The Times of London has published the leaked details of a conversation between French President Nicolas Sarkozy and Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin in Moscow on August 12th. Sarkozy had flown to Moscow to broker a ceasefire between Russia and Georgia, and Putin made his ultimate goal clear. The following is an excerpt from the Times article:

Mr Sarkozy was aware from intelligence reports that the Russian army was aiming to overthrow Mr Saakashvili and install a puppet government. He told Mr Putin that the world would not accept this, according to Mr Levitte, Mr Sarkozy's foreign policy chief, who was in the Kremlin for the talks.

"I am going to hang Saakashvili by the balls," Mr Putin replied.

Mr Sarkozy responded: "Hang him?"

"Why not? The Americans hanged Saddam Hussein," said Mr Putin.

Mr Sarkozy replied, using the familiar "tu": "Yes but do you want to end up like (President) Bush?" Mr Putin was briefly lost for words, then replied: "Ah, you have scored a point there."

Wow. It is rare that the private conversations of heads of state are leaked to the public, and really suprising that the French would do so just days before Sarkozy chairs an EU-Russian summit in Nice (ironically, the scene of one of France's biggest diplomatic blunders of the past decade- see EC Nice Summit of 2000). There is little utility in angering/embarassing the Russians ahead of a vital strategic meeting, and the leak can probably be chalked up to Sarko's super ego.
Back in August, I argued that Saakashvili would not survive the conflict. I thought that Russia's intentions were clear, and was both wrong and surprised when the Georgian President survived. The credit for this may very well go to Sarko. But if this conversation highlights anything, it is that the situation in Georgia is fragile. I seriously doubt that Putin's feelings have changed, and given the evidence that Georgia may have been more of an agressor in the conflict than it claimed, it will take very little for the Russian Prime Minister to finish the job.

IEA Report, Russia/China pipeline agreement, and the European Energy Security Plan

A number of important developments in the global energy markets over the past few weeks:

-an IEA report finds that the world's oil output is declining at a rapid pace. The annual rate of decline is projected at 9.1% without a substantial increase in upstream investment. Even after recent investment, output from the world's largest oil fields is falling by over 6%. As my analysis of Russian energy production highlighted, an increase in upstream investment is neither easy nor probable. Falling global demand will only lessen the incentive to invest more in production. With little excess capacity, and OPEC voluntarily cutting production (potentially by millions of barrels of day more in the coming months), the global oil markets risk renewed volatility when demand recovers.

-Russia and China signed a landmark oil pipeline agreement on October 28th. The addition to the East Siberia-Pacific ocean trunk pipeline could ultimately carry up to 15 million tons of Russian oil to China per year. The agreement is significant on two levels: it signals Russia's desire to pursue the "China alternative", and it could portend a greater financial role for China in Russia's energy sector.

-finally, we might look back on October 13th as the beginning of a new era in European energy. The Times of London is reporting that the bloc will announce a European Energy Security Plan. The plan calls for: 1) the construction of a European supergrid, connecting power grids from North Sea wind farms to the Baltics, 2) the construction of two new gas pipelines, connecting Caspian and African gas to the bloc, and 3) a "Community Gas Ring", which would essentially allow for the pooling of European gas supplies in the event of supply disruptions. These measures will directly address import diversification (particularly in natural gas, and specifically away from Russia), security of supply issues, and fragmented national power grids.

This is a highly ambitious plan, and in my opinion, one that has absolutely no chance of being carried out in its entirety. The pipelines just aren't commercially viable yet. Furthermore, the national regulatory and interest-group challenges to EU-wide liberalization in the energy sector are formidable, and to date have blocked any substantive effort towards a single European energy market. The political will simply isn't there in France/Germany/Italy, and national interests always trump regional considerations in European energy. Despite my pessimism, the Plan is an important development, if for only one reason: it coincides with the resumption of talks between the EU and Russia over their economic and energy relationship. It looks like the EU may have finally come around to playing hard ball with Russia, and utilizing its leverage over Russian security of demand. Stay tuned for updates on these discussions over the coming weeks.

Wednesday, 12 November 2008

Do you like to read?

Princeton University Press is having a book sale.

Really, AmEx? Really?

American Express, which recently converted into a bank holding company, plans to ask the US government for $3.5bn under the TARP.

AmEx relies on packaging credit card debt into securitized debt instruments it then sells on to investors. Obviously, this market is gone. Amex now has a serious cash flow problem, making it difficult to, among other things, service its debt.

Really, AmEx? So your cash flow has disappeared, you are having trouble surviving and servicing your debt, and you think that someone should be there to bail you out? You know, cause its not really your fault that you can't service your debt, you are just the victim of extreme circumstances. Really?

Monday, 10 November 2008

Lest We Forget


November 11th is one of the most important days of the year and one of the few occasions when I am unashamedly and emotionally patriotic. But it is a very different kind of patriotism that we are celebrating. Rather than glorifying past military successes, Remembrance Day (or Veteran's Day) emphasizes the human cost of our victories, our mistakes, and our freedoms. This can only be a healthy exercise.

But lest we forget that many of our soldiers are currently engaged in a number of hostile environments, here's a sobering PBS documentary on the deteriorating situation in Afghanistan. (Be warned: it contains very raw images). These are the soldiers that will make up the next generation of veterans and, sadly, the next generation of headstone engravings. It is much too soon for Afghanistan to have earned the nickname "the forgotten war."

I will direct my Canadian readers to this list, and this article.

(Photo: Towers Library, St. Andrew's College)

Fitch Downgrades Bulgaria, Hungary, Kazakhstan, Romania

It also revised its outlook to "negative" for the long-term foreign currency ratings of South Korea, Mexico, Russia, and South Africa. From the FT:

David Riley, head of Fitch’s global sovereign ratings group, said: “The profound deterioration in the global economic and financial outlook poses significant threats to the emerging markets. The developed economies are heading for the biggest slowdown in 25 years and this will have a big impact on trade with emerging markets.

“Capital and financial flows to the emerging markets are going to be restricted and more expensive, with those countries with high current account deficits and large external funding needs most exposed.”

It is incredible how silly all the talk of "decoupling" looks now.