Friday, 26 November 2010

Discouraging Thought of the Day: Perception vs. Activism

David Brooks, writing in the NYT on the centennial of Leo Tolstoy's death:

"As a novelist, Tolstoy was an unsurpassed observer. But he found that life unfulfilling. As he set out to improve the world, his ability to perceive it deteriorated. Instead of conforming his ideas to the particularities of existence, he conformed his perception of reality to his vision for the world. He preached universal love but seemed oblivious to the violence he was doing to his family."

Well. THAT's discouragingly accurate.

You can have clarity of observation, or you can set out to change the world, but not both simultaneously. It's the quantum physics of social activism.

Of course this applies not only to activists but do-ers of all kinds. As Cohen rightly suggests, the memoirs of political leaders tend to be skewed not (simply) because of attempts at whitewash, "but because they’ve been engaged in an activity that makes it impossible for them to see it clearly. Activism is admirable, necessary and self-undermining." Go watch The Fog of War if you doubt this.

This is also what occasionally makes business leaders very poor judges of economic policy (see here, for example).

But this is very bad news indeed for newly-minted grad students who are setting out to change the world.

Hmmm...

Best to start a blog instead.

Wednesday, 17 November 2010

Readables

- About a week old, but this is one of the best pieces I've read in a while. Follow-up is here.

- The, um, wanker-bankers have conned the Biffo Bunch

- Quantitative easing, explained. The Ben Bernank does not come off well

- Here is a better explanation of QEII. Here is another

- In related news, core inflation falls to record low.

Tuesday, 9 November 2010

Yeah, What Brad DeLong Said

In case you missed it, Bob Zoellick, the head of the World Bank, was pontificating in the FT this week about the merits of returning to some sort of gold peg for currencies. DeLong, in his typically understated fashion, shoots him down hard.

Without passing any particular judgement on Zoellick's mental faculties, I think it's fair to say that suggesting a return to the gold standard in any format is a bad idea no matter who is suggesting it. But like some form macroeconomic acne, the idea of the gold standard keeps popping back up in periods of stress. For example, see my comments on Gillian Tett's misguided op-ed in the FT last year.

At the time I argued that, using the same logic, an economy run by squirrels would use an acorn standard. Why? Because they like nuts, silly. This analogy is even more apt that I had initially realized: much like humans and gold, squirrels spend a lot of time and energy scurrying around gathering up acorns - only to promptly bury them back underground.

Where the analogy breaks down is that acorns actually have an intrinsic value (nutrition), whereas gold does not have much intrinsic value at all. Its skyrocketing price is the result of investors (and here I'm quoting DeLong again) "using gold as a speculative asset and a hedge. They are not using it [as] a medium of exchange, a unit of account, or a safe store of nominal value."

As if this weren't damning enough, a return to a gold peg wouldn't even address the global imbalances problem. It would merely shift it around: US and European central banks own some 50% of the world's gold reserves. Hmmmmm. One suspects that if Saudi Arabia was the dominant world economy, we might be hearing ideas about an oil standard. This at least would have the added benefit of being a highly liquid asset. (HA!)

Seriously folks: this is gauling. All the more so because the gold standard is one of those rare phenomena in economics where it's not a theoretical debate. We've tested it out. It doesn't bloody work.

With so many potentially bad ideas floating around about how to fix the world economy, there's absolutely no reason why we need keep discussing the one we know for sure will be a disaster. 

UPDATE: Zoellick clarifies his comments: "Gold is now being viewed as an alternative monetary asset. This is not the same as a gold standard,” said Mr Zoellick. “Gold has become a reference point because holders of money see weak or uncertain growth prospects in all currencies other than the renminbi, and the renminbi is not free for exchange. So, in relative terms, gold is appealing to people who ask where should I put my money. It is a hedge against uncertainty.”

Well alright. Nevermind then, Bob: I forgive you. But just so we're clear: "a hedge against uncertainty" is not the same thing as an alternative monetary asset, mmk?

Thursday, 7 October 2010

Hayek's Road to Serfrom

One of the hot topics of the week is evaluating the merit of Hayek's Road to Serfdom. I read this book about two years ago now, and I have to say I agree almost entirely with Tyler Cowen's re-assessment of the thing. 

I was surprised by the book: it was not nearly as extreme as I was expecting. In fact, it lays out what to modern eyes are highly reasonable arguments for why the central planning that was dominating the world at the time was doomed to fail. His primary target was the extreme central planning of the fascist and communist states, but his arguments applied equally to the government-planned wartime economies of the Allied powers. 

The book I read immediately afterwards was one by J. M. Keynes. Many of those who currently cite the Road to Serfdom to back up their political views might be surprised to learn that Keynes shared Hayek's fundamental concerns. He agreed with the book's argument about the dangers of central planning; where he differed was in the degree of the response. That Keynes' proposed "middle way" is now considered to be at the Left end of the spectrum speaks volumes about how much society has changed in the past 70 years.

Moreover, that Hayek's predictions failed to materialize is a testament to the degree to which we've internalized many of his arguments in the book. I would argue that the same can be said for Marx. The extremes that both men were railing against no longer exist as credible threats to our society, despite what some will have you believe. In re-reading these texts, their arguments would almost seem quaint were it not for the recognition that the problems were, at the time, very real. 

The flip side to all of this is that this particular book has lost much of its relevancy to the problems we are dealing with today, much in the same way that many of Marx's writings are of little use in addressing contemporary issues. That may not please the self-styled radicals at either end of the ideological spectrum, but for the rest of us it is very good news indeed. 

The world is a strange, strange place

This, from a quick scan of the news: 

- President Evo Morales knees a political opponent in the groin during a soccer match.

- The Philippines bans off-key national anthem singing

- Vietnam introduces state-run Facebook knock-off. "You have a friend request from: The Politburo"

- Rent-a-friend

Thursday, 30 September 2010

Promises, promises...

Paragraphs to ponder, from Karl Smith. Although I've had this point explained to me many times, it never hurts to reflect upon how interconnected and, ultimately, fragile our socio-economic structure really is: 
"All things financial are ultimately promises.
Promises, however, matter. Ultimately they matter because promises are how we coordinate people to make stuff that is bigger and better than any one person could make alone. If we couldn’t make promises to each other we could never build factories, homes, cars, etc. In truth specialization would all but collapse and the modern economy would cease to function.
Many economists like to pretend that the economy functions on the basis of trade. The baker makes bread and trades with brewer who makes beer. But, this isn’t how the real world works is it? The real world is full of promises.
When the baker wants beer he give the brewer a promise. When brewer wants bread he gives the baker a promise. If they don’t trust each other very much they trade in government promises, that’s called legal tender or money. When they trust each other a lot they trade in private promises, that’s called credit.
I have occasionally received gifts in appreciation for my lectures but mostly I receive a big chunk of promises at the end of every month. I use those promises to meet other promises that I have made. And, with the promises I have left over I can get other things that I might want for the month. I keep some of my promises stored away, as a promise to myself.
In the old days when even trust in the government was low promises took the form of metal. For most people the metal had little value but they knew someone else might want it so it was good enough. Today, trust is high. Our legal system is strong and most promises are just bits in a computer system, a little electronic maker that says society promises resources to John Doe. Promises are the foundation of our economy.  That’s why when promises go bad, as they did in the sub-prime crisis, the whole economy goes bad. That’s why some of [us] think the government needs to make some new promises. We are running short."

Wednesday, 29 September 2010

The Autumn of our Discontent

Adam Posen, of the Bank of England's external monetary policy committee, is now convinced that the Bank needs to act fast to avoid a prolonged period of Japanese-style economic stagnation. He argues that the accumulating evidence suggests that the downside risk to doing nothing far outweighs the risks of inflation.


When the overwhelming bulk of pressures in the economy are disinflationary, and when the level of output and employment is clearly likely to be below potential for an extended period, it is right for central bankers to take the additional negative effects of protracted recession on trend productivity growth and on capacity into account.

Is Posen right? I haven't a clue. But he does raise one point which I think is worth noting: there's more at stake here than simply a bit of lost productivity growth and economic capacity:

Let us not forget that it was sustained high unemployment and austerity, the sense that governments were unresponsive to average people’s dire economic conditions, which led to the rise of extremist intolerant parties in pre-war Europe
I've used this historical reference a number of times, but it is an admittedly extreme example. Posen is right to use the language of "let us not forget" as this is merely a reminder - not a prediction of what is to come. Nevertheless, the point is well taken. Last year, Rory wrote a great piece on the brewing summer of discontent: the seething popular anger in the aftermath of the financial crisis and the demand to do something. 

Thankfully, some of the worst predictions have not come to pass. But the danger has not disappeared; a casual scan of the recent news reveals as much. The US has its own backlash in the form of the surging Tea Party movement. The British Labour Party just recently elected Ed Milliband as their leader, indicating a sharp tack to the left. In both cases, these shifts are likely to be politically counter-productive. But in both cases, I read this as a giant "Fuck You" to the ruling consensus that has dominated Anlgo-American policymaking since the late 1990s. 

Granted, prolonged recessions do not necessarily result in deep social unrest. From my (limited) knowlege of Japan, it does not appear that over a decade of economic stagnation has resulted in major upheavals in society. I suspect that this has much to do with the structure and characteristics of Japanese society, however. And it should be pretty clear by now that Europe is definitely not Japan.

To borrow the text from Rory's post last year:

"This poses obvious risks to political stability and commerce. It also constrains the options available to policymakers, making beggar-thy-neighbor actions such as the imposition of trade barriers, subsidization or nationalization of industries and currency devaluation more likely. History tells us that these domestic political considerations, particularly in the developing world, risk reinforcing the downward economic spiral, as policymakers appease factions and fail to reach coordinated regional/global programs. They also risk, particularly in the case of currency devaluations, setting off a [chain] reaction of competitive responses that, in the absence of regional cooperation, ultimately destabilizes the system as a whole."
So it's clear that while inaction is not an option, the kind of response that the political leadership provide matters even more. The G20 proved to be surprisingly successful in coordinating a strong response to the crisis itself, but that level of cooperation is starting to fade in the aftermath as leaders re-focus domestic priorities. The recent signs of a looming "currency war" are a worrisome case in point. 

What we may be facing, then, is a prolonged period of discontent. The only solution is to avoid political posturing and short-termism and take the necessary steps to restore healthy economic growth. These steps may end up being painful or risky but, as Posen rightly points out, the downside risk to doing nothing at all is far too high.    

(photo: Reuters)

Tuesday, 28 September 2010

Readables

Interesting, if superficial, profile of Paul Krugman's recent economic writings. Provides yet more confirmation for why I rarely bother to read them.

Soooo, does this mean Republicans oppose lending to small businesses? Politics: what fun!

Why football (soccer) is a bad business: irrational capital. Proposed solution: ownership by fans.

The voodoo economics of the TV/movie business

Yet more evidence of China moving up the value chain: a collaboration with Japanese companies in computer microchip production.

How to help people in developing countries and make a wicked profit while you're at it.

Thursday, 23 September 2010

Intermission

Posting has been light of the last week or so as I make adjustments for a recent change in my career path. As a result, most of my recent post ideas are currently stuck in draft format - a variety of scattered thoughts lacking coherent direction. (Although really, what else is new?)

Things should return to business-as-usual in the next week or so. In the meantime, feel free to submit any ideas you have for topics you would like to see discussed.

Wednesday, 22 September 2010

Sentence of the Day

From The Economist:

"....Indeed, the problem with the tax debate is not that Democrats and Republicans disagree, but that they mostly agree. Democrats think 98% of Americans should not pay higher taxes; the Republicans say 100% should not."

Thursday, 16 September 2010

Readables

From the previous week:

The biggest problem with Basle III

A conversation with Richard Dawkins and Sir David Attenborough

A conversation with Lee Kuan Yew, prime minister of Singapore for 25 years after its founding, reflecting on old age and the risk that Singapore's success will be taken for granted.

Globalization at work: Chinese factories that are moving up the value-added chain to stay competitive.

Are emerging market bondholders ignoring history?

Paul Krugman has a bone and will not let it go, no matter how confused his thinking may be. (To be fair, I think Sumner has Krugman's arguments about the link between currencies and surpluses completely backwards, but he addresses this here).

Summary of the state of world trade

"Science: it works." The auto X-prize winners