The G20 summit in Pittsburgh produced a consensus that, while complacency is dangerous and risks remain, the worst of the financial crisis/global recession has passed us by. So, what's next?
-World Bank President Robert Zoellick on life after the storm.
-Marko Dimitrijevic argues that the term 'emerging markets' is obsolete; the rising giants have arrived.
-Quickly shift your gaze from Germany to Ireland, where a hugely important re-do will affect Europe for decades to come.
-A sterling slide is good for Britain.
-Is China the developed world's new engine of growth?
Monday, 28 September 2009
Sunday, 27 September 2009
The Shrinking Giant Re-appears
Last week Rory asked as to the whereabouts of Paul Volcker - the elder economic statesman who has been flying unusually below the radar. Well, Volcker has re-appeared in the headlines to deliver a two-part message:
First, he has doubts about the White House's plan for fixing the financial system and is arguing that, while mostly positive, the plan risks making the moral hazard problem worse for large, interconnected institutions. This sort of contrarianism supports Rory's suspicions that Volcker has been less visible because he is not politically convenient. Nevertheless, his value-added to the Obama administration is to be a strong, independent and experienced voice. So if he is raising doubts about the plan publicly, the doubts should be addressed head-on, no?
Second, he seems to be inclined towards some sort of tax on transactions between financial institutions. I have already explained why I thought a Tobin Tax was a bad idea, but I now suspect that Volcker is referring to something different. Nevertheless, if his biggest concern is moral hazard then a transaction tax will not even begin to address the problem, no matter how effective it might be at achieving other objectives.
In other words: I'm confused.
Second, he seems to be inclined towards some sort of tax on transactions between financial institutions. I have already explained why I thought a Tobin Tax was a bad idea, but I now suspect that Volcker is referring to something different. Nevertheless, if his biggest concern is moral hazard then a transaction tax will not even begin to address the problem, no matter how effective it might be at achieving other objectives.
In other words: I'm confused.
Thursday, 24 September 2009
Links
One link, actually. To an article which, after a lovely introduction, provides the 12 lessons for becoming "a super serious chin stroking elder statesman foreign policy elite [in America]."
Without further delay, lesson #1:
Without further delay, lesson #1:
"Being “strong” on a given foreign policy subject is directly proportional to your willingness to blow people/things up, with as little hesitation as possible. Considering any other option betrays your weakness, indecision and inner Frenchman. Further, refusing to bomb a given country is always the equivalent of Chamberlain appeasing Hitler and such reticence will have similar results. Always."And so it continues. Happy reading.
Monday, 21 September 2009
Why the US Dollar Will Weaken
Predicting the future value of currencies is a tricky business.
For instance, about one year ago, as the US economy started heading down the toilet and investors of all stripes began to panic, one would have thought that the impending collapse of the US economy would be bad for the dollar. But not so. In fact it was the opposite: as the crisis spread, US dollar assets became a safe haven from all the other collapsing world economies. Why? Because the US economy is still the biggest, most open, and most liquid in the world.
Nevertheless, without being too specific, I would argue that we are likely to see a long-run weakening of the US dollar. Here are at least two big reasons why:
Changes in the US Economy
It took having to be beaten over the head with a rather large recessionary stick, but US policy makers have realized that the economic conditions that prevailed in the last decade or so should not be repeated going forward. I'm talking in particular about 1) low domestic US savings, and 2) the US's reliance on everyone else to make stuff, sell that stuff to America on the cheap, and invest the money earned from selling that stuff in US assets with a low rate of return. American financial institutions would then take that money and invest it in riskier assets, earning greater return, and making everyone rich.
That's an oversimplification, but you get the idea. Recognizing that there's a big downside to this state of affairs, Obama's top policy advisors have been advocating a shift in the US economic strategy. Larry Summers has been the most explicit, according to two authors from the Peterson Institute:
China's Investment Strategy
"You should be screaming if your life savings are in dollars."
That's the assessment from FT Alphaville after further evidence that China is trying to quietly tip-toe away from the US dollar - something that is hard to do when you own about 1.5 trillion (!) of them. Nevertheless, China is attempting to escape its "dollar trap" by directing state-owned firms to start investing in dollar-alternatives like commodities and commodity-related companies. As China starts selling US dollar assets there will be more US dollars in the market, the value of any given dollar will go down and the currency will depreciate.
The long-term objective of this strategy is to eventually bring about the full convertibility of China's currency, the remnibi, and have it compete with (or replace) the US dollar as the world's reserve currency of choice. I say "long-term" because Beijing will need a long time to diversify away from the US dollar. But nevertheless, when you own 1,500 billion of another country's assets, your strategic decisions are going to be of some consequence.
Now, as I stated in the opening, currency predictions are fickle things. One could easily imagine a scenario where China's economy has an unexpected downturn and the safety of US assets will once again be appealing. Economic analysts are prone to overstating the long-run significance of current events. But caveats aside, the macro-level economic strategies of the two largest economies in the world suggest that the US dollar is going to weaken. Big time.
For instance, about one year ago, as the US economy started heading down the toilet and investors of all stripes began to panic, one would have thought that the impending collapse of the US economy would be bad for the dollar. But not so. In fact it was the opposite: as the crisis spread, US dollar assets became a safe haven from all the other collapsing world economies. Why? Because the US economy is still the biggest, most open, and most liquid in the world.
Nevertheless, without being too specific, I would argue that we are likely to see a long-run weakening of the US dollar. Here are at least two big reasons why:
Changes in the US Economy
It took having to be beaten over the head with a rather large recessionary stick, but US policy makers have realized that the economic conditions that prevailed in the last decade or so should not be repeated going forward. I'm talking in particular about 1) low domestic US savings, and 2) the US's reliance on everyone else to make stuff, sell that stuff to America on the cheap, and invest the money earned from selling that stuff in US assets with a low rate of return. American financial institutions would then take that money and invest it in riskier assets, earning greater return, and making everyone rich.
That's an oversimplification, but you get the idea. Recognizing that there's a big downside to this state of affairs, Obama's top policy advisors have been advocating a shift in the US economic strategy. Larry Summers has been the most explicit, according to two authors from the Peterson Institute:
"The US, [Summers] said, must become an export-oriented rather than a consumption-based economy and must rely on real engineering rather than financial wizardry. Tim Geithner, the US Treasury secretary, and other top officials have spoken similarly of rebalancing US growth.... Redirecting resources away from finance and consumption towards exports and investment will require relative price shifts, for which the dollar has to move down."Now, you could argue that the extent to which Summers & friends will be able to achieve this goal is limited. The US competitive advantage is, after all, in financial wizardry and not exports. Nevertheless, that this is the long-run goal of Obama's policymakers is a statement of intent that deserves to be taken seriously. And I think that it is being taken seriously by a country whose policies will likely have an even greater impact on the future of the dollar: China.
China's Investment Strategy
"You should be screaming if your life savings are in dollars."
That's the assessment from FT Alphaville after further evidence that China is trying to quietly tip-toe away from the US dollar - something that is hard to do when you own about 1.5 trillion (!) of them. Nevertheless, China is attempting to escape its "dollar trap" by directing state-owned firms to start investing in dollar-alternatives like commodities and commodity-related companies. As China starts selling US dollar assets there will be more US dollars in the market, the value of any given dollar will go down and the currency will depreciate.
The long-term objective of this strategy is to eventually bring about the full convertibility of China's currency, the remnibi, and have it compete with (or replace) the US dollar as the world's reserve currency of choice. I say "long-term" because Beijing will need a long time to diversify away from the US dollar. But nevertheless, when you own 1,500 billion of another country's assets, your strategic decisions are going to be of some consequence.
Now, as I stated in the opening, currency predictions are fickle things. One could easily imagine a scenario where China's economy has an unexpected downturn and the safety of US assets will once again be appealing. Economic analysts are prone to overstating the long-run significance of current events. But caveats aside, the macro-level economic strategies of the two largest economies in the world suggest that the US dollar is going to weaken. Big time.
Thursday, 17 September 2009
US Scraps Missile-Defense Plans in Europe
The US has reportedly decided to scrap its controversial missile-defense plans in Europe. This is a really big deal.
Despite the incredibly unfortunate timing of making the announcement on the 70th anniversary of the Soviet invasion of Poland (you always wonder why officials don't know these things, and cant wait ONE EXTRA DAY to make such a sensitive announcement; after all, isnt this what public relations/communications officials are paid to do, know these kind of things?).
Anyway, the implications of this decision are immense, positive and negative, but I for one applaud the US president. This is a really bold move that hits the 'reset' button with full force. But, more urgently, it is all about Iran, and I cannot imagine this decision was reached without some concrete assurances from Moscow that they will squeeze Iran in return.
These are the kind of major shifts in foreign policy we have been waiting for from the Obama administration. The ball is now is Moscow's court, and the Obama administration may come to find that the destiny of its foreign policy is now controlled less by itself, and more by the Kremlin.
Despite the incredibly unfortunate timing of making the announcement on the 70th anniversary of the Soviet invasion of Poland (you always wonder why officials don't know these things, and cant wait ONE EXTRA DAY to make such a sensitive announcement; after all, isnt this what public relations/communications officials are paid to do, know these kind of things?).
Anyway, the implications of this decision are immense, positive and negative, but I for one applaud the US president. This is a really bold move that hits the 'reset' button with full force. But, more urgently, it is all about Iran, and I cannot imagine this decision was reached without some concrete assurances from Moscow that they will squeeze Iran in return.
These are the kind of major shifts in foreign policy we have been waiting for from the Obama administration. The ball is now is Moscow's court, and the Obama administration may come to find that the destiny of its foreign policy is now controlled less by itself, and more by the Kremlin.
Labels:
foreign policy,
Iran,
Obama,
Russia
Wednesday, 16 September 2009
The Incredible Shrinking Giant
Jut a quick thought I have been tossing around in my head for the past few minutes...where the heck is Paul Volcker?
A giant of policy making, Volcker was brought into the Obama administration in an advisory role, but one that was thought to be an integral part of the US president's financial and economic policy formulation.
Almost ten months later, and he is seemingly MIA, minus the occasional statements that lead you to believe he thinks his boss is doing far too little in addressing the financial system's problems.
Which might just be the explanation for his absence.
A giant of policy making, Volcker was brought into the Obama administration in an advisory role, but one that was thought to be an integral part of the US president's financial and economic policy formulation.
Almost ten months later, and he is seemingly MIA, minus the occasional statements that lead you to believe he thinks his boss is doing far too little in addressing the financial system's problems.
Which might just be the explanation for his absence.
Thinking About Compensation
In the run-up to the G20 in Pittsburgh next week, the issue of compensation for top executives is becoming a hot-button issue. As financial indicators are improving (or becoming less worse), some banks' incentives schemes are returning to their old ways. Goldman Sachs, for instance, sparked a furor when they announced that they were on track for record bonuses earlier in the summer. Goldman's CEO has since wisely attempted to attack the practice of handing out massive bonuses, but the figurative pitch forks have been hoisted and the torches lit.
To properly argue that caps on executive pay would be good policy, I think that you would need to two things. First, some sort of philosophical argument which presents capping executive pay as a "public good" because of their special position in our economy. Given that the same argument was used, in reverse, to justify bailing out financial institutions, there's plenty of material to work with. Secondly, however, you would need to show that any such caps would be practical to implement and actually effective at curbing executive pay. Those kinds of arguments are a lot harder to find
To properly argue that caps on executive pay would be good policy, I think that you would need to two things. First, some sort of philosophical argument which presents capping executive pay as a "public good" because of their special position in our economy. Given that the same argument was used, in reverse, to justify bailing out financial institutions, there's plenty of material to work with. Secondly, however, you would need to show that any such caps would be practical to implement and actually effective at curbing executive pay. Those kinds of arguments are a lot harder to find
But none of this matters because, politically, this issue is a real winner. As Rory pointed out in the links below, France's Sarkozy is leading the charge, with the governments of Germany and many other countries behind him. The UK authorities are split on the issue, but Gordon Brown, ever in election-campaign mode, seems keen to appeal to popular sentiment. Moreover, as Michael Skapinker argues today, for the first time in a long while the gulf between Europe and America on bonuses has shrunk - the Obama administration is a lot more open to this idea than has traditionally been the case. This issue may very well be watered down at the G20 drafting table, but it's steaming in with a lot of momentum.
But let's ignore all of this silliness. A good friend of mine has sent me something far more interesting: Dan Pink presenting at TED.
But let's ignore all of this silliness. A good friend of mine has sent me something far more interesting: Dan Pink presenting at TED.
Rather than debate whether financials execs "deserve" millions in bonuses, Dan asks instead whether monetary incentives are an effective tool in the first place. According to considerable research in the social sciences, the conclusion is that people working on complex tasks with monetary incentives perform worse than those without monetary incentives.
Roll that conclusion around in your mouth a little. What does it taste like to you?
Cause to me it tastes like a wholesale rejection of the bonus culture on empirical, rather than emotional, grounds. If this conclusion can be applied generally, then not only can we argue that huge bonuses are potentially bad for the public good, but also for the firms themselves.
Less importantly, why is this conclusion so hard for me to accept?
Tuesday, 15 September 2009
Quick hits and pink picks: One year on from Lehman
-Stiglitz thinks the banking system is even more broken today than on the day Lehman died.
-A very good measure of business sentiment is how quickly business leaders are dumping their shares...well, they are really dumping. Bad sign??
-Martin Wolf's lessons to be learnt from Lehman's demise and its aftermath.
-A lot of political hot air has been expended over executive pay in the post-Lehman age, because its easier to grandstand over the compensation of a few top executives, than it is to actually reform the perverse incentives and regulatory failures that led taxpayers to commit such capital to the survival of the financial system.
One source of that hot air, Super Sarko, looks ready to sink a summit over a NON-ISSUE!! Reforming compensation practices is important, but please, there are far greater matters to address in Pittsburgh.
-A very good measure of business sentiment is how quickly business leaders are dumping their shares...well, they are really dumping. Bad sign??
-Martin Wolf's lessons to be learnt from Lehman's demise and its aftermath.
-A lot of political hot air has been expended over executive pay in the post-Lehman age, because its easier to grandstand over the compensation of a few top executives, than it is to actually reform the perverse incentives and regulatory failures that led taxpayers to commit such capital to the survival of the financial system.
One source of that hot air, Super Sarko, looks ready to sink a summit over a NON-ISSUE!! Reforming compensation practices is important, but please, there are far greater matters to address in Pittsburgh.
Monday, 14 September 2009
Scattered Thoughts on Gold
There has been a lot of noise recently about gold cracking $1,000/oz last Friday and what that means for investments, etc. We will likely have a lot more to say about that in some posts this week, but here are some quick thoughts:
1) I don't know anything about investments.
2) The $1,000/oz benchmark is making a lot of news because human beings like benchmarks and even numbers. The fact that gold moving from $999/oz to $1,000/oz results in headline news, whereas its moving from $983/oz to $984/oz would not, tells you a lot less about gold than it does about the financial press.
3) Today I saw a headline from the Moncton Times & Transcript that read: "Now is the time to invest in gold." Now - bearing in mind point 1)! - I suspect that by the time an article in a small-town syndicated newspaper is telling you to invest in X, it is no longer a good idea to invest in X.
1) I don't know anything about investments.
2) The $1,000/oz benchmark is making a lot of news because human beings like benchmarks and even numbers. The fact that gold moving from $999/oz to $1,000/oz results in headline news, whereas its moving from $983/oz to $984/oz would not, tells you a lot less about gold than it does about the financial press.
3) Today I saw a headline from the Moncton Times & Transcript that read: "Now is the time to invest in gold." Now - bearing in mind point 1)! - I suspect that by the time an article in a small-town syndicated newspaper is telling you to invest in X, it is no longer a good idea to invest in X.
Saturday, 12 September 2009
Quote of the Day
Brought to you by none other thannnnn...... Silvio Berlusconi!
"I sincerely believe I am by far the best prime minister Italy has had in its 150 year history (since unification in 1861),"And it actually gets better. Read the rest here.
Wednesday, 9 September 2009
Doing Business affirms the brighter side of crises
The World Bank has released its annual Doing Business report, which looks at the ease of doing business around the world.
Doing Business ranks economies based on 10 indicators of business regulation that record the time and cost to meet government requirements in starting and operating a business, trading across borders, paying taxes, and closing a business. The rankings do not reflect such areas as macroeconomic policy, security, labor skills of the population or the strength of the financial system or financial market regulations.
It is a narrow measure of a country's economic prospects, but an important one in a globalized economy, particularly for country's dependent on foreign investment and trade. Amidst the creeping protectionism, rapid decline in international capital flows, and poor credit availability of this crisis, you might expect such indicators to plunge. However, the World Bank found 2008/09 to be a record year of reform. Surprising? Perhaps not:
-Singapore was ranked #1 for ease of doing business for the fourth year in a row. This is no surprise (small, open, and highly integrated economy).
-Two-thirds of the recorded reforms were in low- and lower middle-income countries. This isn't that surprising either, as the threshold for these countries is typically low (any concerted reform agenda will drive these countries high up the ranking), and crises tend to disproportionately affect smaller, less-diversified economies heavily dependent on exports and commodity prices. Amidst these conditions, either external (IMF, WB, etc.) or electoral (regime change) factors tend to provide a strong impetus to reform.
-Rwanda was the biggest reformer across almost all indicators, a first for a sub-Saharan African economy, but again, not a surprise. President Kagame has vigorously promoted foreign investment to diversify the economy away from commodity exports (coffee and tea), and with donor funds accounting for almost 50% of the budget, Rwanda has a strong external commitment to reform.
The biggest point, but if you know your history perhaps the least surprising, was the following statement:
'The financial crisis has also prompted governments to act in areas where regulatory reform may be more difficult and require more time.'
I have noted on a number of occasions over the past year that despite the massive destruction caused, global crises also present the biggest opportunities for reform. Often, interests are realigned, reformers and technocrats elected, and economies and foreign investment regimes restructured. The latest Doing Business report reaffirms this trend.
So while there is justifiable pessimism over the protectionist slide of many major economies, we should take comfort in knowing that on at least one measure, globalization pushes on.
Doing Business ranks economies based on 10 indicators of business regulation that record the time and cost to meet government requirements in starting and operating a business, trading across borders, paying taxes, and closing a business. The rankings do not reflect such areas as macroeconomic policy, security, labor skills of the population or the strength of the financial system or financial market regulations.
It is a narrow measure of a country's economic prospects, but an important one in a globalized economy, particularly for country's dependent on foreign investment and trade. Amidst the creeping protectionism, rapid decline in international capital flows, and poor credit availability of this crisis, you might expect such indicators to plunge. However, the World Bank found 2008/09 to be a record year of reform. Surprising? Perhaps not:
-Singapore was ranked #1 for ease of doing business for the fourth year in a row. This is no surprise (small, open, and highly integrated economy).
-Two-thirds of the recorded reforms were in low- and lower middle-income countries. This isn't that surprising either, as the threshold for these countries is typically low (any concerted reform agenda will drive these countries high up the ranking), and crises tend to disproportionately affect smaller, less-diversified economies heavily dependent on exports and commodity prices. Amidst these conditions, either external (IMF, WB, etc.) or electoral (regime change) factors tend to provide a strong impetus to reform.
-Rwanda was the biggest reformer across almost all indicators, a first for a sub-Saharan African economy, but again, not a surprise. President Kagame has vigorously promoted foreign investment to diversify the economy away from commodity exports (coffee and tea), and with donor funds accounting for almost 50% of the budget, Rwanda has a strong external commitment to reform.
The biggest point, but if you know your history perhaps the least surprising, was the following statement:
'The financial crisis has also prompted governments to act in areas where regulatory reform may be more difficult and require more time.'
I have noted on a number of occasions over the past year that despite the massive destruction caused, global crises also present the biggest opportunities for reform. Often, interests are realigned, reformers and technocrats elected, and economies and foreign investment regimes restructured. The latest Doing Business report reaffirms this trend.
So while there is justifiable pessimism over the protectionist slide of many major economies, we should take comfort in knowing that on at least one measure, globalization pushes on.
Tuesday, 8 September 2009
Nifty Graphs: Public Debt
The Economist has a nifty graph on the amount of global public debt, projecting into the next couple of years. Check it out.
According to their maths, Iceland will have an average debt-per-person of over $107,000.00 in 2011. From a quick scan, that's almost twice as much per person as any other country (even the Italians!), and it amounts to almost 200% of their projected GDP. Ouch.
The figures for the United States don't actually look too bad for 2009, but it's that little "yearly rate of change" percentage that you want to keep your eye on.
Update: Click on Zimbabwe. Hilarious.
Thanks to Free Exchange for the pointer.
According to their maths, Iceland will have an average debt-per-person of over $107,000.00 in 2011. From a quick scan, that's almost twice as much per person as any other country (even the Italians!), and it amounts to almost 200% of their projected GDP. Ouch.
The figures for the United States don't actually look too bad for 2009, but it's that little "yearly rate of change" percentage that you want to keep your eye on.
Update: Click on Zimbabwe. Hilarious.
Thanks to Free Exchange for the pointer.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)