-The 'Tobin tax' is suddenly back en vogue; the FT offers a brief introduction.
-The NYT establishes a connection between the growth of independent media and increasingly open religious debate in Egypt.
-The Economix blog at the NYT asks whether congressional earmarks for public universities, surprisingly the largest recipients of so-called 'government waste', should be considered 'pork'.
-FP Passport offers an unconventional perspective on the al-Megrahi deal, and makes a convincing argument in favor of realpolitik. This short piece is blogging at its best: cutting through the noise to reveal the underlying complexity of international relations.
Monday, 31 August 2009
Tuesday, 25 August 2009
Bernanke reappointment II: the case against
In a FT op-ed, Stephen Roach presents 'The case against Bernanke.' Roach calls the reappointment 'short-sighted'; I think his criticism is too fixed on the now distant past.
He argues that despite Bernanke's aggressive and creative response to the crisis, his weaknesses and ideological orthodoxy helped create this mess:
It is as if a doctor guilty of malpractice is being given credit for inventing a miracle cure.
He goes on to say that the jury is still out on whether the Fed's crisis response will work in restoring growth and stability. This is a sensible argument, but surely Bernanke deserves the chance to finish the job. A more appropraite criticism would be that Bernanke's 'philosophical conviction' is ill-suited to influence and implement financial sector reform. But even on this point Roach's argument falls short, as Bernanke has demonstrated an incredible intellectual flexibilty and ability to depart from the pre-crisis orthodoxy.
A second-term should not be seen as rewarding the failures of pre-crisis Bernanke. Instead, it should be welcomed as a vote of confidence in a man transformed by the crisis and using every measure in his monetary toolbox (and making some new tools up along the way) to end it.
He argues that despite Bernanke's aggressive and creative response to the crisis, his weaknesses and ideological orthodoxy helped create this mess:
It is as if a doctor guilty of malpractice is being given credit for inventing a miracle cure.
He goes on to say that the jury is still out on whether the Fed's crisis response will work in restoring growth and stability. This is a sensible argument, but surely Bernanke deserves the chance to finish the job. A more appropraite criticism would be that Bernanke's 'philosophical conviction' is ill-suited to influence and implement financial sector reform. But even on this point Roach's argument falls short, as Bernanke has demonstrated an incredible intellectual flexibilty and ability to depart from the pre-crisis orthodoxy.
A second-term should not be seen as rewarding the failures of pre-crisis Bernanke. Instead, it should be welcomed as a vote of confidence in a man transformed by the crisis and using every measure in his monetary toolbox (and making some new tools up along the way) to end it.
Bernanke to be nominated to second term
US President Obama will reportedly nominate Fed chief Bernanke to a second term this week, ending intense speculation over the reappointment.
Bernanke still has to gain the approval of a not-so-friendly Congress, but after the obligatory grandstanding that will undoubtedly come.
This is the right choice in my opinion; I've often expressed here my admiration for the Fed's response to the crisis. But Bernanke's second term will be anything but a victory lap following his central role in preventing another depression. The challenges he will face in unwinding the Fed's extraordinary response to the crisis, exercising some measure of systemic oversight, and defending monetary policy autonomy may be no less difficult than the challenges his first term brought.
Bernanke still has to gain the approval of a not-so-friendly Congress, but after the obligatory grandstanding that will undoubtedly come.
This is the right choice in my opinion; I've often expressed here my admiration for the Fed's response to the crisis. But Bernanke's second term will be anything but a victory lap following his central role in preventing another depression. The challenges he will face in unwinding the Fed's extraordinary response to the crisis, exercising some measure of systemic oversight, and defending monetary policy autonomy may be no less difficult than the challenges his first term brought.
Monday, 24 August 2009
Links
- For those polled in OECD countries, universal health care gets good grades.
- Arguments for why Europe is a great place to visit, but it's better to live in America. I would add that surburban America may be more comfortable, but it's also more boring (i.e., not as good for young adults without families) and suburban sprawl has big downsides. I do think that his secondary point - that it's better to get rich in America, but be rich in Europe - is easier to defend.
- How the financial crisis has altered the relationship between China and the US. Good source of information, annoying font.
- Arsenal is off to a good start, but haven't really been tested thus far. Watch out for Burnley, though....
- Arguments for why Europe is a great place to visit, but it's better to live in America. I would add that surburban America may be more comfortable, but it's also more boring (i.e., not as good for young adults without families) and suburban sprawl has big downsides. I do think that his secondary point - that it's better to get rich in America, but be rich in Europe - is easier to defend.
- How the financial crisis has altered the relationship between China and the US. Good source of information, annoying font.
- Arsenal is off to a good start, but haven't really been tested thus far. Watch out for Burnley, though....
Friday, 21 August 2009
Friday fun: the zombies win
I know some people who are huge zombie movie fans. I am not. Night of the Living Dead is a classic, 28 Days Later was really great (the sequel terrible), and Shaun of the Dead hilarious. But lets not get carried away, people.
Anyway, having undoubtedly alienated some readers, I'll get to the point. Researchers in Canada have leveraged mathematics to determine that if zombies did exist, civilation would end as we know it. From the BBC:
'If zombies actually existed, an attack by them would lead to the collapse of civilisation unless dealt with quickly and aggressively...They say only frequent counter-attacks with increasing force would eradicate the fictional creatures.'
You might be wondering why I highlight this waste of valuable research dollars (of the loonie variety); because the excercise actually informs the spread and containment of real threats like the H1N1 virus. As the article notes:
'In some respects, a zombie 'plague' resembles a lethal, rapidly spreading infection. The researchers say the exercise could help scientists model the spread of unfamiliar diseases through human populations.'
Now back to the absurd: commenting on the study conducted by Professor Robert Smith? and colleagues (no folks, that is not a typo, the guy's name is actually Smith?, question mark included, and thereby destined from birth to ponder the stranger things in life), Professor Neil Ferguson, an advisor to the UK government on the spread of swine flu:
'My understanding of zombie biology is that if you manage to decapitate a zombie then it's dead forever. So perhaps they are being a little over-pessimistic when they conclude that zombies might take over a city in three or four days.'
If you carry one thing into the weekend, it should be this: if ever confronted by zombies, go straight for the jugular.
Anyway, having undoubtedly alienated some readers, I'll get to the point. Researchers in Canada have leveraged mathematics to determine that if zombies did exist, civilation would end as we know it. From the BBC:
'If zombies actually existed, an attack by them would lead to the collapse of civilisation unless dealt with quickly and aggressively...They say only frequent counter-attacks with increasing force would eradicate the fictional creatures.'
You might be wondering why I highlight this waste of valuable research dollars (of the loonie variety); because the excercise actually informs the spread and containment of real threats like the H1N1 virus. As the article notes:
'In some respects, a zombie 'plague' resembles a lethal, rapidly spreading infection. The researchers say the exercise could help scientists model the spread of unfamiliar diseases through human populations.'
Now back to the absurd: commenting on the study conducted by Professor Robert Smith? and colleagues (no folks, that is not a typo, the guy's name is actually Smith?, question mark included, and thereby destined from birth to ponder the stranger things in life), Professor Neil Ferguson, an advisor to the UK government on the spread of swine flu:
'My understanding of zombie biology is that if you manage to decapitate a zombie then it's dead forever. So perhaps they are being a little over-pessimistic when they conclude that zombies might take over a city in three or four days.'
If you carry one thing into the weekend, it should be this: if ever confronted by zombies, go straight for the jugular.
Brain-Gain
You have no doubt heard the term 'brain-drain' used to describe the flight of skilled and educated workers from developing countries. According to an FT article on Nigerian migrant flows, and nicely building off my 'Call of Home' and 'Go East Young Man' posts of late, many emerging market economies are now experiencing a 'brain-gain.'
Further, the FT has a whole online series analyzing the reconfiguration of migrant flows amidst the crisis, called 'Trading places: Migration in the crisis.' Check it out (or subscribe, i guess).
Finally, I've alluded to the fact that one of my pet-interests right now is the way in which the crisis is reorganizing economies of all scale. Migration is one such focal point that carries huge implications, from remittances to cuisine to development models.
Further, the FT has a whole online series analyzing the reconfiguration of migrant flows amidst the crisis, called 'Trading places: Migration in the crisis.' Check it out (or subscribe, i guess).
Finally, I've alluded to the fact that one of my pet-interests right now is the way in which the crisis is reorganizing economies of all scale. Migration is one such focal point that carries huge implications, from remittances to cuisine to development models.
Thursday, 20 August 2009
Yet More Ketchup Economics
Apparently Heinz has been benefiting quite a bit from the recessionary tendency to eat at home - and use more ketchup as a result.
Incidentally, the same article shows that our (temporarily?) retired blogging friend Patrick was dead-on with item #4 on his list of predictions for goods that will benefit from the recession.
Spam, spam, spam....
Incidentally, the same article shows that our (temporarily?) retired blogging friend Patrick was dead-on with item #4 on his list of predictions for goods that will benefit from the recession.
Spam, spam, spam....
Wednesday, 19 August 2009
Uncle Sam, Citi, and missed opportunities for financial sector reform
The FT ran a front-page story this morning on the feds' role in the resignation of former Citi CFO Ned Kelly in July. I am a bit surprised that it is a revelation that US regulators are intimately involved in Citi's management and strategy.
Nowhere does the paper imply that this was inappropriate or overbearing. But the story speaks to a larger sentiment within the financial services industry against reregulation and government intervention in the day-to-day strategy and management of TARP recipients. This is a curious sentiment indeed, and demonstrates the short-term memory of some of the biggest recipients of taxpayer dollars.
As the firms largest shareholder and financial backstop, why wouldn't US regulators exert authority over the woefully mismanaged firm? We crossed the threshold of moral hazard/government intervention long ago; moves like this should be applauded as an important step towards restoring credibility and competence to Citi and maximizing the return to US taxpayers.
I subscribe to Kenneth Rogoff's view that wholesale reregulation is needed, and it is increasingly clear that the Obama administration has missed the boat on financial sector reform. The financial crisis has largely subsided, some of the largest bailout recipients have payed back the taxpayer, and profitability has generally returned to the sector. The industry is more self-confident and increasingly hostile to government intervention.
Further, the congressional agenda is now overwhelmed by the debate over health care reform, to be followed by energy/climate change reforms ahead of the Copenhagen summit. This ambitious and controversial agenda leaves little room for substantive financial sector reform in 2009. Small measures on derivatives are likely because those are the easy ones. Giving the Fed systemic powers? Much, much harder, and it is unlikely the Obama administration will have the political time or capital to push through reforms of this magnitude. If it bungles health care, which at this moment seems likely, the Obama presidency will shrink, the democratic party will fracture, and the administration's financial sector reform agenda will be downsized.
Reformers from South Korea to Slovakia have understood that you should 'never waste a good crisis.' Unfortunately, the Obama adminstration might have done just that.
Nowhere does the paper imply that this was inappropriate or overbearing. But the story speaks to a larger sentiment within the financial services industry against reregulation and government intervention in the day-to-day strategy and management of TARP recipients. This is a curious sentiment indeed, and demonstrates the short-term memory of some of the biggest recipients of taxpayer dollars.
As the firms largest shareholder and financial backstop, why wouldn't US regulators exert authority over the woefully mismanaged firm? We crossed the threshold of moral hazard/government intervention long ago; moves like this should be applauded as an important step towards restoring credibility and competence to Citi and maximizing the return to US taxpayers.
I subscribe to Kenneth Rogoff's view that wholesale reregulation is needed, and it is increasingly clear that the Obama administration has missed the boat on financial sector reform. The financial crisis has largely subsided, some of the largest bailout recipients have payed back the taxpayer, and profitability has generally returned to the sector. The industry is more self-confident and increasingly hostile to government intervention.
Further, the congressional agenda is now overwhelmed by the debate over health care reform, to be followed by energy/climate change reforms ahead of the Copenhagen summit. This ambitious and controversial agenda leaves little room for substantive financial sector reform in 2009. Small measures on derivatives are likely because those are the easy ones. Giving the Fed systemic powers? Much, much harder, and it is unlikely the Obama administration will have the political time or capital to push through reforms of this magnitude. If it bungles health care, which at this moment seems likely, the Obama presidency will shrink, the democratic party will fracture, and the administration's financial sector reform agenda will be downsized.
Reformers from South Korea to Slovakia have understood that you should 'never waste a good crisis.' Unfortunately, the Obama adminstration might have done just that.
Why Communism Was Bound To Fail
Lessons from the NYT's food critic - a great article about restaurant etiquette and what it reveals about human nature.
Google was a good bet
Dealbook looks at Google's value, five years on from its much hyped IPO.
The bulls clearly won this bet.
The bulls clearly won this bet.
Monday, 17 August 2009
On Glecos
The idea of creating a Gleco (global economic council) is presented by Timothy Adams and Arrigo Sadun in this morning's FT. That's right: a Gleco.

The fact is, for this financial crisis at least, it was the policies and not the institutions which caused the problems. And its hard enough to get the key players to agree on what exactly were the problematic policies in the first place, never mind what to do about them. A Gleco will not fix this.
Take the FSB (no, not that FSB, the Financial Stability Board - the closest thing to an existing global economic council). With two dozen member states and another dozen reps from international bodies, I suspect that the participants of the FSB find that it's plenty difficult to reach agreement as is, thank you, and you can take your Gleco idea and stuff it away somewhere for later.
I think that's probably the way to go. Proposals of this sort make for interesting op-ed material, but in practical terms its more helpful to focus on improving our existing institutions. A Gleco is at best a colourful distraction.
In the realm of poorly-thought-out acronyms, surely the Gleco stands out among its peers. I can imagine a scenario where, in attempting to raise the idea of a Gleco with a co-worker, they instead become convinced that I am talking about a small green lizard, and that I have a speech impediment. It hardly inspires confidence, and confidence is what our financial system requires to function.
But never mind that, because the Gleco idea faces problems that extend beyond the liguistical. Adams and Sadun are promoting the creation of a new body that presides over other international organizations like the IMF, World Bank, the WTO and the rest. A supra-international body, if you will.
Adding layers to an already convoluted system seems like a strange approach to addressing global financial stability. I get that their aim is to provide an overall direction to things, to guide the various international organizations towards a coherent objective. But that's not likely going to play out in practice. Every organization that this Gleco oversees would have to have a seat at the table, in addition to the reps from nation-states.
And even if this Gleco is chaired by the G20, in ten or fifteen years a series of Unforeseen Events will likely result in membership that no longer represents the true balance of power - precisely the same argument they level against the IMF.
Adding layers to an already convoluted system seems like a strange approach to addressing global financial stability. I get that their aim is to provide an overall direction to things, to guide the various international organizations towards a coherent objective. But that's not likely going to play out in practice. Every organization that this Gleco oversees would have to have a seat at the table, in addition to the reps from nation-states.
And even if this Gleco is chaired by the G20, in ten or fifteen years a series of Unforeseen Events will likely result in membership that no longer represents the true balance of power - precisely the same argument they level against the IMF.

The fact is, for this financial crisis at least, it was the policies and not the institutions which caused the problems. And its hard enough to get the key players to agree on what exactly were the problematic policies in the first place, never mind what to do about them. A Gleco will not fix this.
Take the FSB (no, not that FSB, the Financial Stability Board - the closest thing to an existing global economic council). With two dozen member states and another dozen reps from international bodies, I suspect that the participants of the FSB find that it's plenty difficult to reach agreement as is, thank you, and you can take your Gleco idea and stuff it away somewhere for later.
I think that's probably the way to go. Proposals of this sort make for interesting op-ed material, but in practical terms its more helpful to focus on improving our existing institutions. A Gleco is at best a colourful distraction.
Thursday, 13 August 2009
Ketchup Economics - Light
For those who are interested in some lighter reading material on ketchup economics:
Malcolm Gladwell has this great history of ketchup and mustard which explores why the ketchup market is dominated by one brand (Heinz), but the mustard market isn't. It includes some really interesting stuff on how we understand and experience "taste."
(No puns this time!)
Malcolm Gladwell has this great history of ketchup and mustard which explores why the ketchup market is dominated by one brand (Heinz), but the mustard market isn't. It includes some really interesting stuff on how we understand and experience "taste."
(No puns this time!)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)