Monday, 31 October 2011

Occupy Montreal!

The Google works in strange and mysterious ways.


It has come to my attention that the fine folks over at Occupy Montreal have taken time out from their busy schedules of occupying and demanding things to pay a visit to IPE Journal: they have even linked to my whimsical scribblings on their blog. I am humbled. 


In particular, they are using this blog - no doubt after extensive research - as an authoritative guide to the Tobin Tax, or as it is known in French-Canadian, the "Tax Tobin:"

"Now, the propositions 
It was agreed that the Sunday event will be moved to the are between the tai chi sculptures, so campers occupying that area will be removed only for the event. “This is instead of asking the police to close the street. It’s easier”. 
Because temperatures are expected to go as low as 5°C, the assembly accepted to move the meeting to the Square Victoria metro (entrance on Rue Saint-Jaques). 
Saturday march at 3pm will go to the offices of the minister of Quebec, making stops whenever a bank gets on the way – to protest. It was suggested to support the Tax Tobin. A conversation went long, trying to understand what the tax tobin is all about; however, the amendment to “wait until tomorrow so people can inform themselves of what this tax is all about” was accepted. A decision will be made today at 11:30am. 
A child cries in the background."

Indeed.

Wednesday, 26 October 2011

Occupy Wheat Board!

I walk by the local franchise of the Occupy Wall Street movement on my way to and from work every day. It's got me thinking a little about the implicit and explicit assumptions that political movements make about the social value of some economic activities over others. For instance, it is fairly obvious that the OWS brigade is furious about bailouts for the wealthy financiers on Wall Street and beyond. This is very, very understandable.


But what do they think about bailouts for Canadian wheat farmers?


-----------------------------------------


As a general rule I try to keep away from commenting on all things related to the domestic politics of my home country, Canada - it's a poor career move and I usually don't know what I'm talking about anyway. That said, there has been quite a kerfuffle around here lately because the Conservative majority government has recently decided to ditch the Canadian Wheat Board's (CWB) monopsony over a huge chunk of the Canadian wheat market.


Before going any further, it will be helpful to understand what the CWB is: for starters, watch this awesome video (alternatively: the CWB's Wikipedia page or, if you're really sadistic, the CWB Act). In a nutshell: wheat and barley farmers are required to sell their stuff to the CWB, who in turn aggregates it and sells it in the market. In exchange, theoretically, the CWB provides economies of scale in the market and in marketing, resulting in a better deal for farmers. Also, there is no opt-out: it is illegal to sell your wheat any other way. Farmers who think they can compete in the wheat market on their own have to lump it. I should also add that the CWB only applies to wheat farmers in Western Canada - farmers elsewhere can do as they please.


Crucially, the CWB guarantees a minimum price to farmers for their wheat to protect against volatility. Since the CWB is backed 100% by the Government of Canada, in effect it is the taxpayer who guarantees the farmers the price of their wheat. The CWB is also entitled to carry out financial activities, like issuing bonds, debentures or other debt instruments to fund its activities. Any losses on those securities are - you guessed it - covered by the Government and paid for by the taxpayer.


So for various reasons the Government wants to ditch the CWB. The wheat farmers who benefit from the CWB are naturally upset by this, as are the employees of the CWB itself. The political opposition, as is their wont, are strongly opposed.


Here's a though experiment: what would happen if we replaced the words "Canadian Wheat Board" with "Big Banks" - what would happen then? Hmmmm. Let's review the parallels:
  • The big banks are directly protected against loss by the taxpayer via deposit insurance; the wheat farmers are directly protected against loss by the taxpayer through minimum price guarantees.
  • If there is a credit drought, the Central Bank lowers rates to make credit cheap again; if there is a flood of credit, the Central Bank raises rates to protect Bank profits from erosion by inflation. If there is an actual drought or flood affecting wheat farmers, they are bailed out by emergency funds set aside by the CWB.
  • Big banks can raise capital more cheaply because they are Too Big To Fail; the CWB can raise capital more cheaply because they are Too Wheatey To Fail and any losses are covered by the taxpayer.
  • Big banks are heavily supervised by independent agencies and extensive regulations; the CWB is... er... um...
Okay, so the parallels aren't perfect. But you get the idea: Heads and the banker/farmer wins; Tails and the taxpayer loses. Unless of course you're a Western Canadian wheat farmer who could actually be more competitive on your own, in which case everybody loses, except the CWB.


------------------------------


Which, I should stress, may still be the best possible outcome. It could well be that there are valid arguments for why the existence of the CWB is good for Canadians. But fundamentally my point is this: if you're prepared to defend the bailouts and implicit taxpayer subsidy of our big banks, you had better be prepared to explain why the role of finance in society serves such a critical economic function that it can be no other way. Similarly, if you're going to defend the bailouts and explicit taxpayer subsidy of the CWB, you had better be prepared to do the same.


I'm all ears.


On the other hand, if you hate bailouts, if bailouts make you angry - man oh man, go ahead and Occupy Wall Street, Occupy Wheat Board, hell, Occupy Grandma's House!


But, for the love of God, be consistent.*


-------------------------------


(*your humble blogger accepts that expecting rationality from partisans and protesters is akin to expecting rationality from YouTube comments, but, what the hell - a man can dream can't he?)

Thursday, 22 September 2011

Why I am not a political strategist


This letter to Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke is a curious thing. In it, senior Republican politicians ask Ben Bernanke to reconsider doing that thing they think he’s thinking of doing (he didn’t). I readily admit to being completely baffled by the underlying logic.
Now, I understand the political argument that additional quantitative easing, if it works, helps Obama win re-election. Republicans don’t want that. But that puts them in the position of politicians who are both a) meddling with the independence of the central bank, and b) hoping to profit from the misery of Americans. That seems a risky thing to put down in writing.
So that’s the cynical view. On other hand, if the Republicans actually believe that QE is bad for the American economy, then why write the letter? If they are correct, QE will fail and Republicans will ultimately benefit at the polls. Senior Republicans can still position themselves against monetary easing in a very loud and public way. But that is a very different kettle of pike from using your political power to try to influence the decision-making of an independent central bank. Why take that unnecessary risk?
Even if we set aside the shaky economics - is a weak US dollar really bad for the economy guys? really? - and incredibly short-sighted nature of this kind political opportunism, I fail to see where the upside is for Republicans. If someone can think of a good answer, do let me know…

Wednesday, 14 September 2011

You know, some days I really impress myself with... er, myself

In July 2010 I wondered aloud where the recovery was possibly going to come from. Recent months have provided the answer - it wasn't coming after all. 


I really wish I'd put my money where my mouth was.

Monday, 5 September 2011

The iPhone & iPad: Apple's Model T

"In 1909 I announced one morning, without any previous warning, that in the future we were going to be the "Model T," and that the chassis would be exactly the same for all cars, and I remarked: 'Any customer can have a car painted any color that he wants so long as it is black.' I cannot say that any one agreed with me."
- Henry Ford, automotive badass


When it comes to mobile telephony I am, by all accounts, a Luddite. And so it is only after great delay and prolonged mockery by my peers that I am finally looking into buying a smartphone.  But which one? An iPhone, a Blackberry, an Android phone, or one of the myriad of other options? Decisions, decisions.


While it may be that, worldwide, Android phones have the largest (and growing) market share, in North America and certainly among my friends and colleagues it is the iPhone that is dominant. Which is precisely my problem with the clever little device: everyone's bloody got one. The contrarian in me does not want to join the priesthood of the Mac. Besides, they are all exactly the same!


It is this last point which got me thinking about the Model T analogy. In 1913 Ford was nearly half of the car industry, while about 300 firms made up the other half. As we all now know, most of those other firms disappeared very quickly thereafter. Ford managed its dominance by creating a single product - the Model T - that was high quality and cheap. It managed the latter by completely integrating the production process, including the standardization of precision parts to a point where they were interchangeable - a novelty in the industry at the time. 


In much the same way, Apple has managed to dominate selected tech markets by focusing on creating a single product that is far superior to its rivals. The most obvious example is the iPod, which has blown all other mp3 players out of the water. Have you tried looking for rival mp3 players in the recent past? New models from rival companies simply don't exist. Everyone else gave up long ago. Much like Ford's integrated manufacturing process, Apple has dominated the market by creating an integrated in-house user experience by linking the iPod device to its iTunes media player and online store. They have built upon and expanded this business model with their iPhone and now iPad.  


The iModel-T approach seems to be working. In early August Apple briefly surpassed Exxon as the largest firm in the world, measured by market capitalization. In addition, the computer giant HP recently announced it was abandoning smartphones and tablet computing, effectively ceding the battle to Apple and choosing to focus on other business ventures with a more promising future. 


In a world where consumers are paralyzed by the paradox of choice, Apple makes life so much easier by riding to the rescue with a single, easy to use product. There are, however, key differences between the iPhone and Ford's flagship automobile of the early 1900s. For starters, the iPhone doesn't just come in black, but white as well(!) Secondly, unlike the Model T, the iPhone is very, very sexy. For Will Wilkinson, this beauty alone justifies the fact that Steve Jobs and the Apple team have become filthy, stinking, swimming-pool-full-of-Benjamins rich:


"The average American's life is not overfull with gracefully sleek design, to say the least, and in many ways our standards of living have not improved upon that of our parents. But Apple under Mr Jobs has offered the mass market dazzling technical progress with the sort of tastefully luxurious sheen usually reserved for the seriously well-to-do. For this many of us are grateful."


Will's quote illustrates another key difference between the iPhone and the Model T: whereas Henry Ford gambled that consumers would forgive the Model T's ugliness in exchange for paying less for a single, reliable product, Apple has succeeded in convincing consumers to shell out a premium for a beautiful one. 


Unfortunately for Apple, in my case it is precisely this cost premium that motivates my stubborn search for a more reasonably priced, Android-powered alternative. 

Monday, 29 August 2011

Not cool

Much of Asia, particularly Southeast Asia, is a humid place. Very humid. The kind of humidity that doesn't so much hit you like a brick wall when you walk outside, but instead creeps up on you all sneaky-like. One minute you're strolling along the street and the next minute (and it literally is the very next minute) your clothes are shifting like tectonic plates on the liquid layer of sweat that is suddenly coating your entire body. It is pretty gross.

It is therefore no wonder that the wealthier parts of the region are quite fond of their air conditioning. For a visitor not accustomed to the weather it can be a life saver. But for reasons that escape my understanding this fondness for AC has reached levels that, to my eyes, seem batshit crazy. I say that because in many cities in Asia, street-side shops, retailers and large shopping malls seem determined to blast as much AC into the atmosphere as possible.

The Economist has been reporting on this all summer in the context of Japan's energy crisis, but, as they rightly point out, wasting AC is not a particularly Japanese affliction. Last summer I was in Singapore and experienced this first hand: I would be walking along the sidewalk outside of a the entrance to a shopping mall and feel a blast of cold air, even though I was 10-15 feet from the entrance. Why? Because the mall had no doors of course. This, in 30 degree celcius weather and a hundred percent humidity. 

In another instance, the drug store across the street from my hotel had its automatic sliding doors locked open, their role replaced by a curtain of air conditioning that was flowing down from a 2-meter long AC unit mounted just inside the entrance. The mind boggles.

What is the reason behind this wastefulness? Is it an attempt to show off affluence? A tragically misguided attempt to correct global warming? Is it, as The Economist speculates, "culture?" I have no idea. But just know that for every energy efficient light bulb you install, every window you close, every programmable thermostat you install, there are businesses out there steadily undermining your efforts to reduce energy waste. And then some.   

Wednesday, 10 August 2011

There Follows A Rant


George Jonas appears to fall into the category of people who spend too much time writing and not enough time reading. I can’t find any other explanation for the absolutely gobsmacking combination of poor writing, intellectual laziness, and fear-mongering that is his op-ed piece in the National Post today.
Here’s a fun game, boys and girls: try counting the number of metaphors in this shambolic excuse for piece of writing. Go ahead! don’t be shy. I counted over ten. Check out this one paragraph:
“No one resisted it, liberal or conservative, Democrat or Republican. Ronald Reagan added $1.9-trillion to the national debt; George W. Bush dwarfed it by adding $6.1-trillion with his bold foray into the democracy-export business, while Barack Obama added his $2.4-trillion before finishing the first lap of his presidential run. Printing money is an addiction. Deficit is a drug, and death seemed not to impede Keynes’ abilities as a pusher. I doubt if the Tea Party’s provisions will end his long posthumous run — or ours.”
If the Muddled Metaphor Index is a guide, things are looking very bad indeed.
If that game doesn’t pose enough of a challenge, see if you can count the many examples of fallacious thinking found in this piece. Because the argument is so incoherent it is hard to say exactly, but it appears as though Mr. Jonas is attempting to blame Keynesian economics for the fall in financial markets, the euro-crisis, rioting in London, and the entire Arab Spring. That’s quite a claim, so you would expect it to be backed up by some strong arguments and clear analytical thinking.

You would expect wrong.  The fact of the matter is that of Keynes’ economics ol’ Georgey-boy does not appear to have a sweet clue. He probably has not read anything written by Keynes other than the singular quote around which he pivots his article. The extent of his rigorous research is revealed in this passage:

“A Marxist-trained scholar I knew encountered Keynes for the first time when he came to Canada in the mid-1950s.... He remained unimpressed by Von Mises and Hayak [check yo’ spelling, G-money - dh], but Keynes transported him in ecstasy. “Imagine the elegant simplicity,” he told me. “Lord Keynes discovered that if we deny ourselves things we live poorly, and if we deny ourselves nothing, we live well.”

“Are you sure that’s all there is to it?” I asked.
“Yes, yes.”
Seriously George? You asked some random Marxist scholar to summarize Keynes in a single sentence and used that as the premise for your analysis? That is breathtaking intellectual laziness. It is no wonder this piece makes no sense.
But I’m willing to bet this little anecdotal gem was included just so that Jonas could segue into a sentence that begins: “In Soviet-style Keynesian countries...” That is nonsense. Keynes was fiercely opposed to state-controlled economies and his thinking reflected that - his General Theory was precisely an attempt to find an alternative to both communism and the economic ruin of the 1930s. The same holds true for Mr. Jonas' examples of government spending over the years, many of which are not examples of Keynesian economics in any way, shape or form.
But detailing these errors by quoting Keynes’ actual writings would be a waste of time: Mr. Jonas clearly does not care whether our economic problems were caused by Keynesian economics, a perversion thereof, or a whole complex range of other factors. He clearly does not care for accuracy of any kind – this is an ideological tirade within which history, facts and logic have no part to play. Frankly, I’m surprised that he did not somehow weave in a reference to Hitler and Islamo-fascists, for good measure. 
This kind of writing poisons the discourse and makes us dumber. I really hope that the next time Mr. Jonas decides to write an opinion piece on a topic about which he is completely ignorant, he would do the world a favour, step away from his e-typewriter, and go read a bloody book.

Monday, 8 August 2011

Let's Review


  1. U.S. Congress threatens to not make good on U.S. debt
  2. S&P downgrades U.S. debt
  3. Market actors respond by panicking and buying more U.S. debt 
These three phrases speak volumes about our current political and economic environment, not to mention the role and relevance of institutions like legislatures, central banks, and credit rating agencies in shaping market outcomes.
Disturbing? Yes. Inconsistent? Not in the least.

Friday, 29 July 2011

"Policy Failure on a Massive Scale"

I'm about to head off on a blissful long weekend in the woods, and thank God. Civilization has been a real drag for the last little while. I've noticed that even the tone of even more usually reserved commentators has changed to hand-waving and yelling from the rooftops. Take Ryan Avent's post from yesterday on The Economist's Free Exchange blog, which pretty much sums up everything I feel about the situation right now:

"MAYBE everything will turn out all right. One shouldn't forget that possibility. As each day passes, however, frustration grows. Leaders in America and Europe are dallying with failure on an epic scale. They are constrained by dysfunctional institutions, it's true. In Europe, the architecture of the currency union is far too underdeveloped to weather a crisis of the current magnitude. In America, the creaking machinery of the legislature is ill suited to settlement of big questions on a short time frame amid divided government. But it's no longer sufficient to blame inadequate policy responses on institutions alone. America and Europe are flailing because their leaders are failing. They seem to be too small for the tasks at hand, too petty, and too myopic.
...

Again, it's not like the correct policy path is incredibly complicated. Here, I'll sum it up in three quick steps:
  1. Don't cause a major crisis.
  2. Do spend more and tax less for the next year or so.
  3. Do spend less and tax more after that.
See? That's really easy!"
He's not kidding - it is really easy. Look, the New York Times has even laid out it for you in this awesome little interactive graph. Go ahead, time yourself: see how long it takes YOU to solve the deficit.
Have a lovely weekend. 

Thursday, 28 July 2011

Recommended Debt Ceiling Reading

- James Surowiecki on why we should smash the debt ceiling.


- Why there was never going to be a surplus. A sample:
"Basically, in the grip of careless enthusiasm about the economic future, we borrowed $3 trillion from bond markets and handed it out to citizens in rough proportion to how rich they already were. In the middle of a recovery. This is not a useful thing for the government to do."


- If you haven't seen it already, this interview with Larry Summers is superb, and I found his contrast between working for Obama and Clinton very interesting.


- Oh look, here is Larry again!

Tuesday, 26 July 2011

Friends Don't Let Friends Publish Rambling Op-Eds

One of the reasons I'm back to blogging is that it is highly therapeutic; it provides me an outlet to vent when venting is a better alternative to hair-pulling, gnashing of teeth, wailing, or similar types of activities that annoy my co-workers deeply.


For instance, take today's op-ed in the FT by Alan Greenspan. Now, I'm not a compulsive, Krugman-esque Greenspan-basher like some (Paul Krugman, for instance). But I defy anyone to read this and come away with any understanding of what the former Federal Reserve Chairman is trying to say. Here's my effort:
  1. Capital buffers have a cost as well as a benefit.
  2. The general public are foolish sheep.
  3. Private actors make risk decisions; public actors clean up the mess when they get it wrong.
  4. Private actors got it wrong; financial calamity ensued.
  5. Public actors, regrettably, intervened to clean up the mess; moral hazard ensued.
  6. Sufficient capital buffers would, by definition, have prevented financial calamity and, by extension, the spike in moral hazard.
  7. Public actors are therefore encouraging bigger capital buffers.
  8. Bigger capital buffers are bad.
  9. A debate will occur.
End.

-------

To step away from snarkiness for a moment, there are some very valid points in this piece (particularly about the negative side-effects of higher capital buffers on wealth creation). But taken as a whole, it is an incoherent mess. Not to mention his blithe disregard for the increasingly frequency of financial crises and the enormously negative wealth effects associated with those, too. I am left scratching my head at the FT editors who let this one slip through the cracks. 


Actually, on second thought, maybe they've deliberately done the world a service.

And Now Back To Our Regularly Scheduled Programming....

Let's face it: from a political economy point of view it is basically a blogger's wet dream out there right now: the Arab world just vom-chucked all over its autocrats, the Eurozone's leadership are engaged in a Guinness World Record-seeking attempt to kick the biggest can ever down the road and the political representatives of the United States are holding the global economy hostage while they debate whether they should pay for things they've already agreed to pay for. How can I resist? 

Intermission is over. Get back to your seats. 

Game on.


Thursday, 9 December 2010

"What is this Land Rover of which you speak?"

In his April 2009 article for Vanity Fair (no longer fully available), Michael Lewis told the story about how Iceland's banking system basically imploded during the financial crisis. One of my favourite stories from the article is the one he tells about the fate of the country's many Land Rovers.

Presumably because they are a great tool for hauling fish across the Icelandic tundra, Land Rovers were a popular item for the small island nation. They were even more popular as the result of the availability of cheap financing during the pre-crisis boom in credit. The problem was, this cheap financing was provided in foreign currency; the interest rate for euros, pounds and dollars was far lower than that for the domestic currency, the krona. This is all fine and good if your salary is paid in euros, pounds and dollars, but in fact most people in Iceland are paid in krona. 

When Iceland's economy went down the crapper, the value of the krona went with it. Since the value of their income had just plunged relative to the value of their debts, many civilized citizens of Iceland were forced to make one of two choices:
  1. Attempt to pay back their car loans in salted cod
  2. Do something crazy
Many chose the latter. There follows a brief representation of what I assume was a typical telephone call between an Icelandic bank and its client on the subject of overdue car payments in 2008:


"Icelandic Bank: Dear Mr. Ragnar Hjalrnarsson, the monthly payments on your Land Rover are 3 months overdue."


Mr. Hjalrnarsson: *panting furiously, having just run for cover*


"Iclelandic Bank: Mr. Hjalrnarsson?"


*KABOOOM*


"Mr. Hjalrnarsson: Land Rover? What is this Land Rover of which you speak?"
FIN

The fine folks in Iceland had resorted to blowing up their Land Rovers to avoid paying them back. Seriously. This is a country that, in 2008, still had a GDP-per-capita of over $52,000.

Why am I re-telling this story? Because the exploding Land Rover is a great metaphor for a currency mismatch: the situation wherein debts are denominated in a different currency than the income used to pay down those debts. Currency mismatches can exist not just for individuals, but for entire economies at the macro level. But since economies can't go around blowing up Land Rovers whenever it comes time to rollover their debts, the consequences can be quite severe. 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The most recent example of this phenomenon was in parts of Eastern Europe, particularly the Baltic states, way back in 2007-8. Countries like Latvia, Estonia, Hungary, etc... had a large number of loans outstanding to European banks (i.e. denominated in euros). Many of these debts were also short-term and needed to be rolled over right smack in the middle of the financial crisis (see a more detailed explanation in this old post). That proved problematic, to say the least. As a result, parts of Eastern and Southeastern Europe were among the hardest hit economies in an economic crisis that originated somewhere else.

The currency mismatch is not a problem specific to our most recent financial crisis, however; here is economist Morris Goldstein, speaking in 2007: 
".... [S]erious currency mismatch has been a feature of every major emerging-market currency crisis of the past dozen years. It was there in Mexico in 1994–95, in the Asian crisis countries in 1997–98, in Russia in 1998, in Brazil in 1998–99 and 2001–02, in Turkey in 2001–02, and in Argentina in 2001–02.... [C]urrency mismatch provides the best explanation we have for why large exchange rate depreciations in emerging economies have had such costly growth effects. When financial liabilities are mostly denominated in dollars or in other reserve currencies while assets and revenues are mainly denominated in local currency, then a large depreciation of the local currency will result in balance sheet problems that ultimately cause economic growth to nosedive."

Here is Brad DeLong:
"The decade of the 1990s was marked by the sudden emergence of international financial crises. In a typical such crisis, a sudden loss of confidence in the value of a country’s currency by international currency speculators was followed by a rapid rise in the value of foreign currency—in the exchange rate—the threat of large-scale bankruptcies of banks and firms, financial panic, and a sharp severe recession. These crises hit in the Mexican peso crisis of 1994-1995. Then followed the far-reaching East Asian crisis of 1997-1998. The decade ended with crises in Brazil, Turkey, and Argentina."

The currency mismatch is not merely a modern creature - oh no. In the period of unfettered capitalism that characterized the late 19th and early 20th centuries, "hot money" was flowing into what we would now call emerging markets: Southeast Asia and South America. There were quite a few financial blow-ups involving currency and maturity mismatches - the Barings crisis of 1890 being the most famous.

In other words, we need to recognize that the risk of a currency mismatch contributing a major financial meltdown is present in just about every period in which we see capital flowing easily across borders. This leads me to ask one simple, juvenile, question:

Why why why why WHY?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

With all this history, why hasn't anyone learned their bloody lesson? Why do we continue to see, to this very day, the potential for instability caused by currency mismatches present - and growing - in a variety of markets. I can think of several factors that play a role:

 1) Access - pretty straightforward: you need easy access to international capital markets. This has been easier during certain periods of time (pre-1914, the Great Moderation of the 1990s-2000s, etc) and in certain regions (for instance, small EU members have direct access to foreign lending from other EU members due to the membership requirement for open capital accounts).

2) Import requirements - it is unlikely that many exporters or banks will accept the Papua New Guinea kina in an exchange for the sale of goods & services, for instance. Small economies with non-reserve currencies need to use foreign currencies to purchase the things they need, or borrow the funds they need. This can lead to debts in those same foreign currencies.

3) Lack of trust in the local currency - often domestic borrowers will seek outside financing if the local currency has a history of high inflation, political meddling, or exchange rate volatility.

4) weak domestic capital markets - sometimes domestic borrowers simply cannot raise money domestically. There are any number of elements to this, including: restrictive local banking regulations, lack of expertise, or lack of appetite (see #3).

5) Behavioural/psychological element - it is hard to resist cheap money. Look at the subprime real estate crisis in the United States and you can see how difficult it is for people to resist borrowing irresponsibly (often from irresponsible lenders). The people in Iceland basically did the same thing, and got burned when interest rate on the loans shot up. People tend to overestimate their ability to predict future events. 


6) ...what have I missed?

One argument I'm not buying is lack of awareness. As illustrated above, the challenge of currency and maturity mismatches is not new. Policymakers know and appreciate the dangers associated with a country (or many of its citizens) borrowing in foreign currency, particularly for the short-term. But sometimes the problem is an inability to stop hot money inflows & outflows - see the point about access above - and the costs associated with markets who are perceived to have overly-restrictive measures in place for investments.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Why am I bothering with all of this? It is because, even though the crises I've mentioned above are mostly old news, the challenge posed by hot money inflows is as topical as ever. This is part due to the expansionary monetary policies adopted by the United States and other large developed economies to stimulate recovery. I discussed this back in April with this atrociously-titled post, but if anything the trend has become more pronounced in the period since then.

The recent IMF global markets monitor suggests that capital inflows to emerging markets continues to surge, led primarily by portfolio flows to liquid debt and equity markets. In many parts of the world (including parts of Latin America and Asia), the levels of inflows are reaching pre-Lehman levels. It is important to emphasize that this is not foreign direct investment (i.e. the money isn't there for the long-haul).

India is seeing heavy capital market inflows, again mostly in equities and mostly portfolio inflows. China is also trying to keep a lid on domestic credit growth and just recently capped the amount of lending by domestic banks.

In fact, many emerging markets are toying with capital controls as a way to limit volatility. Brazil has done so, and there is speculation (so far un-founded) that Malaysia will follow suit. Brazil was even somewhat successful in getting pro-capital control language in the G20 communique from Korea ("practical tools to overcome sudden reversals of flows," anyone?). The large exporters will also continue to keep large foreign exchange reserves as a buffer - a policy that turned out to be rather justified in recent years, despite the distorting effects it has on global imbalances and the huge opportunity cost.

All of this suggests that the dangers associated with currency mismatches and rapid capital inflows have not gone away. Quite the opposite. Large inflows may be justified in the current environment of strong emerging market performance, but our ability peer into the future is limited. We do not know what is coming next.

We do not know who will be blowing up their Land Rovers next.

Friday, 26 November 2010

Discouraging Thought of the Day: Perception vs. Activism

David Brooks, writing in the NYT on the centennial of Leo Tolstoy's death:

"As a novelist, Tolstoy was an unsurpassed observer. But he found that life unfulfilling. As he set out to improve the world, his ability to perceive it deteriorated. Instead of conforming his ideas to the particularities of existence, he conformed his perception of reality to his vision for the world. He preached universal love but seemed oblivious to the violence he was doing to his family."

Well. THAT's discouragingly accurate.

You can have clarity of observation, or you can set out to change the world, but not both simultaneously. It's the quantum physics of social activism.

Of course this applies not only to activists but do-ers of all kinds. As Cohen rightly suggests, the memoirs of political leaders tend to be skewed not (simply) because of attempts at whitewash, "but because they’ve been engaged in an activity that makes it impossible for them to see it clearly. Activism is admirable, necessary and self-undermining." Go watch The Fog of War if you doubt this.

This is also what occasionally makes business leaders very poor judges of economic policy (see here, for example).

But this is very bad news indeed for newly-minted grad students who are setting out to change the world.

Hmmm...

Best to start a blog instead.

Wednesday, 17 November 2010

Readables

- About a week old, but this is one of the best pieces I've read in a while. Follow-up is here.

- The, um, wanker-bankers have conned the Biffo Bunch

- Quantitative easing, explained. The Ben Bernank does not come off well

- Here is a better explanation of QEII. Here is another

- In related news, core inflation falls to record low.

Tuesday, 9 November 2010

Yeah, What Brad DeLong Said

In case you missed it, Bob Zoellick, the head of the World Bank, was pontificating in the FT this week about the merits of returning to some sort of gold peg for currencies. DeLong, in his typically understated fashion, shoots him down hard.

Without passing any particular judgement on Zoellick's mental faculties, I think it's fair to say that suggesting a return to the gold standard in any format is a bad idea no matter who is suggesting it. But like some form macroeconomic acne, the idea of the gold standard keeps popping back up in periods of stress. For example, see my comments on Gillian Tett's misguided op-ed in the FT last year.

At the time I argued that, using the same logic, an economy run by squirrels would use an acorn standard. Why? Because they like nuts, silly. This analogy is even more apt that I had initially realized: much like humans and gold, squirrels spend a lot of time and energy scurrying around gathering up acorns - only to promptly bury them back underground.

Where the analogy breaks down is that acorns actually have an intrinsic value (nutrition), whereas gold does not have much intrinsic value at all. Its skyrocketing price is the result of investors (and here I'm quoting DeLong again) "using gold as a speculative asset and a hedge. They are not using it [as] a medium of exchange, a unit of account, or a safe store of nominal value."

As if this weren't damning enough, a return to a gold peg wouldn't even address the global imbalances problem. It would merely shift it around: US and European central banks own some 50% of the world's gold reserves. Hmmmmm. One suspects that if Saudi Arabia was the dominant world economy, we might be hearing ideas about an oil standard. This at least would have the added benefit of being a highly liquid asset. (HA!)

Seriously folks: this is gauling. All the more so because the gold standard is one of those rare phenomena in economics where it's not a theoretical debate. We've tested it out. It doesn't bloody work.

With so many potentially bad ideas floating around about how to fix the world economy, there's absolutely no reason why we need keep discussing the one we know for sure will be a disaster. 

UPDATE: Zoellick clarifies his comments: "Gold is now being viewed as an alternative monetary asset. This is not the same as a gold standard,” said Mr Zoellick. “Gold has become a reference point because holders of money see weak or uncertain growth prospects in all currencies other than the renminbi, and the renminbi is not free for exchange. So, in relative terms, gold is appealing to people who ask where should I put my money. It is a hedge against uncertainty.”

Well alright. Nevermind then, Bob: I forgive you. But just so we're clear: "a hedge against uncertainty" is not the same thing as an alternative monetary asset, mmk?

Thursday, 7 October 2010

Hayek's Road to Serfrom

One of the hot topics of the week is evaluating the merit of Hayek's Road to Serfdom. I read this book about two years ago now, and I have to say I agree almost entirely with Tyler Cowen's re-assessment of the thing. 

I was surprised by the book: it was not nearly as extreme as I was expecting. In fact, it lays out what to modern eyes are highly reasonable arguments for why the central planning that was dominating the world at the time was doomed to fail. His primary target was the extreme central planning of the fascist and communist states, but his arguments applied equally to the government-planned wartime economies of the Allied powers. 

The book I read immediately afterwards was one by J. M. Keynes. Many of those who currently cite the Road to Serfdom to back up their political views might be surprised to learn that Keynes shared Hayek's fundamental concerns. He agreed with the book's argument about the dangers of central planning; where he differed was in the degree of the response. That Keynes' proposed "middle way" is now considered to be at the Left end of the spectrum speaks volumes about how much society has changed in the past 70 years.

Moreover, that Hayek's predictions failed to materialize is a testament to the degree to which we've internalized many of his arguments in the book. I would argue that the same can be said for Marx. The extremes that both men were railing against no longer exist as credible threats to our society, despite what some will have you believe. In re-reading these texts, their arguments would almost seem quaint were it not for the recognition that the problems were, at the time, very real. 

The flip side to all of this is that this particular book has lost much of its relevancy to the problems we are dealing with today, much in the same way that many of Marx's writings are of little use in addressing contemporary issues. That may not please the self-styled radicals at either end of the ideological spectrum, but for the rest of us it is very good news indeed. 

The world is a strange, strange place

This, from a quick scan of the news: 

- President Evo Morales knees a political opponent in the groin during a soccer match.

- The Philippines bans off-key national anthem singing

- Vietnam introduces state-run Facebook knock-off. "You have a friend request from: The Politburo"

- Rent-a-friend

Thursday, 30 September 2010

Promises, promises...

Paragraphs to ponder, from Karl Smith. Although I've had this point explained to me many times, it never hurts to reflect upon how interconnected and, ultimately, fragile our socio-economic structure really is: 
"All things financial are ultimately promises.
Promises, however, matter. Ultimately they matter because promises are how we coordinate people to make stuff that is bigger and better than any one person could make alone. If we couldn’t make promises to each other we could never build factories, homes, cars, etc. In truth specialization would all but collapse and the modern economy would cease to function.
Many economists like to pretend that the economy functions on the basis of trade. The baker makes bread and trades with brewer who makes beer. But, this isn’t how the real world works is it? The real world is full of promises.
When the baker wants beer he give the brewer a promise. When brewer wants bread he gives the baker a promise. If they don’t trust each other very much they trade in government promises, that’s called legal tender or money. When they trust each other a lot they trade in private promises, that’s called credit.
I have occasionally received gifts in appreciation for my lectures but mostly I receive a big chunk of promises at the end of every month. I use those promises to meet other promises that I have made. And, with the promises I have left over I can get other things that I might want for the month. I keep some of my promises stored away, as a promise to myself.
In the old days when even trust in the government was low promises took the form of metal. For most people the metal had little value but they knew someone else might want it so it was good enough. Today, trust is high. Our legal system is strong and most promises are just bits in a computer system, a little electronic maker that says society promises resources to John Doe. Promises are the foundation of our economy.  That’s why when promises go bad, as they did in the sub-prime crisis, the whole economy goes bad. That’s why some of [us] think the government needs to make some new promises. We are running short."